The garlic knots are some of the best I’ve ever had. We love coming here and ordering by the slice for the family. Pickleroni is a must try! We love the juke box and pool too. Great atmosphere, fun, and delicious dinner
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Vicky Tran
A Slice of Heaven in Middletown!
I've been on a quest for the perfect slice, and I'm thrilled to report that Slice Pie in Middletown is a strong contender for the crown.
The pizza itself is a masterpiece. The crust is the perfect balance of crispy and chewy texture that holds up beautifully to the generous toppings. The sauce is tangy and fresh, and the cheese is high-quality, melting into a glorious, golden blanket. Each slice feels like a taste of authentic, old-school pizzeria magic.
And then, there are the garlic knots. I cannot stress this enough: The garlic knots are absolutely phenomenal and a non-negotiable, must-get item. They're baked to a soft, golden perfection. They arrive warm and fragrant, and you'll find yourself reaching for one after another. Seriously, don't leave without trying them.
Overall, Slice Pie is a local gem. The food is incredible, the staff is friendly, and the atmosphere is exactly what you'd hope for in a local pizza shop. If you're in Middletown, you owe it to yourself to stop in.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ashley Gilkison
Pizza is the best around by far highly recommend!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Pepperoni Pizza
Tim Morgan
Great crust, great sauce, great atmosphere. Recommend.
Bridget McComas
We had amazing service! Literally brought a baseball team in to feed. No one left hungry and there was a great selection for the boys. Thank you for saving the day!
Amanda Schirmang
Our entire baseball team flooded The Slice Pie on a lazy Sunday afternoon between games and the waitress took care of us promptly and with a smile. Food was excellent; wings, cheese bread, pizza, and salads. Gave our players full run of a side room that probably wouldn't be open at that time of day, was a real nice experience in Middletown, OH.
Mike Wert
Delicious pizza, great dive bar!
Christopher Cridlebaugh
This is my favorite place for pizza and cold drinks. i love the atmosphere and kindness of the employees, truly a great find.
Virginia kozee
The atmosphere here is peaceful no rushing the food is put of this world good and so is the service.
Ty Koons
Great food, great prices, great service! All around a great experience!
Smells bad,poor service, charging a cover when the bar is nearly empty, burnt pizza, broken machines, need I say more.
Jason Brooks
Tried 3 different slices. All 3 were great plus the girl at the bar was gorgeous
Jacki Luck
First, the staff, Jamie Zoe and friends 🧡, you will feel right at home here. Secondly, there is NO better pizza in Ohio. We drive an hour to get to it and love it every time. Great job, Shane and Brandon
Isabella Rose
this place has gone down hill. quality of food and service is just not good. plus i saw a rat when i was dining in. they also don't have a lot of the things on the already small menu.
The garlic knots are some of the best I’ve ever had. We love coming here and ordering by the slice for the family. Pickleroni is a must try! We love the juke box and pool too. Great atmosphere, fun, and delicious dinner
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
A Slice of Heaven in Middletown!
I've been on a quest for the perfect slice, and I'm thrilled to report that Slice Pie in Middletown is a strong contender for the crown.
The pizza itself is a masterpiece. The crust is the perfect balance of crispy and chewy texture that holds up beautifully to the generous toppings. The sauce is tangy and fresh, and the cheese is high-quality, melting into a glorious, golden blanket. Each slice feels like a taste of authentic, old-school pizzeria magic.
And then, there are the garlic knots. I cannot stress this enough: The garlic knots are absolutely phenomenal and a non-negotiable, must-get item. They're baked to a soft, golden perfection. They arrive warm and fragrant, and you'll find yourself reaching for one after another. Seriously, don't leave without trying them.
Overall, Slice Pie is a local gem. The food is incredible, the staff is friendly, and the atmosphere is exactly what you'd hope for in a local pizza shop. If you're in Middletown, you owe it to yourself to stop in.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza is the best around by far highly recommend!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Pepperoni Pizza
Great crust, great sauce, great atmosphere. Recommend.
We had amazing service! Literally brought a baseball team in to feed. No one left hungry and there was a great selection for the boys. Thank you for saving the day!
Our entire baseball team flooded The Slice Pie on a lazy Sunday afternoon between games and the waitress took care of us promptly and with a smile. Food was excellent; wings, cheese bread, pizza, and salads. Gave our players full run of a side room that probably wouldn't be open at that time of day, was a real nice experience in Middletown, OH.
Delicious pizza, great dive bar!
This is my favorite place for pizza and cold drinks. i love the atmosphere and kindness of the employees, truly a great find.
The atmosphere here is peaceful no rushing the food is put of this world good and so is the service.
Great food, great prices, great service! All around a great experience!
Restaurantji Recommends
Smells bad,poor service, charging a cover when the bar is nearly empty, burnt pizza, broken machines, need I say more.
Tried 3 different slices. All 3 were great plus the girl at the bar was gorgeous
First, the staff, Jamie Zoe and friends 🧡, you will feel right at home here. Secondly, there is NO better pizza in Ohio. We drive an hour to get to it and love it every time. Great job, Shane and Brandon
this place has gone down hill. quality of food and service is just not good. plus i saw a rat when i was dining in. they also don't have a lot of the things on the already small menu.
Best wings in Middletown!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pickle Pizza, Garlic Knots, Pepperoni Pizza, Pickle, Pie, Wings, Chicken Wings
Loading...