The Slice Pie

1300 Central Ave, Middletown
(513) 217-0051

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jennifer Weidel

Everyone there was very accommodating! We had a group of around 30 people, I called ahead and there was a miscommunication on my part, but Jamie was like we will get it done. The food was delicious, hot and fresh! Well worth the money we spent! We will definitely be back soon!

Cheryl Bowman

hadn't been here I yrs....got a French bread pizza, raw, falling apart, no seasonings, was awful. Wings were good. COOK YOUR PIZZA!!!! I won't be bk.

Spencer Howard

Didn't what to expect cause outside it looks like a small place but when you walk in you have great ambiance, nice sized bar, lots of open space, pool table, I even saw a couple claw machines. Saw a music event that happened with Michaelangelo Skero and insane poetry. BTW BEST PIZZA IN

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

ToDD White

Service was great, the battery got right to me and took me order. Pizza way way undercooked... Way... Could have been a decent slice if it had been in the oven longer. What came out was the perfect size slice, with a good cheese to sauce ratio, it was just limp and sad. Pretty sure the bartender had to wake up the cook in the middle of the afternoon to accommodate the 4 orders that were hanging from the printer. The bathroom isn't a murder scene, but it certainly smells like it. 2/10 would certainly not poop here., and wash up with your own soap and paper towels after, because there wasn't anything to use on my Saturday afternoon visit. Please read this and elevate the pizza to what it could be!!! I could overlook every else, that slice has potential!!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza

Patrick Moore (DistantBabble)

Great atmosphere, great bartenders, pizza was good, but 3 pickle slices on a pizza called a pickle-roni?!
A little disappointed by the lack of pickles... but it was good pizza.
Confirmed sasquatch free.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pickleroni Pizza

JJ Frierson

Foods was amazing! The bartender was incredible! But it's really dark in there and dusty. Even still, I'd go back for pizza and drinks at any time!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

Carla Preston

Love the ? pizza, garlic knots are pretty good too! Atmosphere is not for me, but will continue to order the food, pick up/deliver, and enjoy...

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: French Bread Pizza, Garlic Knots, Pepperoni Pizza

ola ann biggs

Me and Friend were there on Friday first time ever being there. We were the first people in there and there was some regular time together into the bar. I ordered water lemon water with lemon which took a half an hour for my lemon after we place your order which was just garlic knots, and two slices of pizza comes out a half an hour later with one slice of pizza and garlic knots which one garlic knots then I got my lemons I looked at her. I said where’s my pizza slice? She said what did you order? She totally forgot as we placed our order. There was two other sets of people that came in their drinks and placed their order. So she gave the food to the gentleman that came with me I said oh I’m so sorry. I’ve never bartended and Food at the same time. I said we was In there, so my friend ate his piece of pizza I ate the garlic knots finally two more times she has come up to me about my pizza and what I wanted on it which was just pepperoni I told my friend to eat his piece of pizza so it doesn’t get cold yelling for things that they were making nobody ,finally 55 minutes later I got my slice . She kept apologizing she was very unorganized. But she wanted us to pay that bill. Did management come up to me , no ! I been server I been new . But that was uncalled for it was one hour . When there only 5 people in bar it shouldn’t be that hard to mange . So for 50 min wait on food I lucky she remember the water .$17 charger . No talk to management. No sauce ! I won’t be back ….

Ralph Jividen

Good food and good entertainment. Needs more local music played

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Amanda Spencer

I had my pizza delivered through door dash and the actual dough was hard first time I ever ordered from there and will be the last 40 dollar pizza SMH

Eva Morgan

don't waste money on concert tickets it's such a disappointment I want my money back for my young buck ticket at the least this was such a s disappointing night. ended up a ghost town

Jerry Stout

The bartender .. well she was a sweet heart. The day I was in there someone walked in and tried to rob the place and she stood her ground and the perp ran off. God bless her for being so brave?

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

Maria Nicholson

Stopped here for lunch while on our Middletown adventure. Waitress friendly and service was great. Pizza was amazing.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza

Popular Media

Good food and great music. My favorite band is criticalkhaos

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Echo Ridge

Great pizza and salads! Highly recommend!

Loading...