So I literally just called the shop, wanting to order pizza and a sub, my first question to the elder lady was how much for delivery and then I asked if I picked up the pizza where would I be able to park to get to them cuz the square being shut off for parade of the hills. How rude. I order from there all the time and never have I ever been hung up on before my order was placed, also I kept trying to call back to place the damn order and she wouldn't answer. I've called back five times now. I will be reporting this.I can't even believe the customer service
Andrea Altieri
Came to Hocking Hills for the weekend. We needed to hit up the grocery store (shoutout to the Nelsonville Krogers) and decided to stop for pizza on the way back to our cabin. We got a 14” pie with three toppings. It was more than enough food for my wife and I with a bagged salad from the grocery store. It was so so good! I haven’t had a circle pizza cut into squares in a long time. The crust was tender and had a great crunch. The sauce was flavorful. The toppings seemed fresh. If we are ever out this way again, I would totally get pizza again!
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Casey Stage
Decent pizza, but really unprofessional establishment. It is like pulling teeth to get a pizza from them. They either never answer the phone or answer it and say it's instantly closed. I've been ordering pizza for decades and never had this problem with any other pizzeria.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Barbara Buongiorno
Solid pizza, subs & salads. There are a few booths, but this is mostly a take out pizza place.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Travis G
We are in the area working and decided to order here randomly. The one side of town was without power and when I called here they answered so I went ahead and ordered a large pepperoni and mushroom. It took a bit longer than what they said which is whatever idc. I didn't personally go and pick it up but my coworker said it was a hole-in-the-wall kinda place. I prefer that to be honest. The pizza was great. They are there to make good pizza not be fancy. What a pleasant surprise. Next time I'm gonna have to try the cheese!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
D. PLATT Jr
Best pizza ever made beans is an artist
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hooda Dooda
My wife (Shay) and I (Doug) had a fantastic time here. We ran into Bonnie a couple nights before trying to restaurant. She was a very friendly lady and did justice to talking this place up. The pizza was delicious. Thank you for making our honeymoon all that much better, Bonnie. We'll definitely be back during our next vacation.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Kathleen Rosser
Literally perfect this place is awesome
Penelope Taylor
My man and I ate there tonight. It was a wonderful atmosphere, GREAT FOOD, and even better service. We are from out of state and we will be back!
Absolutely, in my opinion, the best pizza place in this town
Dawn Jaroch
We were in town for our daughter's OU graduation and rented a house nearby Nelsonville. Pizza was the best option as we settled in for the weekend on Friday. Online reviews and recommendations from the rental property led us to Mama Renie's Pizza and we decided to order take-out. Our experience from the time the kind, patient person answered the phone until the last bite of the delicious pizza was all great! We were impressed that it was probably Mama Renie cutting the pizza our pie into serving squares at the time of pickup! The crust was delicious, the sauce was just the right amount and the pizza squares were perfect for a party like setting. If we ever stay in the area again, we will be sure to put this on the menu for our weekend!!!! Thank you.
Rebecca C
Absolutely fantastic food, friendly, fast service & very fair prices! If you're in the Nelsonville area, do yourself a huge favor and eat here!!! A+++
Sandy Byers
Mama Renies pizza is delicious’ and if we get delivery it’s aways fast. Very wonderful owners . I would recommend this pizza place! So good to have mama Renies in Nelsonville.
Jamie Marcum
Our second time here visiting hocking hills from Hamilton oh ,the pizza is awesome highly recommend
Delicious pizza. Great prices. Neighborhood feel.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
So I literally just called the shop, wanting to order pizza and a sub, my first question to the elder lady was how much for delivery and then I asked if I picked up the pizza where would I be able to park to get to them cuz the square being shut off for parade of the hills. How rude. I order from there all the time and never have I ever been hung up on before my order was placed, also I kept trying to call back to place the damn order and she wouldn't answer. I've called back five times now. I will be reporting this.I can't even believe the customer service
Came to Hocking Hills for the weekend. We needed to hit up the grocery store (shoutout to the Nelsonville Krogers) and decided to stop for pizza on the way back to our cabin. We got a 14” pie with three toppings. It was more than enough food for my wife and I with a bagged salad from the grocery store. It was so so good! I haven’t had a circle pizza cut into squares in a long time. The crust was tender and had a great crunch. The sauce was flavorful. The toppings seemed fresh. If we are ever out this way again, I would totally get pizza again!
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Decent pizza, but really unprofessional establishment. It is like pulling teeth to get a pizza from them. They either never answer the phone or answer it and say it's instantly closed. I've been ordering pizza for decades and never had this problem with any other pizzeria.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Solid pizza, subs & salads. There are a few booths, but this is mostly a take out pizza place.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
We are in the area working and decided to order here randomly. The one side of town was without power and when I called here they answered so I went ahead and ordered a large pepperoni and mushroom. It took a bit longer than what they said which is whatever idc. I didn't personally go and pick it up but my coworker said it was a hole-in-the-wall kinda place. I prefer that to be honest. The pizza was great. They are there to make good pizza not be fancy. What a pleasant surprise. Next time I'm gonna have to try the cheese!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Best pizza ever made beans is an artist
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My wife (Shay) and I (Doug) had a fantastic time here. We ran into Bonnie a couple nights before trying to restaurant. She was a very friendly lady and did justice to talking this place up. The pizza was delicious. Thank you for making our honeymoon all that much better, Bonnie. We'll definitely be back during our next vacation.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Literally perfect this place is awesome
My man and I ate there tonight. It was a wonderful atmosphere, GREAT FOOD, and even better service. We are from out of state and we will be back!
Restaurantji Recommends
Absolutely, in my opinion, the best pizza place in this town
We were in town for our daughter's OU graduation and rented a house nearby Nelsonville. Pizza was the best option as we settled in for the weekend on Friday. Online reviews and recommendations from the rental property led us to Mama Renie's Pizza and we decided to order take-out. Our experience from the time the kind, patient person answered the phone until the last bite of the delicious pizza was all great! We were impressed that it was probably Mama Renie cutting the pizza our pie into serving squares at the time of pickup! The crust was delicious, the sauce was just the right amount and the pizza squares were perfect for a party like setting. If we ever stay in the area again, we will be sure to put this on the menu for our weekend!!!! Thank you.
Absolutely fantastic food, friendly, fast service & very fair prices! If you're in the Nelsonville area, do yourself a huge favor and eat here!!! A+++
Mama Renies pizza is delicious’ and if we get delivery it’s aways fast. Very wonderful owners . I would recommend this pizza place! So good to have mama Renies in Nelsonville.
Our second time here visiting hocking hills from Hamilton oh ,the pizza is awesome highly recommend
Loading...