Mama Renie's Pizza
23 Public Square, Nelsonville
(740) 753-2116
Customers' Favorites
Pepperoni Mushroom & Sausage Pizza
Pepperoni and Sausage 14 Pizza
Garlic Bread with Cheese
Ribeye Steak Sub
Buffalo Chicken
Bread Sticks
Chicken Bacon
Italian Sub
Chef Salad
blt Pizza
Menu
Photos
+17 photos
+16 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Came to Hocking Hills for the weekend. We needed to hit up the grocery store (shoutout to the Nelsonville Krogers) and decided to stop for pizza on the way back to our cabin. We got a 14” pie with three toppings. It was more than enough food for my wife and I with a bagged salad from the grocery store. It was so so good! I haven’t had a circle pizza cut into squares in a long time. The crust was tender and had a great crunch. The sauce was flavorful. The toppings seemed fresh....
Decent pizza, but really unprofessional establishment. It is like pulling teeth to get a pizza from them. They either never answer the phone or answer it and say it's instantly closed. I've been ordering pizza for decades and never had this problem with any other pizzeria.
We are in the area working and decided to order here randomly. The one side of town was without power and when I called here they answered so I went ahead and ordered a large pepperoni and mushroom. It took a bit longer than what they said which is whatever idc. I didn't personally go and pick it up but my coworker said it was a hole-in-the-wall kinda place. I prefer that to be honest. The pizza was great. They are there to make good pizza not be fancy. What a pleasant surprise....
You May Also Like
The Mine Tavern - 14 Public Square
![]()
Bar & Grill, Dive Bar, American, Vegetarian
Rhapsody Restaurant - 18 Public Square
![]()
Fine Dining, American, Gluten-Free, Vegetarian, New American
Embrace Nutrition - 41 W Washington St
![]()
Family, Fast Food