Penny Lane Art Gallery and Cafe
109 S Main St, New Carlisle
(937) 679-5304
Customers' Favorites
Small Spinach Salad with Strawberries
Choice of Grilled Cheese
Scary Berry Iced Latte
Iced Coffee Flight
Breakfast Sandwich
Broccoli Salad
B E L T Panini
Avocado Toast
Mocha Blended
Bottled Water
Menu
Photos
+36 photos
+35 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
I go 1-2x weekly now that I’m in school to start my studying with a coffee and maybe a meal or treat. I got the Banana Pudding Latte over ice and the B.E.L.T. Panini for breakfast. I will 100% recommend these over and over again! The coffee is an acquired taste I thought I wouldn’t like, but I’ve gotten it 3 weeks in a row now! Highly recommend this place!
I don't know how they squeeze 5 to 7 people behind thr counter and yet get so much done, but they do!! I don't get out to New Carlisle too often but when I do I'll make sure I stop in. The no-bake cookies are legit. Each cookie probably weighs half a pound and they taste fantastic. The vibe check here is good.
Omg!!! Hidden gem!!!! This restaurant was recommended by a friend. So I had to check it out. Zero complaints! Excellent food. Excellent atmosphere. Excellent service! I will be going back!!!
You May Also Like
Franco the Foodie - 120 Jefferson St
![]()
Comfort Food, Italian, Southern
Taqueria Super - 306 N Main St
![]()
Mexican, Food Trucks
Lee's Famous Recipe Chicken - 303 N Main St
![]()
Chicken, Chicken Wings, Fast Food