Dawn and Jerry's Pizzeria

304 Ray Ave NW, New Philadelphia
(330) 339-1333

Recent Reviews

Shenna Haney

I love this place. I get lunch here all the time, the workers are so nice and the food is delicious.

Luke Shalosky

Super nice people, very delicious food. The chef salad is hands down the best around. Highly recommend.

kaley rabes

Very good pizza, Stromboli and salads. They tend to get busy if you choose delivery on weekend evenings. But worth the wait

John Creekpaum

We are from out of town, wanted some pizza to eat at a park with our 3 kids. Thought the Family Meal deal wasn't going to be enough for our family of 5, so I added an order of cheesy bread in addition to the boneless wingsThis was both foolish and wise. Pizza was amazing, floppy and cheesy and delicious. The cheesy bread was twice as big as I expected and was also delicious. Wings were tangy and tasty. Only thing I would have done differently was waiting longer to eat, the cheese was so gooey from being freshly made that my 3 y.o. struggled to eat it by herself.Definitely recommend this place if you are looking for pizza.

Courtney Melton

Just ordered an xl works pizza and garlic parmesan wings and buffalo wings the wings were good but that has to be some of the best pizza I've ever had! Anytime I'm in new Philadelphia I will be ordering again!

donicka smitley

we ordered food because we tried to show a group of friends how good this was..well after waiting 1 hour and 30 mins they never came! after calling they said oh yeah we got busy( like other pizza shops) and was told sorry. another 30 minutes they came and only brought half of my food! again called because my daughter is hungry and this was her food not being delivered was then basically told not their mistake it was all sitting there oh ok well what are you planning to do about this at 2hrs and was told oh how about we send a pop over.I said not acceptable and stated bad customer service! No I said Don't want pop just my food.They then closed for the night and refused to answer phone. Never brought my food and never came!! I will be calling my bank and reporting. Is this not stealing? I have never ever had an issue like this before

Mademe Cum

It was creamy and it made me feel good and made me C. U. M. ??

Henry Korns

Fast and courteous service my food has been excellent every time

David Smitley

We ordered a family meal was told it would be 45-50 min ended up being 90+ minutes and they forgot half the order. They said they would be right back with the rest of the order it has been another 40+ minutes and still no rest of the order. Called to see what was going on and was offered a free 2 liter

Alan Boring

Out of town first time trying their Pizza I give it a 6.8 out of 10 the crust was excellent. service was not the greatest

Ellen Hootman

The stromboli is wonderful.awsome.perfect amount of pepperoni an cheese great sauce.. an a sm...is alot... first time trying but will order again an the salads are wonderful also

Diosa Pj Nik

Absolutely amazing service food is amazing you get Best bang for your buck every time I order there I least have two days worth of food AMAZING!!!

Ron Lendon

Reside in New Philadelphia, their salads are ABSOLUTELY amazing along with other items (not a pizza family here). Miss the salads daily but after several months of ordering and the order being wrong, I decided to stop ordering. When the order was made correctly after the mistakeS, it was amazing. Honestly miss the food and still have not found another salad better in the county (when made correctly).

Deejay Sucher

we are new to town and ordered pizza somewhere else last week and asked for xtra cheese. they didnt even give us regular cheese it seemed. ordered you guys tonight and asked for xtra cheese and you certainly gave extra cheese. this pizza and cheese sticks have been so good! you guys are great and cheeeezy!

Lashawna Jackson

Staff is very friendly and informative. Amazing food at a great price! Highly recommend!!! Great job guys!!!

Load More