Mary Zifer's Pizza in New Philly

$$ • Pizza

145 2nd St NW, New Philadelphia
(330) 343-1188


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Recent Reviews

I ordered a unbaked pizza tonight for dinner I asked for extra cheese extra pepperoni and extra sausage and extra cheese sprinkles on top when I got home to put this in the oven it was a freaking masterpiece these guys definitely know how to make a pizza I think the girls name was Katie I hope that’s her name I wanted to give her a massive shout out this Is amazing!!!!!!

I ordered a salad and a pizza with sausage and pepperoni. Well I didn’t get my pepperoni on my pizza but they put 5 pieces on my salad. Also the lettuce pieces were in huge chunks. We had to put our own cheese on and cut our salad up. I mentioned on the phone I hardly order from this place and they failed to tell me they don’t take credit cards. Luckily I had some cash on me. They also didn’t tell me it comes with Colby cheese not mozzarella and when I went back in to full review

We asked for a gluten free pizza. For those who are celiac, the dough is gluten free but there is no special handling to prevent cross contamination. Not recommended. The crust on the other pizza was dry and hard as though it was baked yesterday. Not a good first visit.

More Reviews(63)


Monday Closed
Tuesday Closed
Wednesday 11AM - 10PM
Thursday 11AM - 10PM
Friday 11AM - 11PM
Saturday 11AM - 11PM
Sunday 4 - 10PM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.