Mary Zifer's Pizza in New Philly

Name: Mary Zifer's Pizza in New Philly
Address: 145 2nd St NW, New Philadelphia, Ohio, 44663, US
Telephone: (330) 343-1188
Price range: $
Rating: 4.4

$ • Pizza

Hours:
145 2nd St NW, New Philadelphia
(330) 343-1188

Customers' Favorites

Vinaigrette House Salad with Sour Dressings

Sweet House Salad with Sour Dressings

Meat Cheese gr Pepper & Mushrooms

Splash Meatball Sub with Cheese

Meat Cheese gr Pepper Pizza Sub

Meat Cheese & Mushrooms

Breadsticks with Cheese

Meat & Cheese Pizza Sub

Cheese & Green Peppers

Cheese Mushroom

Recent Reviews

4.4 (26)

Write a review

October 2023

This is still one of my favorite pizza places to frequent even after not living in New Philadelphia for almost 20 years.Cash or check only. Every pizza establishment I’ve been to with those options have been top tier good and Mary Zifer’s is in the the top tier of that top tier. I miss it already!

February 2023

Crunchy crust is really good. They use Colby cheese but have mozzarella if you want that instead. And they only take cash or check. Yummy pizza! I included a picture of their menu which is current as of 2/24/2023.

May 2022

First time to place an order, so I went to pick it up. At the counter I saw a carry-out menu & noticed there was only one in the clear acrylic display rack, actually asked if she had more. She said no but most people just take a picture of it on their cell phone. ☺️ Pizza flavor was good, but I didn't like the spicy sausage. I didn't know their crust was going to be so hard and it left a crumby mess. But, I would try them again. I'm all for supporting small businesses that...read full review

More Reviews(88)