“Awesome place to get pizza and wings. Probably best round I would say. Sometimes it's a wait when they are busy but well worth the wait. They ladies here take there time to get y ok ur order perfect and at a great price. If I could eat here everyday I would. Some of the best cheeses that just melt in your mouth along with great sauce and bread emm just THE BEST.Parking: Plenty of spaceKid-friendliness: They love kids.“
“This is still one of my favorite pizza places to frequent even after not living in New Philadelphia for almost 20 years.Cash or check only. Every pizza establishment I’ve been to with those options have been top tier good and Mary Zifer’s is in the the top tier of that top tier. I miss it already!“
“Good, not great, and there's nothing wrong with that either. I'm not going to rave about it but I'll definitely be back as I know they're consistent, and my favourite menu items are going to be exactly the same. Neat location and atmosphere that comes with it. Prices are reasonable, service can be hit or miss but I've never had truly bad service there either. All in all, Magoo's earns pretty much the most solid 4 I can give. Not a 5 star restaurant where you'll hear the word "Michelin" be used to describe anything other than a tyre, and that's all right. If you want some good old Americana Italian food or a decent pie, look no further.Kid-friendliness: Of course.Parking: Plenty of it.“
“We went here last Friday and had a great experience. The blonde brownie dessert we had was outstanding and I don’t usually eat that kind of stuff. It was busy but not too bad and we didn’t have to wait. I got a burger and it was juicy and really good. My wife got a pizza and they have a wood fired oven and she really liked it. We also got these really good cheese sticks that my kids also liked and they’re usually hard to please at restaurants. This will be our new spot when going down 77.“
“It's great, if you like very light sauce. The last time we said hey, we have been getting like missing sauce, just dough. So they asked if we wanted extra sauce. We said no just normal, but more than missing big blank dough spots lol. Well apparently we have to ask for extra sauce. it's weird, don't have this problem anywhere else....their salads are not typical pizza place salad, leaves a little to be desired, very small and priced like a medium salad, few toppings. Subs are great! Homemade taste!“