East of Chicago Pizza
205 Commercial Ave SE, New Philadelphia
(330) 364-0005
Customers' Favorites
Garlic Cheese Bread
Breadsticks
Salad Bar
Pizza
Menu
Photos
+26 photos
+25 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
We've tried several pizza places in New Philadelphia and have to say East of Chicago is the best we've had. When you order extra cheese, that's what you get. The toppings were fresh, and the pizza sauce was perfect...not overwhelming the taste of the other ingredients. Crust was delicious, too.
Buffet started at 4. We got there at 5 and there was no food. They brought 3 personal size pizzas out just as a party if 14 walked in (I found out from an employee that they had a reservation ). They grabbed up all the pizzas that were out. So we left hungry without finishing our meal instead of waiting for more food to come out. Total disappointment. We had to go buy dinner at the chicken place across the street after paying $25 there.
Always enjoy myself there. Treat me like they know me,personally we'll actually they do because I have been eating there for at least 20 yrs Thank you,East
Vegetarian options: I go in and as I am paying for my Buffet I just ask for no meat item pizza and in about 10 minutes here comes a smiley face with 1 or 2 pies lovin it
Vegetarian options: I go in and as I am paying for my Buffet I just ask for no meat item pizza and in about 10 minutes here comes a smiley face with 1 or 2 pies lovin it
You May Also Like
Brickyard Dining Co - 140 Commercial Ave SE
![]()
Pizza, American, Burgers, Family, Vegan
Bob Evans - 311 Graff Rd SE
![]()
Family, American, Comfort Food