New Riegel Cafe
14 N Perry St, New Riegel
(419) 595-2255
Customers' Favorites
Double Order of Ribs with Extra Sauce
Order and a Half Rib Dinner
Original New Riegel Bologna
1 2 BBQ Chicken and Fries
Chicken and Rib Dinners
Double Ribs Extra Saucy
BBQ Ribs and Fries
Chicken Dinner
French Fries
Ribs Dinner
Menu
Photos
+23 photos
+22 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Please stop trying to convince all of us that the sauce has not changed. We have been going there for over 40 years. The sauce is NOT the same. It’s watered down and definitely missing an ingredient which I am allergic to but I ate the ribs for 40 plus years anyway because they were that good. Now, no allergic reaction at all which tells me at least one ingredient is missing or it’s so watered down I don’t react anymore. We keep giving it “one more try” but the last...
I’ve been to the Cafe many years since I was a kid. Great place to be with friends and a laid back dinner! Highly recommended! Jerry and Cindy are the best hosts! Great people great food!
Ribs were cooked well. The sauce isn’t for me. The fries are okay and the side of bread was dry and inedible. Food came out real quick. Pretty sure everything is just sitting back there waiting to be served. Never got a refill on my drink. The moist hand towel was real nice.
You May Also Like
New riegel pub - 11 E Tiffin St
![]()
Bar, Cafe, Barbeque
Left Field New Riegel - 7889 W County Rd 10
![]()
Pizza, Sports Bar, Burgers
Plank Road Tavern - 236 OH-53
![]()
Bar & Grill, Pubs, Burgers