Alley Cat Subs & Pizza

340 Mt Vernon Rd, Newark
(740) 915-8001

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Bill Vista

Supports TRACY D HIGGINBOTHAM owner of Buckeye Lake Winery who’s convinced of FELONY 2ND DEGREE FELONIOUS ASSAULT- child victim.

Brianna Staar

So far we've gotten the pizza and subs and both have been fantastic! Definitely recommend!

Tori Powell

I’m happy they came back!!! So good!

Sara DeVere

We ordered from Alley Cat tonight for the first time and I would recommend it as a local, neighborhood joint! We met the owner who was very kind and helpful, and the pizza was great and reasonably priced. Looking forward to going back and trying the subs. They also serve great causes in our community, which I love. Definitely worth a try for your next pizza night!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mark Wolford

Came in looking for a salad and they didn't have any but they went out of their way to make a couple fresh with everything on it. Awesome service, excellent fresh food. Would recommend to anyone looking for great food that isn't a CHAIN restaurant. This place gives local business a good name!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sarah Tate

Tried this place for the first time tonight. Honestly so good, get sauce, crust. YUM We will be returning!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tyler Rose

The food looks amazing although I only ordered a salad it was delicious. If your looking for a pizza spot that has great people and food alley cat is the one!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Andrea Petty

This was my first time visiting alley cat pizza. The owner Steve, was awesome. Honestly the BEST Italian sub I have ever had! Also you can earn FREE alley cat t- shirts. I will definitely return. Steve works to strays, and I work with the, rescue, foster. So he asked me to include some pictures of some adoptables.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Vickey Richards

First time ordering from here I will definitely be back was one of the best pizzas I have ever had.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

william Harper

It states in their menu, the s'mores pizza comes with a crust and gram cracker crumbles.No crust just a ton of powered gram crackers. Extra meat is a must, you get nothing but nasty bread, if you don't. Definitely not worth 29 dollars for a bad sandwich and bad desert . Plus 11 dollar tip. Not worth it.

Food: 1

Recommended dishes: The Fancy Cat Sub, S'Mores Pizza

Emma Manroy

Wonderful people!Great pizza!?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

David Cable

Delish ous pizza good to go

Tyler Smith

I recently tried Alley Cat and I must say, their meatball sub is a game-changer! The high-quality ingredients and perfect blend of spices make them stand out.Besides the delicious food, the customer service was exceptional – friendly staff and a welcoming atmosphere. Cannot wait to try more of what’s on their menu.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Cheryl Lynn Meredith

Always amazing, thank you!

Chase Riffle

Alley cat subs and pizza is a fantastic Atmosphere And I really enjoy going there , always smiles and all my orders are cared for , if anything is wrong it’s always fixed I’m happy to say alley cat subs and pizza is one of my favorite casual spots to eat , they don’t pressure you , they let you take a long look at the menu and enjoy your experience, I recommend alley cat anywhere I go , much love to alley cat subs & pizza & the crew

Loading...