Alley Cat Subs & Pizza
340 Mt Vernon Rd, Newark
(740) 344-0368
Customers' Favorites
The Fancy Cat Sub
S'Mores Pizza
Menu
Photos
+11 photos
+10 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
I ordered a 16 inch pepperoni pizza and a 1/2 Italian sub, it was not only delicious but under $20. Very thin crust if that’s your thing. The pizza reminds me of the cartoon pizzas with the cheese pull. 10/10, will definitely be a regular customer.
This pizza is delicious. My boyfriend and I have ordered from here almost every week since we found out about it.
Not only is the pizza good, but I'm a sucker for cats and puns so the cat named pizzas like Tom Cat, Fat Cat, and Cat Tails just gives me a good chuckle every time I read the menu.
I'd also like to say the owner is awesome. He's been the one that hands us our pizzas when we go pick them up. He's been very accommodating...
Not only is the pizza good, but I'm a sucker for cats and puns so the cat named pizzas like Tom Cat, Fat Cat, and Cat Tails just gives me a good chuckle every time I read the menu.
I'd also like to say the owner is awesome. He's been the one that hands us our pizzas when we go pick them up. He's been very accommodating...
We ordered on New Year's Eve and doordash failed. The owner felt so bad and was so proud of his food. We went down and picked up our order. Amazing food. The pizza was great and the steak sub was perfect. Very friendly. Prompt. Great food
You May Also Like
Debra's Pizza - 318 Hudson Ave
![]()
Pizza, Italian, Salad
Little Caesars Pizza - 250 Granville St
![]()
Pizza, Fast Food, Chicken Wings
Shipp Brothers Brewing Restaurant & Taproom - 23 W Church St
![]()
Brewpubs, American, Burgers