I finally visited Gartmans for the first time. What a gem! We felt warmly welcomed in by the staff. ❤️ The selection of freshly baked delicious goods was larger than expected. We chose a maple and a chocolate cream stick. So good!!! We will definitely be back!!! Thank you for the excellent customer service!!!
Missy Bedwell
We had a cake and cookies made for my daughter and son in law’s baby shower. They were both done perfectly. The cake was beautifully decorated and adorable. The cookies were perfect and both were absolutely delicious. Definitely recommend to anyone looking for a local bakery.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sam Ferrell
I love the whole bakery, and everyone who works there is fantastic!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Victoria Weinrich
Always good at Gartman's?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Donuts
Mark Douglas Obenour
Nice little downtown bakery in Painesville. Close to Lifeline and DHS downtown. 💵 Dollar donuts 🍩 are yummy. Staff is personable and helpful! Like this little to go donut shop. We'll be back! 😎 Yum!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Beth Berndt
Small and cute. Friendly staff. Horrible tasting . The food was terrible. I got a loaf of sourdough bread. Got home 20 minutes later only to find out it has mold all over the top of it. Fuzzy Mold. The poppy seed roll was extremely bitter. Inedible. the klotchky had generic filling not real fruit. Not even jam or jelly just the kind of filling you would add to a pie. Just gelatinous goo … And covered in sugar. Like a tablespoon of sugar coated on the outside of each cookie. And the dough was extremely thick and dry. The donuts were OK. First time and last time. We will never go back. Just awful food.
Elizabeth Thornburg
My entire family gets our birthday cakes from here! They’re absolutely perfect, I’ve never been a cake fan until I had one from here! Not only was it delicious but it was gorgeous
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
Julie Moon
Old style bakery that takes you back. Pastries, cakes, pies, and breads like grandma, mom, and aunties used to make.
Maria Stebnicki
Yesterday I stopped in for the first time. Purchased cherry and blueberry muffins. The blueberry muffin was fresh and delicious. However, the cherry muffins were dry - not fresh tasting. Unfortunately, my first and last visit. Disappointed!
Larry Miller
I was in your donut shop this morning and I don't feel that that lady is at the counter is very friendly she wasn't very helpful at all I had an encounter with another customer but over her because she's saying that I was not very nice but I think I was very nice I just don't feel like I should have been treated the way I was when I was in your establishment she 0ver charge me on my order I been in here. Before and this same lady older blond hair didn't look like she wanted to be there I did not have a good impression of her sorry but if I was out of line I sorry but she never. Very to accommodating to my me as. A customer I always refer this Bakery to everyone that ask about a good bakery !plus after I got home I still figure she short change me another dollar I will consider that her top even tho she did not serve it sorry I was a inconvenience to your staff!
I did a cake decorating class yesterday and it was so fun! I really enjoyed the small format of the class because the teacher is a cake decorator at this bakery and it was awesome to have her around and assisting us. I went alone but it would be super fun to go with friends or your mom! I hope I can attend another event in the future.
Larry Burgett
Great bakery cakes are great for any occasion
Jacob Trenn
This is a fantastic little family owned bakery with a very cozy feeling. My family loves the cakes here and also the delicious and unique donuts!! We went early in the morning and the lady behind the counter was extremely friendly and kind!
Jennifer Burnette
I went to a cake decorating class! I had so much fun and learned so much. I’ve never decorated a cake before but will definitely be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ryan Young
They made my son’s first birthday cake and it looked and tasted amazing!
I finally visited Gartmans for the first time. What a gem! We felt warmly welcomed in by the staff. ❤️ The selection of freshly baked delicious goods was larger than expected. We chose a maple and a chocolate cream stick. So good!!! We will definitely be back!!! Thank you for the excellent customer service!!!
We had a cake and cookies made for my daughter and son in law’s baby shower. They were both done perfectly. The cake was beautifully decorated and adorable. The cookies were perfect and both were absolutely delicious. Definitely recommend to anyone looking for a local bakery.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I love the whole bakery, and everyone who works there is fantastic!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Always good at Gartman's?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Donuts
Nice little downtown bakery in Painesville. Close to Lifeline and DHS downtown. 💵 Dollar donuts 🍩 are yummy. Staff is personable and helpful! Like this little to go donut shop. We'll be back! 😎 Yum!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Small and cute. Friendly staff. Horrible tasting . The food was terrible. I got a loaf of sourdough bread. Got home 20 minutes later only to find out it has mold all over the top of it. Fuzzy Mold. The poppy seed roll was extremely bitter. Inedible. the klotchky had generic filling not real fruit. Not even jam or jelly just the kind of filling you would add to a pie. Just gelatinous goo … And covered in sugar. Like a tablespoon of sugar coated on the outside of each cookie. And the dough was extremely thick and dry. The donuts were OK. First time and last time. We will never go back. Just awful food.
My entire family gets our birthday cakes from here! They’re absolutely perfect, I’ve never been a cake fan until I had one from here! Not only was it delicious but it was gorgeous
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
Old style bakery that takes you back. Pastries, cakes, pies, and breads like grandma, mom, and aunties used to make.
Yesterday I stopped in for the first time. Purchased cherry and blueberry muffins. The blueberry muffin was fresh and delicious. However, the cherry muffins were dry - not fresh tasting. Unfortunately, my first and last visit. Disappointed!
I was in your donut shop this morning and I don't feel that that lady is at the counter is very friendly she wasn't very helpful at all I had an encounter with another customer but over her because she's saying that I was not very nice but I think I was very nice I just don't feel like I should have been treated the way I was when I was in your establishment she 0ver charge me on my order I been in here. Before and this same lady older blond hair didn't look like she wanted to be there I did not have a good impression of her sorry but if I was out of line I sorry but she never. Very to accommodating to my me as. A customer I always refer this Bakery to everyone that ask about a good bakery !plus after I got home I still figure she short change me another dollar I will consider that her top even tho she did not serve it sorry I was a inconvenience to your staff!
Restaurantji Recommends
I did a cake decorating class yesterday and it was so fun! I really enjoyed the small format of the class because the teacher is a cake decorator at this bakery and it was awesome to have her around and assisting us. I went alone but it would be super fun to go with friends or your mom! I hope I can attend another event in the future.
Great bakery cakes are great for any occasion
This is a fantastic little family owned bakery with a very cozy feeling. My family loves the cakes here and also the delicious and unique donuts!! We went early in the morning and the lady behind the counter was extremely friendly and kind!
I went to a cake decorating class! I had so much fun and learned so much. I’ve never decorated a cake before but will definitely be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
They made my son’s first birthday cake and it looked and tasted amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Donuts, Birthday Cake
Loading...