6 Best Greek Restaurants near Pickerington

“Recently I was driving through Pickerington and decided to get Greek Star for dinner. I lived in Pickerington around 12 years ago. Much to my surprise Greek Star was still in business, just a different location. I spoke with gentleman about my favorite dish I had many years ago. Unfortunately it wasn't available but he gave me a few samples of other amazing authentic food. I ended up getting a Gyro, egg plant dip with pita and he gave me some Greek fries on the house! All which were AMAZING! I HIGHLY recommend Greek Star. The food as not changed a bit! So delicious! Service was so friendly and kind and the new location is going to be perfect! I WILL be back!!!“

“First thing I absolutely love and talk about how king gyro has the best gyro and fries in Columbus!!! The only place I ever go to get gyros. But yesterday, I was absolutely disappointed in the tiramisu. It was my second time ever having tiramisu and the first restaurant that I had it at it was absolutely delicious. And I’ve had other desserts before, but this by far was horrible. It was mushy. It was soaked in coffee they didn’t just dip it like they should have. It was so much coffee that it dripped all over my bag and spilled out.“

“Good quality food, generous portions, always ready in 15-20 minutes. Friendly service also.“

“Stopped by for lunch because it was around the corner from where I was working today. Staff was very friendly. Food was terrific! Got the gyro meat with rice and it was delicious! Way more than I could eat in one sitting. Friend got gyro salad and said it was fantastic. Will definitely return when in town for work.“

“We went to have dinner last evening. They told us that the dinner is $15.99. They told us that the brisket wasn't included, but they were nice enough to serve us brisket from the lunch. On the way to check out at the counter, we pay extra for brisket per pound. Since they were nice to us, we didn't check the price (which we should've). The day after we were checking the price, it was way more than we thought it was. Lunch was $17, 99, and dinner was $15.99. When I called then I was told they person at the counter charged us $21, 99, which was WAY more than t were supposedose to charge. The person was firm on the price until I told him thathadave text from sababa of lunch, which was $17, 99, and we had din, er, which was $15.99. Of course, I was upset about him because he either didn't know the truth or lying out right that he didn't know they had a promotion yesterday for less price. (If you are working at the counter it's your JOB to know to charge your customers rightfully) If someone is upset on it than it's your job to calm them, not to get ANGRY on retaliation. He called his manager and after a long hold, for which I thought he discussed it with his counter person that what's actually going wrong, he told me that it's not a big deal and it's just $5 dollars, which was way more than that. Obviously, it pissed me off, and again, the manager got ANGRY in retaliation (which he shouldn't be) because both the customer service and the manager are NOT giving you the right information. In the last, he told us the correct amount to be refunded and HUNG UP ABRUPTLY. (Without apologizing or saying SORRY. As I said, FOOD is awesome, but the customer service from the counter SUCKS but the waitress is really NICE to provide us brisket. I would ask anyone if their is a discount price for the dinner ($15.99) and you are charged for regular lunch price (21.99), and the customer service is NOT accepting mistake. Wouldn't you be upset or mad about it? The manager would be angry about giving you a refund and hanging up abruptly without apologizing.“

“I had an amazing experience at My Big Fat Gyros! The food was absolutely top-tier—fresh, flavorful, and made exactly how you want it. The gyro was packed, juicy, and the homemade sauce really took it to another level. You can tell they don’t cut corners when it comes to quality.

The service was just as impressive. Friendly, fast, and welcoming from the moment I walked in. They made sure everything was right and treated me like a valued customer.

If you’re looking for great food with great service, this is definitely the spot. Highly recommend My Big Fat Gyros—I’ll be coming back for sure!“