Pastimes Ice Cream

115 N Elm St, Prospect
(740) 494-2450

Recent Reviews

Sort by
T. Jones {T. J.}

I have been going there as often as possible for the peanut butter milkshakes

Jamey Molihan

They should paint it .but everything else is awesome .

Dustin Culp

A small hometown dairy bar with a lot of love and commitment for their customers. It's hard to find places that don't cut corners anymore. But thus place definitely goes above and beyond with their food and dairy products. Highly recommended for anyone looking for a quick stop at lunch or dinner. These gals are amazing!

Rick Stephan

It's a nice drive along the river from Columbus to Prospect. And then you get some ice cream upon arriving.

Ron Sempier

Ordered a cherry milkshake and got a chocolate. Didn't realize right away. It was good, though.

Stevi Decker

The new owner is RUDE and DISRESPECTFUL! The ice cream is good but not worth the service you get, no trash can in site, and the incredibly high prices.

Karen Schirtzinger

The owner of this place is a TERRIBLE person just in general. She treats her TEENAGE employees like garbage and the customers not much better. She always thinks she doesn’t need customers to stay in business? Her words, not mine.

Julien Wesson

I have been there in summer 93’ …so many memories! 30 years later ice cream are still delicious ?

Natalie Steven

Since the change in ownership this is not an establishment you should support. The owner is rude, critical, and does not serve as an example for her staff. I hope she sees her reviews and makes some changes or I hope she gets shut down

Meagan Horn

It’s a shame you can’t give them zero stars! Outdated food/ice cream that the owner refuses to make right and they’re downright nasty people to begin with!

Elishia Pollard

If I could give them 0Stars I would. The owner is such a snotty lady that does not know how to treat customers or her employees.

bailey hunt

Owners are rude to customers and employees. Prices are outrageous now and it’s cash only. I won’t be back!

Dave Gwinner

This place is fantastic....you can get just about anything....Enjoy.....

Travis Wolford

Expensive, small portions, and ssllllloooowwwwww

DaOfficial1 “DaOfficial1” Beastie

Great food and the friendliest staff definitely will return

Loading...