I have been going there as often as possible for the peanut butter milkshakes
Jamey Molihan
They should paint it .but everything else is awesome .
Dustin Culp
A small hometown dairy bar with a lot of love and commitment for their customers. It's hard to find places that don't cut corners anymore. But thus place definitely goes above and beyond with their food and dairy products. Highly recommended for anyone looking for a quick stop at lunch or dinner. These gals are amazing!
Rick Stephan
It's a nice drive along the river from Columbus to Prospect. And then you get some ice cream upon arriving.
Ron Sempier
Ordered a cherry milkshake and got a chocolate. Didn't realize right away. It was good, though.
Stevi Decker
The new owner is RUDE and DISRESPECTFUL! The ice cream is good but not worth the service you get, no trash can in site, and the incredibly high prices.
Karen Schirtzinger
The owner of this place is a TERRIBLE person just in general. She treats her TEENAGE employees like garbage and the customers not much better. She always thinks she doesn’t need customers to stay in business? Her words, not mine.
Julien Wesson
I have been there in summer 93’ …so many memories! 30 years later ice cream are still delicious ?
Natalie Steven
Since the change in ownership this is not an establishment you should support. The owner is rude, critical, and does not serve as an example for her staff. I hope she sees her reviews and makes some changes or I hope she gets shut down
Meagan Horn
It’s a shame you can’t give them zero stars! Outdated food/ice cream that the owner refuses to make right and they’re downright nasty people to begin with!
If I could give them 0Stars I would. The owner is such a snotty lady that does not know how to treat customers or her employees.
bailey hunt
Owners are rude to customers and employees. Prices are outrageous now and it’s cash only. I won’t be back!
Tamara Huckaba
I don’t usually do this type of thing but after encouragement from the owner, here I am. As a kid, we would all do yard work on the weekends and then get baths and head on over to Prospect dairy bar to get an ice cream cone. My love of sherbet came from there. I continued to do the same thing with my kids. We would always go to Prospect Dairy bar after working in the yard or a long weekend of ball games. Really, just about any reason. It was our favorite spot. I have lots of friends that have written off the dairy bar after it changed owners, but although she isn’t friendly, I still spent lots of money there simply because it is very good ice cream. We would get lunches there this spring spending $50-$70 once a week. Today, my mom and I attended a funeral for a life long friend. Afterwards, I just really wanted a double burger from there. We agreed to head over for lunch. I ordered a double burger, no bun and a small sherbet ice cream cone. $11.75 totalThe young lady working the window gave me the ice cream cone while my burger was cooking. After a couple of bites I had my mom try it. It tasted very sour and there were dark orange, chewy beads in it. So I asked her if there was a possibility that the sherbet was bad because it was sour tasting. She said she would get the owner (who was cooking my burger).Approaching the window she asked me “what’s the problem?” I explained and she said there was nothing wrong with the sherbet. That’s how sherbet tastes because it’s sherbet. It has citric acid in it. I told her that I’ve never had it taste that way before and go there often. She wanted to argue. I requested to have a vanilla instead, hoping to resolve the issue, and she said “go out back and throw it away and then I will give you a vanilla”. My mom then took it out back to throw it away. The owner then accused me of “complaining the last time I was there”, which set me on fire! In 25 years, I have never complained ONE time there. EVER. I assured her that it most certainly was not me. She then said “somebody from NU complained so I don’t know”. At this point I was really upset and assured her that is was NOT me! Let me remind you, we are talking about a $2.25 small ice cream cone. I requested a fork for my no-bun burger and she stated “it’s not my job. Tell one of the others”. She was standing right there next to the minors that work FOR her! She’s the owner! I told her I felt sorry for them because I’m sure she speaks to them the same way she was speaking to me. I then pulled out my phone to record this non-sense and make the public aware of her practices and how she treats her employees and customers. She told me they “don’t have a Facebook, don’t do social media and it wouldn’t affect her business because she doesn’t need customers like me”. Right. I told her to keep the vanilla cone, I didn’t want it, and that she should be ashamed of herself. The young girl brought my fork and apologized for her behavior. I assured her it wasn’t her fault. My mom and I left. I hope this post takes off and costs her more than the $2.25 ice cream cone it cost me. She apparently doesn’t need customers.To the parents of the two young ladies working there, I would question who your daughters are being mentored by. She’s a horrible person. All good things come to an end. Today was my last day going to that dairy bar.
Rachel Stillions
For years the owner has been nothing but rude to my family when we visit. She has made terrible, offhand comments to us whether it be about needing and extra cup for melty ice cream or saying that I, as a Type One Diabetic, shouldn't be having ice cream. Those are only a few to say the least. I couldn't agree anymore with the other 1 star reviews. I will no longer be supporting this business after hearing so many horror stories from customers and employees.
Morgan Turrill
I used to love going here. Now the owner is rude, and you can hear her and her husband arguing and cursing at each other from the parking lot. I got sour sherbet, and when I told them it was bad, they said that’s just how sherbet is and there was nothing wrong with it. I’ve eaten a lot of sherbet in my life and it’s never been chunky or sour. Ever. I hope they never get another customer again after the way she talked to my mom for saying her sherbet wasn’t right.
I have been going there as often as possible for the peanut butter milkshakes
They should paint it .but everything else is awesome .
A small hometown dairy bar with a lot of love and commitment for their customers. It's hard to find places that don't cut corners anymore. But thus place definitely goes above and beyond with their food and dairy products. Highly recommended for anyone looking for a quick stop at lunch or dinner. These gals are amazing!
It's a nice drive along the river from Columbus to Prospect. And then you get some ice cream upon arriving.
Ordered a cherry milkshake and got a chocolate. Didn't realize right away. It was good, though.
The new owner is RUDE and DISRESPECTFUL! The ice cream is good but not worth the service you get, no trash can in site, and the incredibly high prices.
The owner of this place is a TERRIBLE person just in general. She treats her TEENAGE employees like garbage and the customers not much better. She always thinks she doesn’t need customers to stay in business? Her words, not mine.
I have been there in summer 93’ …so many memories! 30 years later ice cream are still delicious ?
Since the change in ownership this is not an establishment you should support. The owner is rude, critical, and does not serve as an example for her staff. I hope she sees her reviews and makes some changes or I hope she gets shut down
It’s a shame you can’t give them zero stars! Outdated food/ice cream that the owner refuses to make right and they’re downright nasty people to begin with!
Restaurantji Recommends
If I could give them 0Stars I would. The owner is such a snotty lady that does not know how to treat customers or her employees.
Owners are rude to customers and employees. Prices are outrageous now and it’s cash only. I won’t be back!
I don’t usually do this type of thing but after encouragement from the owner, here I am. As a kid, we would all do yard work on the weekends and then get baths and head on over to Prospect dairy bar to get an ice cream cone. My love of sherbet came from there. I continued to do the same thing with my kids. We would always go to Prospect Dairy bar after working in the yard or a long weekend of ball games. Really, just about any reason. It was our favorite spot. I have lots of friends that have written off the dairy bar after it changed owners, but although she isn’t friendly, I still spent lots of money there simply because it is very good ice cream. We would get lunches there this spring spending $50-$70 once a week. Today, my mom and I attended a funeral for a life long friend. Afterwards, I just really wanted a double burger from there. We agreed to head over for lunch. I ordered a double burger, no bun and a small sherbet ice cream cone. $11.75 totalThe young lady working the window gave me the ice cream cone while my burger was cooking. After a couple of bites I had my mom try it. It tasted very sour and there were dark orange, chewy beads in it. So I asked her if there was a possibility that the sherbet was bad because it was sour tasting. She said she would get the owner (who was cooking my burger).Approaching the window she asked me “what’s the problem?” I explained and she said there was nothing wrong with the sherbet. That’s how sherbet tastes because it’s sherbet. It has citric acid in it. I told her that I’ve never had it taste that way before and go there often. She wanted to argue. I requested to have a vanilla instead, hoping to resolve the issue, and she said “go out back and throw it away and then I will give you a vanilla”. My mom then took it out back to throw it away. The owner then accused me of “complaining the last time I was there”, which set me on fire! In 25 years, I have never complained ONE time there. EVER. I assured her that it most certainly was not me. She then said “somebody from NU complained so I don’t know”. At this point I was really upset and assured her that is was NOT me! Let me remind you, we are talking about a $2.25 small ice cream cone. I requested a fork for my no-bun burger and she stated “it’s not my job. Tell one of the others”. She was standing right there next to the minors that work FOR her! She’s the owner! I told her I felt sorry for them because I’m sure she speaks to them the same way she was speaking to me. I then pulled out my phone to record this non-sense and make the public aware of her practices and how she treats her employees and customers. She told me they “don’t have a Facebook, don’t do social media and it wouldn’t affect her business because she doesn’t need customers like me”. Right. I told her to keep the vanilla cone, I didn’t want it, and that she should be ashamed of herself. The young girl brought my fork and apologized for her behavior. I assured her it wasn’t her fault. My mom and I left. I hope this post takes off and costs her more than the $2.25 ice cream cone it cost me. She apparently doesn’t need customers.To the parents of the two young ladies working there, I would question who your daughters are being mentored by. She’s a horrible person. All good things come to an end. Today was my last day going to that dairy bar.
For years the owner has been nothing but rude to my family when we visit. She has made terrible, offhand comments to us whether it be about needing and extra cup for melty ice cream or saying that I, as a Type One Diabetic, shouldn't be having ice cream. Those are only a few to say the least. I couldn't agree anymore with the other 1 star reviews. I will no longer be supporting this business after hearing so many horror stories from customers and employees.
I used to love going here. Now the owner is rude, and you can hear her and her husband arguing and cursing at each other from the parking lot. I got sour sherbet, and when I told them it was bad, they said that’s just how sherbet is and there was nothing wrong with it. I’ve eaten a lot of sherbet in my life and it’s never been chunky or sour. Ever. I hope they never get another customer again after the way she talked to my mom for saying her sherbet wasn’t right.