Sporty's Pizzeria

101 N Main St, Prospect
(740) 494-2681

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Joshua Mullennix

Just went for my first time today and it was amazing. Everything is made in house and was the freshest and tastiest food I've ever had. The owner was amazing and his staff as well, they were super nice and even treated us with some free breadsticks, a sausage and gravy breakfast pizza they are trying and a free guitar lesson. I will be back for sure!

Cortney Jordan Harris

Sportys Pizzeria is absolutely the best! Great atmosphere!!!! Great owners!!!!!!!

Michael Lanning

I stumbled upon Sportys while hiking across Ohio. I met the owner and he was super cool. The food was amazing and we even played the guitar for a while. I stopped in a few weeks later after losing my wallet and they helped me out. Overall great food, great people and great Vibe!

Katie Rychener

Sportys is such a great place! I haven’t been in a long time due to not living in the vicinity any longer. But, we went Saturday evening and it did NOT disappoint. The food was awesome! The pretzel appetizer was incredible. Salads were super fresh and the ? crust was fantastic! The staff was super kind and attentive. 5⭐️s , for sure! Thanks so much for a great family night out.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Gabe Roth

Amazing service and great food!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

clayton mccann

OUTRAGEOUS PRICES. I spent 14.96 on a small 10” pizza with one

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Amy Austin

We love sportys. The food is fantastic and the staff is beyond helpful and friendly. Highly recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amy Austin

We love Sportys. The staff is fantastic and the food is delicious. Highly recommend.

Ashley Legge

We ordered from here for the first time since we were driving through, and I can’t believe it took us this long to try Sporty’s! It was amazing! Had a stuff crust (large) for the three of us and we barely touched half of it! Plus two gyros that had some amazing Tzatziki sauce! Love the food, and love the prices. Will def be back very soon!

Hollywood “Danger” Gator III

Good food

Angie Miller

OMG! I ordered a salad & not only was it ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS, but it was ABSOLUTELY BEAUTIFUL! PERFECT! I LOVE Sportys! I love the people & the price is unbeatable!! They delivered to me today (in the awful snow storm) but I usually try to go in bc the people are just AMAZING! LOVE talking to them! Thanks Sportys

J O

My brother Jerry and I spend most weekends searching for new places to try one of our favorite foods: pizza. Someone suggested Sportys and their old-world pepperoni special. We decided to go and try it. Her establishment is nestled in a corner of a quaint Ohio town and adorned inside with photos of the town and it's history as well as antiques. We were immediately greeted by the owner, Candy. She was so warm and welcoming and made us feel at home. She went over the menu and suggested the old-world pepperoni and then sat down and took some time to get to know us a little. She asked where we from and how we came to find out about this place. She then proudly presented the pizza, which was baked in a square and sliced accordingly. It was absolutely delicious. Hot and bubbly with a tangy sauce you could die for. She also serves a deep dish style we plan to try in the future. As we were leaving, she asked when we were coming back next, promising an even better experience next time. With all due respect, I don't think she could do anything to make us feel more welcome nor make an even better pizza. She won us both over!! We'll be back again soon despite the drive from Columbus. It's definitelyworth a try as she has a large menu which includes nachos, hamburgers, and pasta. Thanks, Joe

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chef Salad, Pepperoni Pizza

Alexandria Morton

Cute little place I love the owners they are awesome at their craft!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

Julien Wesson

Thank you for your warm welcome ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Bryan Santschi

They take a medium crust and spread out to a jumbo. Different everytime we order and this was the last time we will ever buy from them. Stopped buying there subs because they use cheap lunch meat in them.

Loading...