The Keys, Put-in-Bay, OH

Wonderful restaurant! We went twice during our stay. The first time we grabbed and split the conch fritters, grouper, and corn dip. All were delicious. The second time, I had perfect mahi mahi tacos and my husband had the perch basket. Seafood is on point in a beautiful location.

The burger is quite expensive regarding to the size and flavor and cooking extent to which

burger is terrible

As close to the real Keys as you are going to get in Ohio. Super cool atmosphere with great service. Strong drinks and street corn dip was fabulous. Great place to be stuck and watch a storm roll in.

The food is greasy, wayy over priced, the staff are rude. It's just not a place I'd recommend.

Reuben Walleye was delicious! Everything was good and such a great spot for all! A must try in PIB!

It reminded me of the Florida keys

Horrible service, very disappointing

Have been coming here for years and bret the manager as well as his staff are fantastic

Have been coming here for years, great experience every time. My ID expired the day prior to my trip and I didn't think it would matter. However, the manager Brett helped me print a paper ID so I can get around this weekend. I appreciate the staff greatly for helping me out!

A very cool little island. Lots to do. Great, friendly people. Cute little bed and breakfasts to stay in. Lots of bars, restaurants and shops. We will definitely be back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The food at the keys is great, but the prices are quite steep for what you get. The ambiance is amazing, feels like you're in a tropical place rather than Ohio.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

09/21/2024 - I visited The Keys with a buddy to watch OSU defeat Marshall 49-14. Big restaurant with an open space that leads to other parts of the restaurant. We sat at the bar. No wait time. Cool and fun atmosphere for all. I ordered their Chicken Tenderly with a Margarita. Everything tasted delicious. Sitting at the bar provides a nice panoramic view (if facing Lake Erie). Awesome and stellar service. Thank you, Alex. Parking a few feet away from the restaurant (golf cart parking). Decent prices.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This place has a very good sea food, specially the golden shrimp; however, the non-seafood items such as hamburger do not have that quality.
We had a pleasant experience there, with our server, Salomon, who was caring and receptive.
I recommend this place at Put in bay.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Good frozen drinks. Cool inside. There is a couple different areas associated I think? Worth checking out. Our server was nice.

Also, make sure to check out the rock before you walk up. Especially if you didn't check the weather report.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5