18 Best Bakeries near Sheffield

“Best sugar cookies ever. I can’t stop eating the ones I got yesterday. Will definitely get some more.“

“The snoogles are always delicious, and the Asiago loaf is to die for! I just love this place so much“

“These are the best cookies I have ever had“

“We've had donuts for our parishioners from various stores in the area on Sundays for years and none can compare to Expresso. Donuts are freshly made every day, delicious & of a generous size and the owners and staff are excellent to work with. So glad they are in Elyria!“

“We've been purchasing pies from Mama Jo's since we moved here a year ago. My father LOVES the cherry pie. He has a piece every morning with coffee. My husband and I love the Boston Cream Pie. I've also tried the banana cream. All have not disappointed, other than I would LOVE to see the cream pies offered with graham cracker crust. 😋“

“Thanks again for the vegan choc cheesecakes to help celebrate Richard's surprise 70th birthday at the Feve - enjoyed by all“

“Fair warning, don't try Mrs Scott's sweets, unless you are willing to drive back there on a regular basis. Once you try it, you will definitely come back for more! My favorite, is the "Death by chocolate" cupcakes. I have died many deaths, and keep coming back for more!“

“The food from this place is absolutely delicious. 🥰“

“I ordered a cake for my 30th birthday party. I got the white cake with the raspberry. It was a party hit! Absolutely did not have any left by the time the night was over. The cake was beautifully done and is exactly what I had pictured. I highly recommend ordering your cake from here! I will be for future events!“

“As someone whose mother bakes a lot, we always discuss what we like and dislike about different treats we eat. We both can agree that the macarons are wonderful as they fill them with a depth of flavor. That's primarily the reason I keep going back. We also agree that the cupcakes are beautiful but the cake portion is not stellar-- maybe a bit above average. If you're a frosting person, you'll likely enjoy the cupcakes a lot more. The blondies are good. I don't have any experience with their cookies.“

“Everything is fresh and scrumptious! We will be back any time we are in the area.“

“Stopped in for the first time today!!! What a great find!!! My wife and I had sandwiches and took a couple chocolate croissants home! Fresh, great tasting, and reasonable prices! Could not ask for more.“

“I got a smash cake (6in round) for my toddler sons bday and I wanted a pumpkin since it’s mid October. The cake turned out better than Anything I could of imagined! She did an amazing Job! The cake was moist with an amazing chocolate flavor. I will definitely be calling her next year or any other time If I need a cake! I added photos of the cake below! I added the 3 candle and ignore the finger marks in the cake (toddler finger prints) This cake was perfect!! Thank you! I will be referring ppl! We are very satisfied and pleased with the whole cake! Love it! I also forgot the mention how sweet, understanding And professional the lady was! The price was very reasonable as well.“

“Jeanie has been around for years LOve her cakes“

“I can't say enough. Wow, amazing, delicious, all the workers are great. ☺️ I was greeted and treated like a Queen. 💕 Thank you so much. I'll definitely be back.“

“Ordered Father’s Day cookies & they were great cookies, great packaging & great pricing !!!! Highly recommend ☺️“

“Meahan was our server. She did a great job and was very efficient.“

“Today I visited Anna and Cal at Paris Baguette in Avon, Ohio and they were really sweet. I needed a refund for my drink due to its high sweetness level, but Anna helped me with the refund and was very polite. I will be back and I believe I have found a new bakery to go to!!“