Mama's Pizza

40 Mansfield Ave, Shelby
(419) 342-7777

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Stephen Wilkinson

Love the “old world pepperoni”! Great location right next to Blackfork Brewery. We do carrot.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Joshua Petersen

The foldovers are perfect every time

Food: 5

Service: 5

Noah Henry

Amazing pizza and foldovers! Friendly staff too.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Anni Kay Limpach

Cheese burger

Jim_E

I've given this place a few tries. My experience with the service was okay....It's just some of the nastiest food I've ever ordered. It was warm, properly cooked, but the overall taste I'd rather forget about. The pizza is gross and how do they manage to make a grilled hamburger taste like it came from a vending machine? Some people seem to like it. I just don't get it.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 3

Jamie

Not impressed.

Food: 1

Service: 4

richelle schunatz

I AM OBSESSED with their salads! Their PIZZA & FOLDOVERS ARE PERFECTLY MADE as well. Always so friendly! I always suggest Mama's Pizza to anyone coming in town.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Derek Hess

Been years since ordering here. Got a flyer in the mail.
Thought a Philly mushroom Swiss sub sounded amazing.
No flavor and next to nothing sub best part was the crispy bread.
The pizza we got was ok much better than the sub.
Id rather eat domino's or drive to crestline for checkers
Needless to say be years again or if I attempt to go back.
Will say the person taking the order was very pleasant and best part of the experience

spencey

First time trying, got a recommendation from Caleb. Food was pretty good for the cheap price.

Nevar YaYa

This establishment employs a man by the name of Tristan (unsure of spelling) who has made racially charged comments to another employee several times now. He called her a monkey and a slave. Hopefully they do the right thing and terminate him.

Brian Koebele

I have tried to like this place. The pizza is very expensive for what you get. We got pizza and wings and dessert for $50 . I would pay that if the pizza was even good... it isn't.

Slim Rhec

Stopped delivering to tiro

Shane Mcclary

Used to order the Philly foldover a lot. Used to be just under $10. Since they built the new building that same small Philly foldover is now $16. Even has some random charge for $1.50. Says it's to keep their business going. NO!! The foldovers are good but not nearly that good. I'll drive to norwalk and get the same thing for $10. Way to expensive. Bring back the old building if you have to. You lost another customer.

Margie Payne

Pizza was so good!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Scott Barnett

I wanna clarify, the food itself is good, staff is nice, but it's so insanely expensive, I couldn't recommend this place. I understand the economy isn't doing so well, but you're charging me California prices, when this is middle of nowheres Ohio. I used to get this place religiously 2018-2019. However they got greedy i guess. Just go to Dominos or Gioninos if you want affordable food.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Pizza, Bone-In Wings

Loading...