The Other Guy Pizza
15910 OH-37, Sunbury
(740) 913-0694
Customers' Favorites
Pepperoni and Banana Peppers
Large Pepperoni Pizza
Sausage & Peppers Sub
Teriyaki Wings
Meatball Pizza
Peperoni Pizza
Mmeatball Sub
Potato Skins
Cheese Pizza
Garlic Knots
Menu
Photos
+14 photos
+13 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Great pizza. Was looking for NY/NJ style pizza for a while around here and finally found it. Perfect sauce, crust is great. Chicken wings weren't great (too much fat compared to meat), but this is strictly my taste. so place, owner, service, food is straight up 5 stars! Be back definitely.
Might be the best pizza I’ve had in decades in the metro area. Off the beaten path, reasonable prices, and Rocco the owner was interesting as well as an excellent host. If you like hitting the small independents, good food, nice people, orders are correct, and the way places used to be - definitely a must do. Heard rumors on the cannoli which sell out fast on Fridays only - we are definitely coming back to test those 5 star reports!
Its a little out of the way for a lot of people, but SOOOOOO worth the trip. Simple old skool place just simply doing it right. Scratch made dough with quality cheese and topping ingredients. Stop in on a Friday. They make Canoli's from scratch too.
You May Also Like
Fracasso's Village Pizza - 3699 OH-605
![]()
Pizza, Italian, Vegetarian
District 13 - 45 E Granville St
![]()
American, Cocktail Bar, New American
Branch Pizza - 34 S Vernon St
![]()
Pizza, Beer Bar, Pet Friendly