15 Best American Restaurants in Tiffin

The Turntable American • $$
116 S Washington St, Tiffin

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Prawns

“The Turntable experience was by far one of the best dinner experiences my husband and I have had. The service was impeccable—Jocelyn’s energy and enthusiasm were infectious. The atmosphere makes you feel comfortable with fantastic background vinyls playing continuously. Our meal was absolutely incredible—all of the food was so fresh tasting, powerfully flavorful, and the shareable plates are a perfect concept to try multiple meals. Rob and his team have created a very special gem in Tiffin and we hope to see them continue to rise. We visited for our anniversary and it has now made the top of our restaurant list for future date nights.“

4.9 Superb54 Reviews
Clover Club Sports Tavern & Eatery American • $
266 S Washington St, Tiffin

Customers` Favorites

BBQ Pulled Pork Sandwich and Coleslaw
Bourbon Barrel Ale Crisp Apple
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Chicken Sandwich
Big Soft Pretzel
Rueben Sandwich
Meatloaf Dinner
The Wad Burger
Buffalo Wings
Angry Orchard

“Popcorn machine is on point that’s for sure.“

4.4 Superb71 Reviews
MST Pub & Grub/ Sauce Company Bar & Grill • $
92 Madison St, Tiffin

Customers` Favorites

Loaded Chunks Try It with Tater Tots
Hot Honey Garlic Parmesan
Philly Cheesesteak Burger
Chicken Cordon Bleu Wrap
Loaded Chicken Chunks
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Aloha Chicken Basket
And Cheese Burger
Bologna Sandwich
Chicken Sandwich

“Parking might be hard but it's well worth it and the wait. Had the pretzel bites with one of the best honey mustards I've ever had. And a bacon egg and cheeseburger that was pure flavor. One of the best burgers I've had in a long long time. Highly recomend and will be back without a doubt.“

4.9 Superb141 Reviews
Benchwarmers Restaurant and Delivery American • $
105 Allen St, Tiffin

Customers` Favorites

Build Your Own Grilled Cheese
Boneless Chicken Wings
Mushroom Swiss Burger
All American Burger
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Triple Cheeseburger
Steakhouse Burger
Chicken Sandwich
Alpine Sandwich
Boneless Wings

“Tori at Benchwarmers is great, friendly, and very accommodating!! 10 / 10 on service!! The food was phenomenal and the overall atmosphere was great!!“

4.3 Superb72 Reviews
GW's Fine Food & Spirits American • $
275 S Washington St, Tiffin

Customers` Favorites

George's Double Decker with Bacon
Mushroom Swiss and Fries
Chili Cheese Burger
Spicy Cheese Curds
French Toast Combo
Bob's the Mess
Beef Manhattan
Macaroni Salad
Chicken Dinner
Breaded Veal

“I just enjoyed the perfect smash burger. Thanks Bob and crew, I’ll be back soon!!“

4.3 Superb45 Reviews
Frisch's Big Boy American • $
800 W Market St, Tiffin

Customers` Favorites

Quart - Macaroni and Cheese
Mini Big Boy Sundae
Philly Cheese Steak
Big Boy Hamburger
Crinkle-Cut Fries
Big Boy Platter
Vegetable Soup
Grilled Cheese
Hot Fudge Cake
Super Big Boy

“Many memories going to Big Boys in my hometown. The food was like I remember. The restaurant is smaller than what I was expecting. Service was good though they seemed short-staffed. Everyone was courteous. I only wish they still carry the seasoning salt it always complemented the coleslaw for me.“

4.2 Good62 Reviews
Pioneer Mill of Tiffin American • $$
255 Riverside Dr, Tiffin

Customers` Favorites

Lemon Pepper Chicken Dinner
Prime Rib Dinner Salad
Twice Baked Potato
Jumbo Shrimp Dinner
Chicken Florentine
Seafood Portofino
French Onion Soup
Liver and Onions
Perch Sandwich
Steak Au Poivre

“I've had multiple large events/gatherings at the Mill and they never disappoint. From private parties (buffet style serving) to individual meals from the general menu for parties over 15, we've always had amazing food. This past weekend they accommodated our massive group on the fly despite having 3 or 4 large parties already booked around the same time. The staff is amazing and the food is perfect every time. Our family appreciates everything you do and they always look forward to our next get together at the Mill. ❤️“

3.8 Good69 Reviews
Double Barrel Bar And Grill Bar • $
295 Vine St, Tiffin

Customers` Favorites

Fried Potatoes
Fish and Chips

“We looked around town yesterday on Saturday around 330 for somewhere to get chicken chunks!!! The viaduct was closed. Mike’s was closed and so was Madison Street.!! so we decided to head to the double barrel!!! Definitely was not disappointed! It was a great choice. I’m kind of glad the other places were closed.!! food was delicious and great service! Thank you, Cassie!“

4.8 Superb17 Reviews
Sauber's Stumble Inn Sports Bar • $
5921 W Tiffin St, Tiffin

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Cheese Flatbread
Lettuce Tomato Onion
Garlic Cheese Bread
Chicken Bacon Ranch
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Specialty Pizzas

“great food and prices,very clean and great service too.“

4.9 Superb9 Reviews
Bel-Mar Boat Landing Bar & Grill • $
1700 Duchess Ln Lot 12, Tiffin

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Strips
Chicken Wings
Fish Basket
Side Salad

“great night at the tiffin yacht club!“

4.5 Superb18 Reviews
The Wall Street Pub & Grille Pubs • $
235 Miami St, Tiffin

Customers` Favorites

Mushroom Swiss Impossible Burger with Fries
Spinach and Artichoke Dip
Boneless Wings and Fries
Mozzarella Cheese Sticks
Burger and Tater Tots
Beer Cheese Burger
Meatloaf Sandwich
French Onion Chips
Buffalo Chicken
blt Flatbread

“Wonderful time. Great service, great food. Will definitely go back!“

4.3 Superb37 Reviews
The Empire American • $$
138 S Washington St, Tiffin

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Mashed Potatoes
Small House Salad
Sea Scallops
Crab Cakes
Burger
Salads

“Highly recommend the Empire! Sharon and her staff were wonderful, very professional, and accommodating.They helped put on a beautiful and delicious brunch for my daughter and son-in-law’s baby shower! Lots of compliments from friends and family! Thanks again to the Empire! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

3.5 Good51 Reviews
Carmies BBQ & Grill Barbecue • $
2460 OH-231, Tiffin

Customers` Favorites

Dine in: Yes Outdoor seating: Yes Takeout: Yes
Perch Dinner with Tater Tots and Green Beans

“10 of us went to the comedy / dinner. The food was very good. And the comedy show was great. Worth every penny we paid!!!!“

4 Good24 Reviews
Bob Evans American • $
2310 W Market St, Tiffin

Customers` Favorites

Introducing Bob Evans Dinner Bell Plates Eight Great Plates Under 8
Hand-Breaded Crispy Fried Chicken Family Meal to Go
Slow-Roasted Turkey & Dressing Family Meal
Buttermilk Biscuit Sandwich Bundle
Family Size Seasonal Fresh Fruit
Family Size Green Beans with Ham
Farmer's Choice Family Breakfast
Homestyle Fried Chicken Tenders
Family Size Macaroni & Cheese
Farmhouse Chicken Sandwich

“Service was horrible! Had to wait on meal over 1 hr
When got food coleslaw was without dressing. French fries over cooked
Meat was tough and grizzly! Waitress said reason for food taking so long was that call in orderd were filled before ours! Bill was over 38$
Waitress didn't offer refills on drinks! Will not go back here for along time,“

3.1 Average44 Reviews
Buffalo Wild Wings Chicken Wings • $
100 S Shaffer Park Dr, Tiffin

Customers` Favorites

Hamburger Dine in: Yes Outdoor seating: Yes Takeout: Yes Delivery: Yes Curbside pickup: Yes
Cheese Curds Garlic Parmesan Wings
Brisket Burger with Onion Rings
Chicken Wings Combo
Traditional Wings
Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken Sandwich
Boneless Wings
Orange Chicken
Buffalo Wings

“My wife and I stopped by and tried the new Bacon Patty Melt. We both enjoyed the sandwich very much.“

3.6 Good64 Reviews