Pioneer Mill of Tiffin
$$ • American, Bars, New AmericanAbout Pioneer Mill of Tiffin
Customers' Favorites
Lemon Pepper Chicken Dinner
Prime Rib Dinner Salad
Jumbo Shrimp Dinner
Twice Baked Potato
Chicken Florentine
French Onion Soup
Seafood Portofino
Liver and Onions
Perch Sandwich
Steak Au Poivre
Pioneer Mill of Tiffin Reviews
275 ratings
Share your opinion about Pioneer Mill of Tiffin
We enjoyed our first thanksgiving out and about. Great wine list, nice selection of favorites on the menu. Hidden gem.
Enjoyed out first visit to the Pioneer Mill last weekend while visiting our son attending College in Tiffin. Great food, enjoyed a nice salad bar and friendly service.
We are from Mi our son forgot his varsity jacket. The staff went above and beyond to locate us! They figured out the school by the jacket, called our high school to locate us! Carrie even so graciously offered to meet us in Toledo to return it!
Our son in Tiffin was able to pick it up!
It’s...read full review
We are from Mi our son forgot his varsity jacket. The staff went above and beyond to locate us! They figured out the school by the jacket, called our high school to locate us! Carrie even so graciously offered to meet us in Toledo to return it!
Our son in Tiffin was able to pick it up!
It’s...read full review
I've had multiple large events/gatherings at the Mill and they never disappoint. From private parties (buffet style serving) to individual meals from the general menu for parties over 15, we've always had amazing food. This past weekend they accommodated our massive group on the fly despite having 3 or 4 large parties already booked around the same time. The staff is amazing and the food is perfect every time. Our family appreciates everything you do and they always look forward...read full review
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 4 - 8PM |
| Wednesday | 4 - 8PM |
| Thursday | 4 - 8PM |
| Friday | 4 - 10PM |
| Saturday | 4 - 10PM |
| Sunday | 1 - 8PM |
The Pioneer Mill of Tiffin is a family-friendly restaurant that offers a variety of classic American dishes. The steaks and prime rib have received mixed reviews, but the 10-layer chocolate cake is a standout dessert. The restaurant is often busy, especially during events, but the staff works hard to accommodate customers and provide a pleasant dining experience. Customers have praised the attentive service, good-sized portions, and delicious meals like the Thai chicken, lobster Neptune, and prime rib. The restaurant has also received positive feedback for its ability to accommodate large groups and events, with the staff consistently delivering amazing food and service. Overall, the Pioneer Mill is worth a visit, as it seems to offer a nice hometown atmosphere and satisfying meals.