Very good deep dish pizza and super friendly staff only negative is you have to wait 45 minutes for the deep dish pizza, but they warn you about that once you order it, so it's not a big deal.
Mohamad Awad
If you want a deep dish pizza.. pizza paplis is where to go.. but everything else is just basic pizza.. and their prices are pretty high for a basic pizza.. maybe your paying for the atmosphere.. I'm not sure.. but the pizza is ok.. nothing too crazy maybe they need deep dish pizza competition in Toledo to see where they really stand
Cody
Ate before a walleye game, took the leftover pizza with us. Our stomachs were knotting up waiting in line to get into the Huntington center. After the game got home and looked at the pizza closer after warming it up, pizza dough was undercooked. Needless to say we were upset, and won't be returning.
Tom Kroner
stopped for some pizza before a walleye game. ordered a dep dish. appreciated the waitress letting us know it would be about 45minutes. we were starving. the pizza came out barely warm in the middle. ok that happens. however the waitress didn't come back for at least 20 minutes. picked at it and saved samples of the raw dough. she finally cam.back and the manager comped 25% Off the pizza. what a joke. ingredients tasted great..just imagine if it was cooked properly.
Trina Taite
Date Night Done Right at Pizza Papalis! My husband and I decided to switch things up with a Tuesday date night, and this was our first time trying Pizza Papalis. We ordered the deep dish veggie pizza with mushrooms, spinach, banana peppers, green peppers, and green olives—loaded and delicious! We also got the cheesy bread with spinach and feta cheese that was pretty good. My husband had to get French fries and Surprisingly, they ended up being a favorite too—crispy, well-seasoned, and way better than we expected. I had an Amaretto Sour, which was smooth and refreshing, while my husband enjoyed the Italian Cherry Margarita.
Our waitress was very nice and checked on us often, which made the experience even better. We’ll definitely be back, especially to take advantage of the half-off Tuesday pizza deal with the purchase of an appetizer.
We’re also excited to go back once the weather breaks so we can enjoy the breeze with the garage-style windows open—it looks like the perfect summer vibe! The only downside? Parking can be a bit of a challenge. But overall, great food, friendly service, and a perfect spot for a chill night out.
Christina Wanderer
So I've been coming to the Greek town Pizza Papalis since I was a kid. Yesterday in Toledo was the worst. We drove over an hour to eat there. It was our anniversary and just wanted a good pizza. Very disappointed! Bread Stix were hard and overdone. I ended up eating a few cuz I was so hungry. The breaded ravioli we def frozen and heated up. Not good. We ordered a large Chicago style pizza half VIP and half meat lovers. It was so under cooked. Asked to speak to the manager waited 10 min for the server to say she said we can reheat your pizza. It takes over 45 min to get a pizza there. When we asked to speak with a manager. He came out and said they might be having a bad day and they could reheat it. I said no I want my money back when he wanted to make a new one. I didn't want to wait another hour for a pizza that might be under cooked again. I didn't think the manager was very nice. That being said we won't be back. Paying 45 dollars for an undercooked pizza is disgusting. Thanks for making our anniversary meal awful.
Richard Plant
you can not go wrong food is so GOOD!!
Annah Wang
The service was really exceptional and friendly. The food was very enjoyable. The only issue we had, was the table and chairs are very old and annoyingly wobbly.
Kevin Pietro
Phenomenal food. A tasty take on Deep Dish Pizza and the bone in wings were a great compliment to the whole experience.
John Measles
Worst service ever...waited 2 hours for our pizza...was cold when we got it...my son never got their pizza as the waitress forgot to put in his order...had to wait for our checks...had to wait for our change...3 hours sitting at this place...totally uncalled for...i will never ever be back to this place...highly dissapointed
Dave and his staff will make your dining experience fast and worry free. Great atmosphere.
2025 update: ingredients have changed compared to prior experiences, unable to digest the pizza sauce now compared to past. May be me, may have changed suppliers, but we gave it several tries with no success, sorry.......
Ron Blanchett
Seating could be a lot less cramped otherwise a great place to get a bite to eat.
Gary Muszynski
Great atmosphere, great food.
Hanah
Went here before a Walleye game and our server was rude. When we got our pizza it was cold and had uncooked pepperoni on it. I also asked for an extra side of lemons for my water and the server gave me them wadded up in napkins. We were very disappointed in our food and the service. It will definitely be awhile before we try this place again.
Heidi
Went before a walleye game took the waiters 45 minutes to refill our drinks brought us the wrong oder it was the worst service we had in 5 years will never go go back
Very good deep dish pizza and super friendly staff only negative is you have to wait 45 minutes for the deep dish pizza, but they warn you about that once you order it, so it's not a big deal.
If you want a deep dish pizza.. pizza paplis is where to go.. but everything else is just basic pizza.. and their prices are pretty high for a basic pizza.. maybe your paying for the atmosphere.. I'm not sure.. but the pizza is ok.. nothing too crazy maybe they need deep dish pizza competition in Toledo to see where they really stand
Ate before a walleye game, took the leftover pizza with us. Our stomachs were knotting up waiting in line to get into the Huntington center. After the game got home and looked at the pizza closer after warming it up, pizza dough was undercooked. Needless to say we were upset, and won't be returning.
stopped for some pizza before a walleye game. ordered a dep dish. appreciated the waitress letting us know it would be about 45minutes. we were starving. the pizza came out barely warm in the middle. ok that happens. however the waitress didn't come back for at least 20 minutes. picked at it and saved samples of the raw dough. she finally cam.back and the manager comped 25% Off the pizza. what a joke. ingredients tasted great..just imagine if it was cooked properly.
Date Night Done Right at Pizza Papalis!
My husband and I decided to switch things up with a Tuesday date night, and this was our first time trying Pizza Papalis. We ordered the deep dish veggie pizza with mushrooms, spinach, banana peppers, green peppers, and green olives—loaded and delicious! We also got the cheesy bread with spinach and feta cheese that was pretty good. My husband had to get French fries and Surprisingly, they ended up being a favorite too—crispy, well-seasoned, and way better than we expected. I had an Amaretto Sour, which was smooth and refreshing, while my husband enjoyed the Italian Cherry Margarita.
Our waitress was very nice and checked on us often, which made the experience even better. We’ll definitely be back, especially to take advantage of the half-off Tuesday pizza deal with the purchase of an appetizer.
We’re also excited to go back once the weather breaks so we can enjoy the breeze with the garage-style windows open—it looks like the perfect summer vibe! The only downside? Parking can be a bit of a challenge. But overall, great food, friendly service, and a perfect spot for a chill night out.
So I've been coming to the Greek town Pizza Papalis since I was a kid. Yesterday in Toledo was the worst. We drove over an hour to eat there. It was our anniversary and just wanted a good pizza. Very disappointed! Bread Stix were hard and overdone. I ended up eating a few cuz I was so hungry. The breaded ravioli we def frozen and heated up. Not good. We ordered a large Chicago style pizza half VIP and half meat lovers. It was so under cooked. Asked to speak to the manager waited 10 min for the server to say she said we can reheat your pizza. It takes over 45 min to get a pizza there. When we asked to speak with a manager. He came out and said they might be having a bad day and they could reheat it. I said no I want my money back when he wanted to make a new one. I didn't want to wait another hour for a pizza that might be under cooked again. I didn't think the manager was very nice. That being said we won't be back. Paying 45 dollars for an undercooked pizza is disgusting. Thanks for making our anniversary meal awful.
you can not go wrong
food is so GOOD!!
The service was really exceptional and friendly. The food was very enjoyable. The only issue we had, was the table and chairs are very old and annoyingly wobbly.
Phenomenal food. A tasty take on Deep Dish Pizza and the bone in wings were a great compliment to the whole experience.
Worst service ever...waited 2 hours for our pizza...was cold when we got it...my son never got their pizza as the waitress forgot to put in his order...had to wait for our checks...had to wait for our change...3 hours sitting at this place...totally uncalled for...i will never ever be back to this place...highly dissapointed
Restaurantji Recommends
Dave and his staff will make your dining experience fast and worry free. Great atmosphere.
2025 update: ingredients have changed compared to prior experiences, unable to digest the pizza sauce now compared to past. May be me, may have changed suppliers, but we gave it several tries with no success, sorry.......
Seating could be a lot less cramped otherwise a great place to get a bite to eat.
Great atmosphere, great food.
Went here before a Walleye game and our server was rude. When we got our pizza it was cold and had uncooked pepperoni on it. I also asked for an extra side of lemons for my water and the server gave me them wadded up in napkins. We were very disappointed in our food and the service. It will definitely be awhile before we try this place again.
Went before a walleye game took the waiters 45 minutes to refill our drinks brought us the wrong oder it was the worst service we had in 5 years will never go go back
Loading...