The Original Goodie Shop

2116 Tremont Ctr, Upper Arlington
(614) 488-8777

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Assorted Gourmet Cupcakes 1 2 DZ
Thank Goodness Karen's Leaving
1 2 Dozen Sprinkled Cupcakes
Animal Face Cookies 1 2 DZ
1 2 DZ Animal Face Cookies
1 2 Dozen Assorted Donuts
Decorated Cookies 1 2 DZ
Buttercrust White Bread
Chocolate Iced Brownie
Assorted Donuts 1 2 DZ

Menu

Donuts and Goodies
Chocolate Iced Brownie

Cookies
Smile Face Cookie
Butter cutout cookies, iced, and decorated with a smile.

Sweet Rolls and Coffee Cakes
Signature Cinnamon Sticks
We layer our sweet roll dough with korintje cinnamon and coat them in a buttery brown sugar glaze. Every bite is like the center of a cinnamon roll.

Breads
Apple Cinnamon Bread
Buttercrust White Bread

Beverages
Chilled Soda
Chilled Bottled Water

Extras
Chicken Pot Pies

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: facebook
+54 photos
Photo credit: google
+53 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Husband and I stopped in here on a late Saturday afternoon before going to dinner next door. This was our first visit and the staff was friendly. The case to the right when you first walked in was pretty much completely empty, and they were almost out of pies in the top basket, but the cookie case and the ones to the left of the cookies, were pretty full. We selected an assortment of cookies, and they were all delicious! Next time we go back we want to get some of the rolls as...
April 2025
Great cookies and the sweetest workers. I love that’s it’s family owned and operated and the workers who aren’t family seem to be treated as such. Very pleasant and clean bakery too.
April 2025
Sean and his sister Kelly were wonderful at helping myself and the customers who came in. They were prompt to greet myself and the other customer who came in, courteous, polite and were more than happy to help with our order. Five star customer service from them!
The treats are wonderful here and they even sell other items that are not desserts such as chicken pot pies which are good too.

This is my top choice of where to pick up desserts and treats...
January 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Moretti's Of Arlington - 2124 Tremont Ctr
Italian, Bar, Wine Bar, Cocktail Bar, Vegan
Herbalife Upper Arlington Nutrition (UA NUTRITION) - 2148 Tremont Ctr
Cafe, Juice Bar & Smoothies, Health Markets, Health Food, Health Food Store
The Old Bag of Nails Pub - Upper Arlington - 2102 Tremont Center
Pubs, British, Fish & Chips, Vegetarian

The Original Goodie Shop

2116 Tremont Ctr, Upper Arlington, OH 43221
(614) 488-8777