Cream of the Crop Ice Cream Shop
18 Pleasant St, Wakeman
(440) 839-0151
Customers' Favorites
Reese's Lovers
Banana Split
Big Beef Dog
Butter Pecan
Strawberry
Hot Fudge
Blueberry
Menu
Photos
+24 photos
+23 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Visited a small town in the middle of Ohio for the 4th of July weekend with a little Camping. I met one of the nicest locals who suggested that if I was looking for some Ice Cream during my visit Cream of the Crop Ice Cream Shop in Wakeman, Ohio. It was truly the BEST I’ve ever had in my 52 years of living on this Earth.
Amazing Homemade Ice Cream!!!
Cute little place! The older lady there was so kind and helpful as my son has several allergies. She was very willing to look up ingredients for us. They all were so nice! After we had been there about 20 minutes they really started getting busy. It was so nice to see everyone was so kind waiting their turn to go in.
I highly recommend the Reese Swirl if you like peanut butter and The Parent Trap.
If you want really good...
Cute little place! The older lady there was so kind and helpful as my son has several allergies. She was very willing to look up ingredients for us. They all were so nice! After we had been there about 20 minutes they really started getting busy. It was so nice to see everyone was so kind waiting their turn to go in.
I highly recommend the Reese Swirl if you like peanut butter and The Parent Trap.
If you want really good...
Delicious homemade ice cream in a small town. We were shocked by the line out the door on arrival, but it was delicious and they had a large variety of flavors. We will definitely stop back in.
You May Also Like
Happy Lotus Nutrition - 21 W Main St
![]()
Health Food
Wake Up Coffee House - 21A W Main St
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee, Coffee & Tea, Pet Friendly
Uncle Chuck's Place - 19 W Main St
![]()
Sports Bar, Chicken Wings, Burgers