Fratelli's Pizzeria

Pizza is always amazing and dont sleep on the garlic knots with cheese! Great local spot real NY style. Love it

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Best NY Style pizza we have had in years. The pie was soo good and cheesy, sause was what helped make it even better. Small restaurant located in West Chester but the pie and hoagies are a 10/10. I don't normally give a 10 rating to many small restaurants but this joint deserves it. I highly recommended that they get a Facebook page going for business.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Cheese Pizza New York Style, Calzone, Fried Cheese Ravioli

The first time I came here right before they went on vacation I thought how brilliant the pizza and service was! Traditional NY pizza that bent when you picked it up, crust was tender and taste was AMAZING! The staff was attentive and extremely helpful.

I not so patiently waited until they came back from vacation to try it again. First day they reopened I came back in and such a huge difference. The pizza dough was overworked and overcooked. It was so tough I could barely cut most of it with the knife they provided. Not one of the staff members came over to see how I was doing, offer me a box, or a refill on my drink. The music was so loud you couldn’t think and I typically don’t mind louder music but I definitely got a headache while sitting there.

I don’t know if the first time was the norm or today is but I won’t be rushing back after this experience which is sad because I thought I finally had found a wonderful place to get a good pizza around here.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

I come here a lot with my family, the food is pretty good and fairly priced, the only complaints I really have is they rarely answer the phone, there’s no ac inside, and their almost always late to open the store

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

Great NY style pizza. The garlic and basil is especially good. Grew up on the East Coast and this is a slice of home!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Pizza reminds me of growing up on Long Island. I drive 30 mins just to get some pies.

Food: 5

This place rocks. Great food and great prices! I highly recommend to anyone who likes pizza and pasta.

We had a large party, so we ordered 6 different large pizzas. It was unanimous; most disappointing pizza we've had here. The crust was good, and definitely New York style, but every single pizza tasted the same. The Hawaiian pizza had maybe one piece of pineapple per slice and nothing else; just a tomato pizza with some pineapple thrown on. The meat pizza had ground up meat on it. The white pizza with chicken we ordered had tomato sauce on it with some chicken and some white sauce drizzled on it.

We spent over $100, and could have spent less at a chain restaurant and had better pizza.

Food: 2

Very good pizza. Definitely top 5 in the Cincinnati area. A little on the expensive side though.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Easily the best NY style pizza within a 25 mile radius. I’d go as far to say the best pizza within a 25 mile radius. I’ve had pizza in NY and plenty of pizza in the area. I tried it the first time last Friday and have had it 3 times since.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

If you love NY style pizza, this is the place!

Great East Coast style pizza!

Always get to go, but pizza is always hot and ready. If you like New York style this is the best place we have found locally.

Great New York Style pizza

Killer pies.... True hand-made 💪