Cakes by Jerri Deeter

3873 S Range Line Rd, West Milton
(937) 698-4732

Recent Reviews

Brynn Pond

I absolutely love the way that my wedding cake turned out. From the moment I met Jerri she was super friendly made sure she accommodated everything that me and my new husband wanted the tastings for the cake was absolutely phenomenal. She made sure that everything was spot on with what we asked for she made sure that there was a plate for our cake topper because we didn't have any pegs to go in it. I highly recommend her if you want to get any kind of cake done! Also she made sure that everything on her cake we were able to eat.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Zach Maples

Let me start by saying I do not like cake or icing. We met Jerri at a wedding show and I tried one of her cupcakes. By the end of the show I think I had 5-6 (needed to try each flavor of course). Guess I can’t say that I don’t like cake or icing any more.Everything that Jerri prepared for our wedding was top notch. We are planning parties, just to give us a reason to make another order. Prices were great, food was amazing. We will definitely be referring people to Jerri for years to come.P.s- We order roughly 400+ pieces of dessert for 100 people. We thought there would be a ton left over. We were very wrong, people were fighting over the last few pieces cause everything was so good.

A. Buerger

Jerri created a fabulous cake for my daughter's wedding. The cake was four layers with a different flavor for each layer. All the layers were absolutely delicious and many guests confessed to sneaking back for a second piece in a different flavor. We are so happy we found Jerri!

Hannah Arnett

I can't recommend Cakes by Jerri Deeter enough! Her cakes and pies were perfect! We absolutely loved our wedding cake, the chocolate was our favorite! Thank you Jerri!

Alexander Hickey

They provided the desserts for our wedding this weekend. They did not disappoint, the dessert bar was delicious.

Morgan Skinner

Jerri was wonderful to work with! Our cakes and cupcakes delicious and so beautiful! Our wedding guests sneaking out plates of the cupcakes to take with them! Highly recommend Jerri!

Morgan Emery

Jerri was wonderful to work with! Our cakes and cupcakes delicious and so beautiful! Our wedding guests sneaking out plates of the cupcakes to take with them! Highly recommend Jerri!

Carrie Latt

Jerri made our wedding cake, cupcakes, mini pies and cookies for our wedding! She makes the best tasting cakes and desserts around. She is very friendly, very easy to work with, and professional. You can tell she is experienced in her craft. Her pricing is very affordable. I would definitely recommend her to anyone that is looking to have delicious desserts for any occasion!

Elizabeth Frusher

Jerri did WONDERFUL on my cake and cupcakes. Everyone kept talking about how good the cake was and asking who made it. Check this lady out, you won't be disappointed!!!

Kim Klipstine

Absolutely delicious! Professional and a lovely lady.

Ashley Elakman

Jerri makes the best cake I have ever tasted. She is easy to work with and we would highly recommend her.

James Hardy

Amazing Cakes and cupcakes. I do not know of any better!

Ashley Smelcer

Jerri makes the best cake I have ever tasted. She is easy to work with and we would highly recommend her.

Brittany Steiger

Jerri did an amazing job on our modern, yet classic wedding cake. I love detail, and I had some non-traditional ideas in mind for my cake. Jerri was very upfront and honest about what she was and was not comfortable doing on it! I gave her a few inspiration photos, and we decided on one. She nailed it with this one! Beautiful.

Miranda Huddle

Jerri did our wedding cake at the beginning of August, and it was absolutely amazing! The cake was so good, and it looked beautiful. She did everything exactly like I requested!

Load More