Asterisk Supper Club

14 N State St, Westerville
(614) 776-4633

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Shelli Hanschu Elliott

Such a unique and comforting atmosphere with utterly delicious food!!!

Carolina Uscanga

This place went beyond my expectations! The atmosphere alone is worth the visit—it has such a unique vibe. I’m definitely coming back for tea time. It’s a super romantic spot. The food is tasty and the beet salad is delicious!!

Barbara Romero

Nice place. Good
service

Mr. Branham

After having afternoon in London my wife was looking for something close that was like that. Well this isn't the same at all however that have there own experience. It's not bad at all. The tea wasn't as strong flavored but it was good. The scone are alot smaller and not as fluffy. Now the sandwichs are smaller but the variety is much larger. The sweets variety is small but ok. Would I do the tea time again? No however we did have fun. The front service wasn't that great we weren't greeted at the door however when our server came she was great and welcoming. It was a good experience.

Ursula Pisorn

Incredible place for tea or lunch. The ambiance is so quaint and creative; the food was impeccable ( definitely get the mushroom toast); and the wait staff was perfection!

This place is a MUST VISIT if you’re in the area!

Matt Senne

Afternoon tea was impeccable!

Jordan Chappelear

Could not recommend more! We had an amazing time! Our server was amazing and everything was delicious. Our server took the time to explain all the things that come with afternoon tea and attended on us often. This is the place for afternoon tea!

S Spaulding

Excellent service! Everything we tried was awesome. Highly recommend.

Kristin Watkins

Great dinner and drinks with friends. Such a unique and cozy atmosphere. Highly recommend!

I. H Ski

A lovely little gem in the heart of Westerville. Atmosphere is divine, the finger sandwiches are extraordinary and the tea is never ending. Lovely place, have to visit whether you’re a book enthusiast or not. It’s the chandelier that does it for me .

Rose Kilgore

While in town for a wedding, we couldn’t resist indulging in a delightful afternoon tea here. Opting for the full tea, we were thrilled by the wide array of teas and sandwiches to choose from. Our server, Mary, was a true delight—her warmth and attentiveness made our experience truly special. The atmosphere was impeccable, with thoughtful Halloween decorations adding a charming touch to the setting. Each bite was delicious, and there was more than enough for two. We left feeling both happy and satisfyingly full!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brian Berlocker

Great spot for creative cocktails.

Jeff Husband

Excellent food and experience. Music and voices were a little loud though. Fiance was able to get tea and scones for dinner. Poutine is Excellent. Glass Shark and Fortune Teller cocktails were awesome 👌. Menus are presented in books. Ironically I got the Pirate book. Fiance got electrical wiring.

S A

This place is fantastic, great tea for a great price. The environment was very relaxing. Our waitress zoe was fantastic! My wife and I are for sure coming back!

carol lebold

Oh my goodness-fun and deliciousness! Met some family for lunch and it far exceeded expectations! All food was delicious but the fancy tea lunches are special and beautiful. The staff was attentive and so so good! Every single person. Definitely will return for dinner and cocktails. The whole place is just beautiful with eclectic books everywhere. Chandeliers. And beautiful mix and match of old china and silver. Charming.

Loading...