Asterisk Supper Club

14 N State St, Westerville
(614) 776-4633

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jody Delong Jacks

Cavatelli Pasta and Mushroom Toast for lunch with a friend today.

Miranda Bartholomew

One of my favorite places in the city!

Kevin Hayes

I have been here during the Day and in the evening. Excellent vibe, staff are great. Cocktails are different and delicious. Food is tasty. Cream Tea is great. Thank you Dani, Mike & Derek.

Kymberly Lodge

I paid $12 (+$10 to add salmon) for a Caesar salad to go after our dinner here so that I had something for my lunch the next day. Ordered at 8pm, opened around noon the following day. It was a bowl of browning lettuce - no cheese, no croutons, no dressing… 😭. The salmon was delicious, but I ended up taking it home and buying a Caesar salad kit to have it with. HUGE waste of money and super disappointing upon opening for lunch. I had pasta with shrimp for my actual dinner the night before and it was alright, 3.5/5. Cocktails were great.

Karen Berzins

A fun place. Love all the books and pretty tea cups. Excellent food.

Dani Tay

The Chicken Sandwich with sweet chili ginger, cucumber and cabbage slaw, and wasabi aioli was incredible—every bite was spot on. The truffle fries with garlic aioli were just as good. We also tried the spinach and artichoke dip, which had great flavor but was a little watery. My husband ordered the meatloaf and had only good things to say, though I was too full from my meal to try it myself. I’m already looking forward to coming back for the tea service. The cozy library-inspired vibe inside was the perfect touch.

Grace Stachura

Amazing, creative dishes and staff is always attentive and hospitable. Great place for parties or tea for two!

Cheryl Trevethan

Amazing Ladies lunch place with tea & finger sandwiches but then..
A transformation to a lovely date night. I look forward to my next visit

Nathan McCallum

I promise I am not a picky eater, nor would I ever consider myself to be any sort of food critic. But by god, each dish I got here you could’ve sworn they dumped the entire salt shaker on. The atmosphere is adorable, the service was fantastic… but after 3 dishes being utterly decimated with salt, I cannot ever recommend this place or consider coming back

Brenda Judy

Micah, was our server. Is a very fantastic young man. He helped us with our choices made us laugh yet he was very professional.

CINDY

This a unique eating experience. You can select a High Tea style lunch or a selection of various sandwiches and dinners. They have a bar style eating area and also tables, all in an atmosphere that reminds me of a library.

Taylor Ceneviva

Had the pleasure of sitting at the bar and being served by Gabe and Micah. Great food and service. Perfect spot for date night!

Robin Hall

My daughter and I took my three granddaughters for afternoon tea. The girls were so excited and in awe of all of the books and the beautiful cups and plates. Menus are found inside of books that are placed on the tables-how fun and creative! Nick was our server and was uber friendly and helpful. The food was awesome, and many positive memories were made. You won’t regret patronizing this business!

Stacy Wilson

Looking through the lens as a business owner, I was extremely impressed. I went for dinner and sat at the bar. The bartender Meredith was spot on perfect. Friendly, yet very attentive to all of her customers. She crafted a delicious handcrafted cocktail - Asterick Orchad, of course! - and she was just a joy. The food was delicious. The atmosphere very welcoming. What more can you ask for? Yes. It's a bit pricey, but definitely worth it. When I roll through here next summer I will most definitely make time to experience their 'Tea Time' offerings. Thank you to the staff at this wonderful place. See you next summer.

beth ders

7/2025: chicken and waffles were not good. Waffles were tiny with overpowering sage and basically a dry chicken nugget. Ahi tuna was overcooked and too much wasabi made it bitter. Kitchen was decent. Bread pudding was dry and dense. Tasted like a Pillsbury cinnamon roll. 1 star but used to be better.
5 years ago:Chicken and waffles was great. Really enjoyed the atmosphere. And staff was great on a busy night. Will definitely go back.

Loading...