DiCarlo’s Pizza

20 S State St #K, Westerville
(614) 463-0522

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Two Pepperoni Pizza Slices and a Pepperoni Roll
Cheese and Pepperoni
Full Tray of Pizza
2 Slices of Pizza
Pizza Roll
Extras
Box

MENU
2 SLICES OF PIZZA
2 CRIPSY SQUARE SLICES COVERED IN FRESH CHEESE AND PEPPERONI
BEER & WINE
BEER & WINE | PROSECCO $7 | 6 PACKS $12 | BOTTLED WINE $12
BOX OF PIZZA
6 CRIPSY SQUARE SLICES COVERED IN FRESH CHEESE AND PEPPERONI
COCA-COLA
DIET COKE | COKE IN A GLASS $3.50 | COKE & DIET COKE 2 LITERS $5
EXTRAS
BANANA PEPPERS | SAUCE | CHILI OIL | EXTRA CHEESE & WATER $3
MERCHANDISE
DICARLO'S COFFEE MUGS | ASSORTED TEES $27 | TRUCKER HATS $30
PEPPERONI ROLL
CHEESE | PEPPERONI | BANANA PEPPERS | ALL TOPPINGS $7
TAKE N BAKE KIT
HALF-BAKED PIZZA KIT WITH TOPPINGS ON THE SIDE. MAKES 6 SLICES!
TRAY OF PIZZA
24 CRIPSY SQUARE SLICES COVERED IN FRESH CHEESE AND PEPPERONI

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: ubereats
Photo credit: grubhub
+14 photos
Photo credit: ubereats
+13 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Updated 07/29/25: The price increase is absolutely outrageous. $3 per slice. The pizzas have been cold, flimsy, chewy and dry lately. It’s still $1.55 in Wheeling for fresh, hot pizza with way more sauce and cheese than Westerville. When Brandon’s there it is absolutely perfect. Otherwise, it’s awful. We used to be weekly regulars. Unfortunately, it’s no longer worth the price.

We were so excited when the location opened back up with the new owner. He...
July 2025
If Brandon is working, I’m there. This dude can make pizza. I’m a transplant from the Steubenville, Ohio/Weirton, WV area, where I grew up on DiCarlo’s, and until now, my sons and I have had to drive over two hours to get our fix of Valley pizza. Well, now we don’t have to, cause there are two legit DiCarlo’s franchises right here in our own back yard. And both are very good. We especially like the Westerville location, though, because it’s closer for us, and Brandon...
June 2025
I just went back for the first time since they’ve been back open and I hope they make it. This seems like it should be right here very nice atmosphere. In this pizza I give it a 8 1/2
February 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Java Central Café and Roaster - 20 S State St Suite B
Coffee Shops, Coffee Roasteries, Cafe, Coffee
Thai Grille - 15 E College Ave
Thai, Asian, Gluten-Free, Vegan, Vegetarian
Schneider's Bakery - 6 S State St
Bakery, American

DiCarlo’s Pizza

20 S State St #K, Westerville, OH 43081
(614) 463-0522