Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern

400 Polaris Pkwy, Westerville
(614) 890-3663

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Rick

Rusty Bucket is a restaurant that is hitting on all cylinders. Specifically, they are not short staffed, the food is good and service is quick, there is a least one manager walking around that will help customers, and the menu is good. I would say great but two of my favorite things (meatloaf and Beef Stroganoff) come with Mushroom Gravy and I hate Mushrooms. My wife loves Mushrooms so she can eat them.

Dick

Outstanding Pub atmosphere! Great food, service and overall restaurant experience. Meatloaf and Stroganoff are both top notch.

Krista

We had a very nice time at Rusty Bucket. Our server was fantastic, and the food was good as always. We always come here when we are home visiting family. It's a tradition.

Lindsey Hansen

Always a great time. Great menu and selection. Double nickel salad is perfect and sweet potato fries are so tasty!

Daniel White

Excellent food and atmosphere. The haddock sandwich wasn't quite what I was expecting. Usually you get a large fillet on a hoggie but this was multiple small fillets on a hamburger bun but SO good. The lady had the meatloaf and said it was fantastic. Good drinks and good service made for a most pleasant evening.

Kveta Barber

Laura was EXCELLENT! Helpful, attentive, friendly. Food was delicious as usual!

Curtis Endicott

Great food as usual

Parkway Nutrition

Great place and our waitress Jessica was outstanding

Bud

Friends out to dinner. We shared the Brussels Sprouts for an appetizer. These are definitely delicious. Then, we shared a Sicilian Pizza for dinner. The pizza was very good. Nice flavors. Our server did a nice job as the restaurant was packed!! Thank you for your hard work.

Scott

A solid meal with great service. A good regional chain tavern/bar. If you liked Max & Erma's back when they were in the market, you will know this place. Same vibe with maybe slightly better food.

Louis DiFilippantonio

Everything was very good would have given it to Five Star but the food was just a tiny bit different than what I was used to her ready for, or what I remembered. But it was good

katherine

Waitress was attentive and provided good service. Food was good, but could've been warmer.

Judy

My only “complaint“ would be that the menu was quite limited and did not have the full meals like I was hoping for. That's a great place for sandwiches and beverages and there is one steak on the menu. I would like to see some more classic meals on the menu as well. But on the whole, this was an excellent restaurant.

JAyc

Cassie our server did a great job. KY Hot Bown on Sunday night's special. It was great especially the turkey. I will be back!!!!!

Mary

As usual, Rusty Bucket in Westerville was WONDERFUL in every aspect! We got seated right away. Our food was delicious & server was outstanding! We couldn't have asked for a better experience!

Loading...

Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern

400 Polaris Pkwy, Westerville, OH 43082
(614) 890-3663