One of the last great REAL bakeries in the city. Fresh variety of donuts all made in house. Cakes, cookies, treats. Very small town feel. In the heart of downtown Westerville.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bakery, Just a Little Taste of Heaven, Apple Fritter, Doughnut
Mrs. H.L. G-B
Absolutely wonderful! I've had their baked treats at functions and parties but today was my first trip inside. Classic & nostalgic. The staff were so friendly and happy about my excitement. Beautiful wedding cakes being made alongside breads and cookies, doughnuts and eclairs. Support local and stop by and consider them for your next party. ( not pictured was the blueberry doughnut I must've misplaced lol )
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
David G.
Great donuts, the way they were meant to be. Not Krispy Kreme, Dunkin, or Tim Hortons.
Heather
Beautiful cake for my daughter's wedding!!! The design was amazing and the taste was scrumptious!!! Twenty-two years ago, my mother in law had my wedding cake made here also and Schneider's is still the best in the business!! Highly recommend this phenomenal bakery!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mark Davis
10 out of 10 stars. What a gem! This small town bakery puts out fabulous pastries, pies, cookies and so much more!
Local favorite! I pick up donuts and cookies for my Otterbein students all year long!
AllTheBestVideos
Very friendly staff. I’m 100% serious when I say they have the best pastry’s I’ve ever tried. I would recommend to anyone in Westerville. Very well priced as well!
Great tasting donuts and other things! Just gotta eat them fast, they go stale quickly! But that’s how you know they aren’t full of a bunch of unnecessary preservatives! :)
JeffreyH811
Schneider's Bakery is a good option for most things sweet. Unfortunately my normal go to bakery has closed for good (Swiss Shop). The good news is that I found Schneider's Bakery. I was looking for a birthday cake for my wife and found this place. The person who answered the telephone was very helpful and knowledgeable. She took my order right away and I was able to pick it up in two days. The cake was perfect and everyone enjoyed it. I also picked up some other items from the show case when I arrived to pickup the cake. All items were great and I will be back again and again.
Ross Gordon
One of my favorite donut locations in town! I love taking my kids as an excuse to go, the service is wonderful and the selection is impeccable! I'll be stopping by again soon.
Melissa Whittington
It seems to be going downhill on the quality. I ordered A cake and pies, and both the Dutch Apple pie and the cake were underbaked, and the Dutch Apple pie also had so much of the cinnamon mixture that it was inedible (very bitter). We ate the cake anyhow as it wasn't so underbaked that it was a worry, but cake shouldn't have visible batter. On previous visits in the past year, items were either underbaked, stale, or simply jist disappointing. I figured I was just showing up on off days, but repeatedly suggests otherwise.
Bucknut
In, from out of town, I made it a point to get some fresh, delicious pastries. The donuts and cookies were delicious. I was surprised to see date pinwheels. They were delicious
My favorite bakery
Bad service. Day old
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Always very nice and their blueberry cake donuts are amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Custom Birthday Cake, Doughnut
One of the last great REAL bakeries in the city. Fresh variety of donuts all made in house. Cakes, cookies, treats. Very small town feel. In the heart of downtown Westerville.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bakery, Just a Little Taste of Heaven, Apple Fritter, Doughnut
Absolutely wonderful! I've had their baked treats at functions and parties but today was my first trip inside. Classic & nostalgic. The staff were so friendly and happy about my excitement. Beautiful wedding cakes being made alongside breads and cookies, doughnuts and eclairs. Support local and stop by and consider them for your next party. ( not pictured was the blueberry doughnut I must've misplaced lol )
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great donuts, the way they were meant to be. Not Krispy Kreme, Dunkin, or Tim Hortons.
Beautiful cake for my daughter's wedding!!! The design was amazing and the taste was scrumptious!!! Twenty-two years ago, my mother in law had my wedding cake made here also and Schneider's is still the best in the business!! Highly recommend this phenomenal bakery!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
10 out of 10 stars. What a gem! This small town bakery puts out fabulous pastries, pies, cookies and so much more!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bakery, Cream Horn, Round Glazed Donut, 5 Berry Pie, Blueberry Turnovers, Apple Puff Pastry, Sugar Twists, Iced Cake, Apple Fritter, Doughnut
Local favorite! I pick up donuts and cookies for my Otterbein students all year long!
Very friendly staff. I’m 100% serious when I say they have the best pastry’s I’ve ever tried. I would recommend to anyone in Westerville. Very well priced as well!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bakery, Cream Horn, Round Glazed Donut, Apple Fritter, Doughnut
Restaurantji Recommends
Great tasting donuts and other things! Just gotta eat them fast, they go stale quickly! But that’s how you know they aren’t full of a bunch of unnecessary preservatives! :)
Schneider's Bakery is a good option for most things sweet. Unfortunately my normal go to bakery has closed for good (Swiss Shop). The good news is that I found Schneider's Bakery. I was looking for a birthday cake for my wife and found this place. The person who answered the telephone was very helpful and knowledgeable. She took my order right away and I was able to pick it up in two days. The cake was perfect and everyone enjoyed it. I also picked up some other items from the show case when I arrived to pickup the cake. All items were great and I will be back again and again.
One of my favorite donut locations in town! I love taking my kids as an excuse to go, the service is wonderful and the selection is impeccable! I'll be stopping by again soon.
It seems to be going downhill on the quality. I ordered A cake and pies, and both the Dutch Apple pie and the cake were underbaked, and the Dutch Apple pie also had so much of the cinnamon mixture that it was inedible (very bitter). We ate the cake anyhow as it wasn't so underbaked that it was a worry, but cake shouldn't have visible batter. On previous visits in the past year, items were either underbaked, stale, or simply jist disappointing. I figured I was just showing up on off days, but repeatedly suggests otherwise.
In, from out of town, I made it a point to get some fresh, delicious pastries. The donuts and cookies were delicious. I was surprised to see date pinwheels. They were delicious