Love Gray Hoyse Pies ?Just pick up a AWESOME SunShine Pie (peach&cherry combo pie)All the pies here are seriously THE BEST!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Jacob Garretson
Amazing, 11/10 would recommend! They have so many great options.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Christina Higgins
I ordered pies for our family Christmas on Dec 5th. Due to having 4 adult kids and significant others we celebrate our Christmas the following week. On Dec 20th Gray House Pies called me to tell me that they could not fulfill my order because they will be closed that week. The website took my order and took my payment with no notice until Dec 20th when it was too late to order pies from anywhere else. I wanted more compensation than a credit for my order. The manager was going to ask the owner and no one ever called me back...they just credited my credit card for my order total. As a person that works with the public I know that this was terrible customer service! They should have at least given me a gift card for 2 pies in the future for good will.
Service: 1
Ludmila McNeeley
The $17 fruit cake was awful. Threw it in the garbage. The eggnog pie was just ok for $30
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Ryan Stoffko
This place is great! The pies are fresh, quality and made with care. The service is kind & informative. Have only been here once - but now I know where I will be getting future pies for Family Get-Togethers.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
c fields
Silly prices, just go to Heinens..
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Nancy W.
I hope somebody gets this because I am so disappointed. I ordered a chicken pot pie expecting the size of a 9 inch pie not a four-inch pie. I ordered mushrooms and cheese with it and I didn't get that. When I picked the order up the guy looked at me like he didn't know what I was talking about. $18.50 for this little pie that had a quarter cup of chicken maybe four carrots, with no peas and a lot of gravy. The $3 extra for mushrooms, and $3 extra for cheese that were not in the pie...really! I'm glad I didn't get this for the family it would've been embarrassed . So disappointing!!! I will not be back.
Emily Szymanski
Delicious! And Alex was very friendly and welcoming! A customer service pro!
Gary K.
Absolutely yummy delicious baked goods. Rivals the baked goods my mother and my grandmother would make!
Mona M.
Excellent selection. Pecan pie is absolutely delicious!
The pies are small and expensive, but they are good. However, beware when ordering online. My sister and I both ordered pies online for Father’s Day. When we separately went to pick up our orders we were told our orders weren’t ready. No phone call about it. I ordered this pie DAYS in advance. If we are able to select a time to pick up a pie it should be ready at that time. My sister went to pick up her pie and had to stand there and wait for them to make it. These were Father’s Day gifts. The pie I originally ordered my dad wasn’t available and I had to choose another. This just seems ridiculous that it happened to the both of us on the same weekend.
Shelley Rutger
Newly opened near Eclectic Lakewood. The quiche"s are delicious. Crust is light, flaky, and buttery tasting. They will soon have expresso, First Crack coffee, a cleveland roaster. Staff at the new shop are friendly and helpful.
Lisa Geisheimer
I’ve had their fruit pies once previously years ago and I remember not caring for them but we decided to order an apple and mixed berry pie last weekend for a family function. The remainder of nearly 2 full pies went into the trash yesterday. The filling in the fruit pies lacks flavor and the crust is not flaky. Although I appreciate their use of organic ingredients, I do not care for their pies.
Diana Pettyjohn
We have had pies and quiches from Gray House pies in the past that were good. I ordered two pies for Thanksgiving, apple and pecan. These pies were not cheap. The apple pie was mealy with a too soft crust. The pecan pie was ok but not the best.
Jim W.
Bought 5 pies for a rather large family Thanksgiving. Everyone appreciated the wonderful assortment and flavor.
Love Gray Hoyse Pies ?Just pick up a AWESOME SunShine Pie (peach&cherry combo pie)All the pies here are seriously THE BEST!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Amazing, 11/10 would recommend! They have so many great options.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I ordered pies for our family Christmas on Dec 5th. Due to having 4 adult kids and significant others we celebrate our Christmas the following week. On Dec 20th Gray House Pies called me to tell me that they could not fulfill my order because they will be closed that week. The website took my order and took my payment with no notice until Dec 20th when it was too late to order pies from anywhere else. I wanted more compensation than a credit for my order. The manager was going to ask the owner and no one ever called me back...they just credited my credit card for my order total. As a person that works with the public I know that this was terrible customer service! They should have at least given me a gift card for 2 pies in the future for good will.
Service: 1
The $17 fruit cake was awful. Threw it in the garbage. The eggnog pie was just ok for $30
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
This place is great! The pies are fresh, quality and made with care. The service is kind & informative. Have only been here once - but now I know where I will be getting future pies for Family Get-Togethers.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Silly prices, just go to Heinens..
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
I hope somebody gets this because I am so disappointed. I ordered a chicken pot pie expecting the size of a 9 inch pie not a four-inch pie. I ordered mushrooms and cheese with it and I didn't get that. When I picked the order up the guy looked at me like he didn't know what I was talking about. $18.50 for this little pie that had a quarter cup of chicken maybe four carrots, with no peas and a lot of gravy. The $3 extra for mushrooms, and $3 extra for cheese that were not in the pie...really! I'm glad I didn't get this for the family it would've been embarrassed . So disappointing!!! I will not be back.
Delicious! And Alex was very friendly and welcoming! A customer service pro!
Absolutely yummy delicious baked goods. Rivals the baked goods my mother and my grandmother would make!
Excellent selection. Pecan pie is absolutely delicious!
Restaurantji Recommends
The pies are small and expensive, but they are good. However, beware when ordering online. My sister and I both ordered pies online for Father’s Day. When we separately went to pick up our orders we were told our orders weren’t ready. No phone call about it. I ordered this pie DAYS in advance. If we are able to select a time to pick up a pie it should be ready at that time. My sister went to pick up her pie and had to stand there and wait for them to make it. These were Father’s Day gifts. The pie I originally ordered my dad wasn’t available and I had to choose another. This just seems ridiculous that it happened to the both of us on the same weekend.
Newly opened near Eclectic Lakewood. The quiche"s are delicious. Crust is light, flaky, and buttery tasting. They will soon have expresso, First Crack coffee, a cleveland roaster. Staff at the new shop are friendly and helpful.
I’ve had their fruit pies once previously years ago and I remember not caring for them but we decided to order an apple and mixed berry pie last weekend for a family function. The remainder of nearly 2 full pies went into the trash yesterday. The filling in the fruit pies lacks flavor and the crust is not flaky. Although I appreciate their use of organic ingredients, I do not care for their pies.
We have had pies and quiches from Gray House pies in the past that were good. I ordered two pies for Thanksgiving, apple and pecan. These pies were not cheap. The apple pie was mealy with a too soft crust. The pecan pie was ok but not the best.
Bought 5 pies for a rather large family Thanksgiving. Everyone appreciated the wonderful assortment and flavor.