Worthington Tavern

671 High St, Worthington
(614) 396-6052

Recent Reviews Order Online Reserve

Customers' Favorites

Bang Bang Salmon Dinner
Crispy Chicken Sandwich
Cedar Roasted Salmon
Creole Shrimp Pasta
OKC Smash Burger
Breakfast Pizza
Chicken & Pasta
Asparagus Ceasar
Burger Deluxe
French Fries

Menu

Shareables
Smoked Chicken Wings
Smoked and fried chicken wings topped with shredded celery served with a side of bleu cheese. Your choice of Hot Honey, Zesty White BBQ, or Buffalo. Wing Allergens: Gluten and soy **Can not be made gluten-free or soy free Sauce Allergens: White BBQ: Egg Buffalo: Dairy Hot Honey: N/A
Tangy BBQ Ribs
St. Louis-style BBQ glazed ribs topped with fried onions, fried broccoli, and peppers. Allergens: Soy, gluten, and sesame seed Dietary Adjustments: GF without glaze sauce and onions. Soy free without glaze and broccoli.
Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail
Four Jumbo Shrimp served with a creamy house cocktail sauce and charred lemon. Allergens: Shellfish and egg Dietary Adjustments: Regular cocktail sauce for egg allergy
Meatball
Giant meatball smothered in fire-roasted marinara drizzled with a balsamic gastrique and topped with parmesan cheese. Served with garlic bread. Allergens: Gluten and dairy **Can not be made GF or dairy free Dietary Adjustments: N/A
Whipped Eggplant
Whipped eggplant dip served with puccia bread that is topped with olive oil and salt. Allergens: Dairy and gluten **Can not be made dairy free Dietary Adjustments: Puccia bread can be replaced with crudite for a GF option

Salad
Asparagus Ceasar
Grilled asparagus topped with vegan Caesar dressing, and pecorino romano. Served with croutons and anchovy. Allergens: Dairy, gluten, and fish Dietary Adjustments: GF without croutons, dairy free with no cheese topping. Fish free without anchovy side
Wedge
Baby gem lettuce, egg, bacon confit tomato, and bacon bits. Topped with bleu cheese and a port glaze drizzle. Allergens: Dairy and egg Dietarty Adjustments: Sub vinaigrette as a dairy free option. Remove egg for egg allergy
Seasonal Salad
Spinach base with strawberries, blueberries, kiwi, and pickled red onions. Topped with feta cheese, almond granola and a light lemon vinaigrette. Allergens: Dairy, nuts, and gluten Dietary Adjustments: Remove almond granola for a GF and nut free option. Remove Feta for dairy free option

Sandwiches
Crispy Chicken Sandwich
Fried chicken breast with au poivre aioli, B&B pickles, and buttercrunch lettuce. Allergens: Dairy, egg, and gluton Dietary Adjustments: Remove au poivre aioli for dairy and egg free option. Sub GF bun for GF option. Vegan patty available
OKC Smash Burger
Two smashed patties, tavern sauce, American cheese, charred & pickled onion, shredded lettuce, and pickles. Allergens: Gluten, dairy, sesame seed, and egg Dietary Adjustments: GF bun available for gluten and sesame seed allergies. Dairy-free with the removal of American cheese. Egg-free option with the removal of tavern sauce
Burger Deluxe
½LB wagyu patty, steakhouse aioli, Swiss, caramelized onion, roasted mushroom, shredded lettuce, pickles. Allergens: Dairy, gluten, sesame seed, egg Dietary Adjustments: GF bun available for gluten and sesame seed allergies. Dairy free with the removal of Swiss cheese. Egg free option with the removal of steakhouse aioli
Not Your Ave Joe
House-made spicy vegan joe mix topped with fried onion straws on a vegan bun. Allergens: Soy and Flower **Can not be made soy-free Dietary Adjustments: Bun can be substituted for a GF bun for a GF option. The GF bun is not vegan.

Pizza
Caprese
House made pizza sauce on fresh pizza dough coated in garlic oil. Topped with mozzarella, basil, and a balsamic drizzle. Allergens: Dairy and gluten Dietary Adjustments: Sub cauliflower crust for a GF option. Remove cheese for dairy free option
Soppressata
Fresh pizza dough coated in garlic oil and house made pizza sauce. Topped with soppressata, mozzarella, and drizzled hot honey. Allergens: Dairy and gluten Dietary Adjustments: Sub cauliflower crust for a GF option. Remove cheese for dairy free option
White Pizza
Fresh pizza dough coated in garlic oil and EVOO. Topped with spinach, rosemary, roasted garlic, feta, pecorino, and arugula. Allergens: Dairy and gluten Dietary Adjustments: Sub cauliflower crust for a GF option. Remove cheese for dairy free option

Mains
Hearth Baked Half Chicken
Hearth-baked chicken seasoned with herbs, over a bed of asparagus and couscous. Served with tzatziki sauce. Allergens: Gluten and dairy Dietary Adjustments: No couscous for the GF option and no tzatziki for dairy free option
Piccante Pasta À La Vodka
Rigatoni with Calabrian chili vodka sauce, parmigiano reggiano, olive oil, and basil **Spicy Dish Allergens: Dairy and gluten Dietary Adjustments: Dairy-free option with no cheese and replacing vodka sauce with marinara. GF penne is available.
Tavern Steak Frites
10 oz prime ribeye topped with garlic herb butter. Served with a side of steak fries and tavern sauce. Allergens: Dairy Dietary Adjustments: Dairy free with the removal of herb butter
Bang Bang Salmon
Blackened salmon on a bed of jasmine rice and Bok choy. drizzled with avocado-cilantro sauce, sriracha aioli, and sweet soy. topped with fried onions and sesame seeds Allergens: Gluten, soy, sesame seed, and fish Dietary Adjustments: For a GF option remove fried onions and sweet soy. For soy free remove sweet soy. sesame seeds can be removed from dish and salmon can be subbed out for chicken.
Mediterranean Pasta
Pasta covered in garlic olive oil cooked with cherry tomatoes, artichokes, basil, and kalamata olives. Topped with Parmesan cheese Allergens: Dairy and gluten Dietary Adjustments: GF pasta available upon request. Cheese can be removed for a dairy free option.

Sides
Beer Battered Fries
Allergens: Gluten
Couscous
Allergens : Gluten
Roasted Green Beans
Allergens: N/A
Roasted Asparagus
Allergens : N/A
Fried Broccoli
Allergens : Soy
Sauteed Broccoli
Allergens : Gluten Dietary Adjustments: Can be made GF
Bread
Allergens: Gluten
Tossed Salad
Allergens: N/A
Crudite
Allergens: N/A
Puccia Bread
Allergens: Gluten
GF: Steak Fries
Allergens: N/A

Kids Dinner
Kids Buttered Noodles
Allergens: Dairy and gluten Dietary: GF noodles are available upon request. No cheese for a dairy-free option
Kids Cheese Pizza
Allergens: Gluten and dairy Dietary Adjustments: No cheese for a dairy-free option. GF crust avaibalbe
Kids Cheeseburger
Allergens: Gluten, dairy, and sesame seed Dietary Adjustments: For sesame seed and gluten allergies please select GF bun
Kids Chicken Fingers
Allergens: Gluten, egg, and dairy
Kids Grilled Cheese Strips
Allergens: Dairy and gluten
Kids Hamburger
Allergens: Gluten and sesame seed Dietary Adjustments: For sesame seed and gluten allergies please select GF bun
Kids Salmon
Allergens: Fish
Kids Steak
Allergens: N/A

Kids Dinner Sides
Kids Fries
Allergens: Gluten
Kids Fruit Cup
Allergens: N/A
Kids Green Beans
Allergens: N/A
Kids Toss Salad
Allergens: N/A
Kids GF Fries
Allergen: N/A

Sweets
Charred Cheesecake
Charred cheesecake drizzled in caramel and served with a side of seasonal fruit compote and cookie crumble. Allergens: Egg, dairy, and gluten Dietary Adjustments: Can be made GF with the removal of the cookie crumble
Salted Butterscotch Budino
Salted butterscotch pudding topped with amaretto cream and a shortbread cookie. Allergens: Gluten, dairy, and egg Dietary Adjustments: GF when the cookie is removed

Extras
Au Poivre Aioli
Allergens: Egg
Blue Cheese Crumbles
Allergens: Dairy
Blue Cheese Dressing
Allergens: Dairy
Buffalo Sauce
Allergens: Dairy
Tzatziki Sauce
Allergens: Dairy
Herb Butter
Allergens: Dairy
Hot Honey
Allergens: N/A
Marinara
Allergens: N/A
Mayonnaise
Allergens: Egg
Ranch Dressing
Allergens: Dairy
Steakhouse Aioli
Allergens: Egg
Tavern Sauce
Allergens: Egg and Fish
White BBQ
Allergens: Egg
Port Drizzle
Allergens: N/A
Creamy Cocktail
Allergens: Egg
Sriracha Aioli
Allergens: Egg
Sweet Soy
Allergens: Gluten and soy
Avocado-Cilantro Aioli
Allergens: Egg

MERCHANDISE
Peacock Tiki Cup

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+55 photos
Photo credit: tripadvisor
+54 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Dined here with my husband and adult son. Our first time at Worthington Tavern. We all had the Smash Burgers which were very good. My husband was raving about his Old Fashioned. The service was great! We will definitely be back!
October 2025
This visit was fantastic. We arrived during happy hour, so we enjoyed drinks for nine bucks or less. We started with some Brussels sprouts and oysters, and a kid had some chicken tenders. Everything was reasonably priced at that time.
September 2025
I had won a gift card here when I had went to an event with my friend in Dublin last year & I was absolutely wowed! My friend and I love brunch and we will be back. The only issue I had was finding parking but nonetheless very good!
July 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

The Old Bag of Nails Pub - Old Worthington - 663 High St
Pubs, Fish & Chips, American, Bar
Jet's Pizza - 660 High St
Pizza, Vegetarian
Peace, Love and Little Donuts of Worthington - 656 High St
Donuts

Worthington Tavern

671 High St, Worthington, OH 43085
(614) 396-6052