After moving to Ohio 20+ yrs ago from Jersey pizza was best in Ohio the brick oven and dough / sauce made it . Would recommend D. Portnoy from Barstool make time for a visit…
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lauren Rasor
Family owned business! We asked a local where to eat and they recommended Tat’s Pizza. It was delicious and your typical hometown pizza joint. A must visit when in Zanesville!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Elliott Windrope
Super friendly staff who let us eat despite arriving fifteen minutes before close. Excellent pizza I would go here again in a heartbeat!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pat Anderson
The pizza is good. The rest of it was trash. The Alfredo tasted like exactly what you could buy in a banquet frozen meal. The ravioli was worse than chef boyardee. The cheesy bread was just cheese on bread. It’s like they’ve never heard of seasoning. I can’t believe I used to like that awful Italian dressing when I was younger. Straight trash. It burned my tongue. It’s like dumping gasoline into your salad. And don’t even think about a salad if you have any lactose issues. Half of it was cheese. It’s 2025. Time to evolve. Start with some flavor.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 5
Tom Headley
Went to Tats this evening 4 of us sat there for 15 minutes. Watched the waitress on her phone. People at another table got up to get a refill on her drink. So no one came out to us so we got up and left. Told the girl at the cash register. Thanks for the service tonight. She said Oh Thank you. I told her, no you don't understand we have been here for 15 minutes and no one acked like they wanted to wait on us. So we are leaving. Plus there was several tables dirty. So not sure what was going on there tonight.
Service: 1
Trent Bowshier
Were regulars on Friday with the large spaghetti mushroom and meat balls
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Beautiful World
Very clean and exceptional service.
The food rating is only based on pizza as that is all we had. The crust was not really a pizza dough; it was more like a cracker dough. Though that seems to be typical of most small town pizzerias in Ohio, so maybe someone else would give it more stars.
The server was bringing someone else a salad that looked great! 😸
I would definitely recommend this restaurant to everyone!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Troy Barton
Excellent pizza!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Renee Jesus freak Love
Tat's never disappoints! My favorite menu item is a salad with cheese and their homemade Italian dressing!
Jason Palmer
Pizza was great, we got the medium deluxe, was our 1st time visiting, will def be going back.
I'm half Italian! The food here is terrible! The people Zanesville deserve so much better than this. The meatballs reminded me of what you might find at a retirement home or poorly-funded school cafeteria. The garlic bread was like cardboard. The salads were way too salty. Pasta sauce was very strange! IDK why so many people think this restaurant is good. Service was fast, so that's okay...
Paul Shover
Phenomenally delicious but a tad pricey.
13cdtowns
The food was awesome, the service was mediocre at the best. Took forever for refills and right before they closed they offered to go cups but no refills we were disappointed in that
Nessa D
Food was good. Fast and hot. The waitress was very nice. The pizza was super thin one side- the pep was thicker than the crust. The other side was good. The place was super nice inside. We were only people in there. The straws are wrapped in with the silverware which is a fantastic idea!!
After moving to Ohio 20+ yrs ago from Jersey pizza was best in Ohio the brick oven and dough / sauce made it . Would recommend D. Portnoy from Barstool make time for a visit…
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Family owned business! We asked a local where to eat and they recommended Tat’s Pizza. It was delicious and your typical hometown pizza joint. A must visit when in Zanesville!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Super friendly staff who let us eat despite arriving fifteen minutes before close. Excellent pizza I would go here again in a heartbeat!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza is good. The rest of it was trash. The Alfredo tasted like exactly what you could buy in a banquet frozen meal. The ravioli was worse than chef boyardee. The cheesy bread was just cheese on bread. It’s like they’ve never heard of seasoning. I can’t believe I used to like that awful Italian dressing when I was younger. Straight trash. It burned my tongue. It’s like dumping gasoline into your salad. And don’t even think about a salad if you have any lactose issues. Half of it was cheese.
It’s 2025. Time to evolve. Start with some flavor.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 5
Went to Tats this evening 4 of us sat there for 15 minutes. Watched the waitress on her phone. People at another table got up to get a refill on her drink. So no one came out to us so we got up and left. Told the girl at the cash register. Thanks for the service tonight. She said Oh Thank you. I told her, no you don't understand we have been here for 15 minutes and no one acked like they wanted to wait on us. So we are leaving. Plus there was several tables dirty. So not sure what was going on there tonight.
Service: 1
Were regulars on Friday with the large spaghetti mushroom and meat balls
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very clean and exceptional service.
The food rating is only based on pizza as that is all we had. The crust was not really a pizza dough; it was more like a cracker dough. Though that seems to be typical of most small town pizzerias in Ohio, so maybe someone else would give it more stars.
The server was bringing someone else a salad that looked great! 😸
I would definitely recommend this restaurant to everyone!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Excellent pizza!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tat's never disappoints!
My favorite menu item is a salad with cheese and their homemade Italian dressing!
Pizza was great, we got the medium deluxe, was our 1st time visiting, will def be going back.
Restaurantji Recommends
Great pizza friendly staff
I'm half Italian! The food here is terrible! The people Zanesville deserve so much better than this. The meatballs reminded me of what you might find at a retirement home or poorly-funded school cafeteria. The garlic bread was like cardboard. The salads were way too salty. Pasta sauce was very strange! IDK why so many people think this restaurant is good. Service was fast, so that's okay...
Phenomenally delicious but a tad pricey.
The food was awesome, the service was mediocre at the best. Took forever for refills and right before they closed they offered to go cups but no refills we were disappointed in that
Food was good. Fast and hot. The waitress was very nice. The pizza was super thin one side- the pep was thicker than the crust. The other side was good. The place was super nice inside. We were only people in there. The straws are wrapped in with the silverware which is a fantastic idea!!
Loading...