Pizza Restaurants near Afton

“Goodfellas is a small pizza place less than 2 miles from a small community I am visiting on Grand Lake. There aren't many options around here, and I didn't have high expectations going in. I was pleasantly surprised with the service, quality and flavor of the pizza and wings we ordered. I had the bacon cheeseburger pizza on gluten free crust, which was crisp and loaded with toppings. My family tried "The Hoffa" "The Boss" and "The Hitman". Everyone was impressed with the flavor, but especially impressed by the thin crust as it was crisp throughout and not burnt on the edges.“

“We were here during spring break. Didn't seem busy sat immediately with a noon arrival. The place is nice and comfortable. The food was excellent. Smash Burger was better than most and the Nashville hot chicken was the best I've had anywhere not to hot but tasty and hung over the “

“If you're out on Monkey Island or spending a day at the lake, the personalized pizzas are a must have. They're great when cooked fresh and still warm however, if you get an old one, don't be disappointed. Boxes are always labeled with a time stamp, so be sure to check that before purchasing.I personally have not ordered a to-go pizza made to order from this location so I cannot speak on how those are made or taste.I have always been a Simple Simon's fan, this location is no different from other gas station Simple Simon's.“