Mama Mia What A Pizza

7471 NW 23rd St, Bethany
(405) 367-7144

Recent Reviews

nagatomo masako

Best vegetable pizza in Bethany!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza

J.C. Stallings

If you believe in miracles then don't order from here. It would be a miracle if your order was correct even once!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Elohim Flooring

Delapedated establishment. Seems they don't care anymore, definitely not trying to impress in any way shape or form. I question the freshness of the product. We won't be returning.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 4

Dr. Spazz

I have been around America. Iv tried pizza from everywhere. Hands down, they have the best. They don't taste like anyone else's pizza they have their own style, and I'll be honest, whatever that style is, it deserves a Michelin star! Gordon Ramsey would cry at the taste of this amazing pizza

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza

keith benjamin

Delapedated establishment. Seems they don't care anymore, definitely not trying to impress in any way shape or form. I question the freshness of the product. We won't be returning.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 4

dio's left nut

great food for a good price; the owners were nice and you can tell that they care about what they do. very expansive menu, and can’t wait to try other things out!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Michael Seeds

Trying to order dinner. The guy says we’re on a break. Told me to call back in 30 minutes. He was very rude will never go there again. Remind you this was 5:00pm. I can see why they got so many bad reviews.

raelene montiel

I ordered 2 pizzas last night with a side of wings, breadsticks and marinara sauce. When I had gotten home and opened the pizza boxes, they were paper thin and all the toppings were falling off because it was flopping over from being so thin. When I called, I was told that maybe I ordered thin crust, but I never said anything about thin crust. The wings were also hard and barely had any sauce on them. I called just to let them know because obviously I won’t be coming back and all they did was try and excuse the quality of food they had provided to me. If you buy from here, make sure you open the pizza before taking it home or taking it from a delivery service, because they won’t honor your word for it. I regret tipping the girl.

Heather Launa Day

I hate to leave bad reviews but this place is not good at all. I think if they just had a Greek restaurant it would be ok but even the Gyro was not traditional. I think they should close to be honest.

Pam

Not enthused about the cold sauce served aside my calazone. It was hot, and fairly filled as a veggie one goes. Personnel was nice and friendly, food was ready when I got there, I ordered online.Vegetarian options: Veggie calazone, needs better sauce.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 5

Jonathan Lyles

Ordered online, wanted a calzone and this place was near where I needed to go yesterday for lunch to do an errand. I was called after I placed my order to tell me they couldn't do what I had put on the calzone online. Basically I had removed the sausage and added pineapple. When I asked why they couldn't since the online menu let me do it, I got a rude response saying he was canceling my order. Just for asking a question. Won't order here again and will tell anyone I know not to there.

Jessalynn Stephenson

Basically frozen pizza, not good or worth the money. Garlic knots were like little oily rocks. Customer service nonexistent, they just pointed to the food on the counter. Won't go back.

Jeremy Obregon

I got a chicken Alfredo pizza and it was so delicious! My fiance ended up getting a chicken salad and everything in that salad was fresh and tasted great! Love this place, definitely planning on ordering here again

Tammi

Great pizza very friendly people love visiting with them if you live in Bethany,Ok I recommend you try it out even if you are just passing through stop in tell them Tammi sent you ❤️❤️❤️??

Jerri Groschick

This is our favorite restaurant for NY style pizza, pasta, calzones, and sandwiches. Paul and his wife are so kind and welcoming. They use the freshest and finest ingredients. The prices are great too. My husband had a gyro tonight and I had a veggie calzone. Everything was exceptional. I wish I had know about this long before now. Can't wait to eat there again.

Load More