Thoroughly enjoyed the pizza. Cooked to perfection and very delicious.
bacon pope
It can get warm when they are churning out pizzas. When you get yours, you understand.
Ralene Sunshine
Papa Angelo’s is the place to go! The staff is amazing! The food is phenomenal. Definitely a place to try if you haven’t already.
Sana Ghounajoqa
Maybe they were having a bad day, but we came here to try their pizza out and it was not good. Flavor was really bland, and I was hoping for $16 small pizza to have fresh mushrooms. Also topping were barely warm as if they did not have time to cook. Sadly, I don’t think we’ll come back
L Hardman
The pizza was so good. It was like having a New Yorker pizza. The atmosphere is wonderful it makes you wanna stay and hang out. A day that I went they have music playing and Peggy Johnson. It was wonderful. They came and checked on us periodically to make sure that we did not need anything. That’s definitely a place that I will return to eat.
Dustin Clements
Great pizza fresh made to order!!
Chris Zuraff
A treat!! Authentic big new Yorker pies from Authentic New yorkers. Chose from their selection or create your own. Good hot or for late cravings. And don't forget to check out all the history on the walls while you wait
Jake Doberenz
A bit of a small, cramped location. I also felt like I needed more than one slice to be full—it tasted pretty good but I have had better.
James Pebworth
Descent pizza joint. Was good for a change...
jenna debo
Perfect. Great family owned restaurant, great staff and great pizza.
Good pizza, but EXTREMELY overpriced. Won’t do it again. Nearly $40 for a medium pizza with garlic knots.
Blake Miller
Pizza was way too greasy. Ranch was gross.
David Kamenesky
First time coming here from Missouri. Excellent Pizza. Can't wait to come back!
Victoria Niesel
Pizza was burnt. 🥲 the garlic knots were okay. Also a little burnt. domino's is way better. 🤷♀️
Patsy J Langley
I used to love this place the cheese they used before was amazing so flavorful I don't know what changed, used to be worth the high price now is just meh :(
Thoroughly enjoyed the pizza. Cooked to perfection and very delicious.
It can get warm when they are churning out pizzas. When you get yours, you understand.
Papa Angelo’s is the place to go! The staff is amazing! The food is phenomenal. Definitely a place to try if you haven’t already.
Maybe they were having a bad day, but we came here to try their pizza out and it was not good. Flavor was really bland, and I was hoping for $16 small pizza to have fresh mushrooms. Also topping were barely warm as if they did not have time to cook. Sadly, I don’t think we’ll come back
The pizza was so good. It was like having a New Yorker pizza. The atmosphere is wonderful it makes you wanna stay and hang out. A day that I went they have music playing and Peggy Johnson. It was wonderful. They came and checked on us periodically to make sure that we did not need anything. That’s definitely a place that I will return to eat.
Great pizza fresh made to order!!
A treat!! Authentic big new Yorker pies from Authentic New yorkers. Chose from their selection or create your own. Good hot or for late cravings. And don't forget to check out all the history on the walls while you wait
A bit of a small, cramped location. I also felt like I needed more than one slice to be full—it tasted pretty good but I have had better.
Descent pizza joint. Was good for a change...
Perfect. Great family owned restaurant, great staff and great pizza.
Restaurantji Recommends
Good pizza, but EXTREMELY overpriced. Won’t do it again. Nearly $40 for a medium pizza with garlic knots.
Pizza was way too greasy. Ranch was gross.
First time coming here from Missouri. Excellent Pizza. Can't wait to come back!
Pizza was burnt. 🥲 the garlic knots were okay. Also a little burnt. domino's is way better. 🤷♀️
I used to love this place the cheese they used before was amazing so flavorful I don't know what changed, used to be worth the high price now is just meh :(
Loading...