Papa Angelo's Pizzeria

6744 NW 39th Expy, Bethany
(405) 491-6767

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

New Yorker Pep and Sausage Pizza
Cheese Pizza Pepperoni Pizza
Supreme Pizza the Empire Size
Just the Way You Like
Classic Cheese Pizza
New Yorker Supreme
Slices of Pizza
Garlic Knots 6
Lunch Special
Smoked Bacon

Menu

Pizza

Empire Pizza 20"
New Yorker Cheese 18"
Large Cheese 18"
Medium Cheese 14"
Small Cheese 12"
Little Joe 8"
10" Gluten-Free Crust Pizza
Joe's White Pizza
Pizza topped with ricotta instead of marinara, mozzarella, tomatoes, and garlic.

Pasta

Manicotti
Baked Ziti
Spaghetti
Meatball
Calzone
Ricotta and Mozzarella. Comes with a side of marinara.

Salad

Garden Salad
Onion, bell pepper, tomato, black olive.

Garlic Knots

6 Garlic Knots
Half dozen.

Sides

Side Of Ranch
Side Of Garlic Oil
Side Of Marinara Sauce
Side Of Habanero Sauce
Side Of Reaper Sauce
Side of Topping

Beverages
Large Fountain Drink
Small Fountain Drink
Can Of Soda
2 Liter

Dessert
1 Cannoli
2 Cannoli
Cake
Cheesecake
Candy Bars
Chips

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+57 photos
Photo credit: foursquare
+56 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

We are so happy to have walked in & ate at this awesome pizza place!!!! Great service, delicious food & I love the New Yor City vibes!!!! Super neat place!
We are looking forward to being back many times!!!!
December 2025
I love this place. Genuinely one of the best places to get pizza in the state not to mention the kindest staff I have dealt with! Every time I come in they greet me like a friend. I stay in way north of the restaurant and I will drive down just to eat. Can’t recommend this place enough!
December 2025
Outstanding New York style pizza! Aware that the Large is really very large. Excellent quality - atmosphere is very authentic hole in the wall New York style pizzeria. Enjoyed the pizza Hawaii and the New York pepperoni!
August 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Serve Coffee & Community - 6736 NW 39th Expy
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Community Service/Non-Profit, Coffee
Stray Dog Cafe - 6722 NW 39th Expy
American, Cafe, Burgers, Vegetarian
Birrieria Diaz - 6700 NW 39th Expy
Mexican, Vegan, Vegetarian, Cocktail Bar

Papa Angelo's Pizzeria

6744 NW 39th Expy, Bethany, OK 73008
(405) 491-6767