Notorious P.I.E. Pizza

305 E Main St, Norman
(405) 310-2390

Recent Reviews

Nequel B.

Visited for the first time today. Cute spot on Main Street. You can park on the street or in the back parking lot. The vibe of this place is chill it also has an old school vibe. The music was great and our server did a great job with our large party. The restaurant knew to expect us and our appetizers came right out. The food was delicious.

Berenice W.

Great Pizzas, the fried cheese NY is one of the best tasting pizzas I've ever had in OK. The sizes are HUGE, so they're best whenever you're hungry plus they reheat extremely well so don't be afraid of taking leftovers home.

RickandSunny Casey

very understanding of gluten free diets.

Hailey G.

Food was so good! Bartender was super helpful and nice. Definitely will be visiting again

Jacque S.

Another great recommendation! Believe me, this pizza.... Oh my goodness, mind blown! This place is located downtown Norman, very cute area. I took my first bite and was in heaven! We had the NY style with pepperoni and green peppers. The staff was very kind and the atmosphere is fun but also laid back. Looks like a great place for the college kids, but parent-friendly too! We were only able to eat half of it, luckily we met a group of polite young men who took the rest home. (I hate wasting amazing food)

Ryan Rafferty

We came during happy hour between 3-6 and the prices are great. We had appetizers, a couple of slices, a mixed drink, and sodas for around $20 and it was all delicious. The staff was very nice and the restaurant was clean.

A P.

Pizza is good. I was surprised that the garlic bread was on a bun and not their pizza dough. I really liked their veg pizza. Marinara sauce is good and thick.

Courtney Lay

delicious food, great staff, and so supportive of the community organizations. love them!

Nancy M

Best pizza ever! Especially if you're gluten-free. I hope they can make mushroom crust as well as the cauliflower one but still yummy. Quality ingredients, cooked to perfection. And staff there are super nice.

Jeff C.

Best crust I've ever eaten! I love this place. Whether it's a slice and salad for lunch or a whole pie, it's always great. I'm still trying to figure out what my favorite is. Oh and they support the local community too

Janet D.

Delicious food, fun atmosphere and friendly staff. :-) We loved it!

Andrea Banaj

This has been the absolute worse experience with take out that I've ever had. They burnt one of the pizzas so bad that it was inedible. When I took it back and asked for a refund they refunded $20 just to turn around and add $20 for "changes made to the order" when no changes were made.Worse than the poor quality, the back and forth to pick up and return, was them being dishonest about the refund. DO NOT RECOMMEND

Dusty Follis

Such a fun place to grab a slice of pie.

Terry J.

Great Chicago deep dish pies and pretty decent jalapeño hummus. Drinks were nice, girlfriend and I had a great time.

Yankee

I think this was the worst pizza I ever had.I appreciate that it was cooked in fired oven. But the crust on the bottom was hard as a rock while the top was soggy, raw dough. It is a very large pizza, though.Also appreciate that the sauce seems to be made with fresh cherry tomatoes, but it was sickeningly sweet. I think they added sugar to the sauce that was already using a very sweet variety of tomato.One of the slices had some rock hard shell-like thing when I bit into it and nearly broke my teeth. I don't know what it was.As for the hummus, it was tasty. But the croutons were dry and hard as a rock.Even if it tasted great, I probably wouldn't come back just because $22 for a pizza is pretty high, even if it is huge.

Load More