I ordered the mud pie and it was a massive disappointment, the consistency was just a melted milkshake that I was having to eat with a spoon. The brownie was ok but no better than the Great Value ones at the grocery store. Definitely overpriced as well.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 4
Bill S.
Something might be wrong with you if you don't like this place. Great selections of different custards. Flavors galore and many favorite toppings to choose from. Great spot to go after dinner.
Lyndye Steen
This is my favorite custard place! They have such great options to choose from.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Harper Murray
really good custard, had the union boss, 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Union Boss
ScarlettEclaire
Thanks for the rec, Seth!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Love Machine, Union Boss
Mallory A.
GREAT ICE CREAM!!! My friends and I will be stopping here everyday until we have to move.
Brittany Miller
My sister took me to Rusty's as its one of her favorite places. It was so good
Rebecca H.
It is a Norman, Oklahoma classic. I highly recommend the Razzmatazz, Pumpkin pie, and one of my favorites is The Foreman. The service is really great and the fastest around!!!
James Auschwitz
Awesome! The custard was so good. I had the Flying Elvis concrete with peanut butter and banana, which was a hunka, hunka burning love, but I don't think you could go wrong with anything on that menu
Chad W.
Our go to treat place when we are downtown. Has been since he used to have his two other locations instead. It's not cheap but it's local and great
Great custard and equally awesome service that is friendly and welcoming
Jeffrey Baughman II
The staff was nice and friendly. The concretes were great!
Mari Newcomer
Employees were happy and attentive. Custard was great! Loved sitting outside.
MarciLynn
Super cute custard shop with lots of unique options! The service was great and environment welcoming. They even gave us the left over root beer from our order! Super fun find.
Matthew Brown
Rusty's is a local favorites, especially when the summer months get into full swing here in central OK! They have a huge number of toppings/mix-ins to pick from, ranging from fresh fruit to every candy bar imaginable. Their custard is luxuriously smooth and the combinations are endless, so there's always something new to try! Admittedly it's not the cheapest, but it's well worth the price for a sweet, creamy treat!
I ordered the mud pie and it was a massive disappointment, the consistency was just a melted milkshake that I was having to eat with a spoon. The brownie was ok but no better than the Great Value ones at the grocery store. Definitely overpriced as well.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 4
Something might be wrong with you if you don't like this place. Great selections of different custards. Flavors galore and many favorite toppings to choose from. Great spot to go after dinner.
This is my favorite custard place! They have such great options to choose from.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
really good custard, had the union boss, 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Union Boss
Thanks for the rec, Seth!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Love Machine, Union Boss
GREAT ICE CREAM!!! My friends and I will be stopping here everyday until we have to move.
My sister took me to Rusty's as its one of her favorite places. It was so good
It is a Norman, Oklahoma classic. I highly recommend the Razzmatazz, Pumpkin pie, and one of my favorites is The Foreman. The service is really great and the fastest around!!!
Awesome! The custard was so good. I had the Flying Elvis concrete with peanut butter and banana, which was a hunka, hunka burning love, but I don't think you could go wrong with anything on that menu
Our go to treat place when we are downtown. Has been since he used to have his two other locations instead. It's not cheap but it's local and great
Restaurantji Recommends
Great custard and equally awesome service that is friendly and welcoming
The staff was nice and friendly. The concretes were great!
Employees were happy and attentive. Custard was great! Loved sitting outside.
Super cute custard shop with lots of unique options! The service was great and environment welcoming. They even gave us the left over root beer from our order! Super fun find.
Rusty's is a local favorites, especially when the summer months get into full swing here in central OK! They have a huge number of toppings/mix-ins to pick from, ranging from fresh fruit to every candy bar imaginable. Their custard is luxuriously smooth and the combinations are endless, so there's always something new to try! Admittedly it's not the cheapest, but it's well worth the price for a sweet, creamy treat!