The Ice Creamatory
1200 12th Ave SE, Norman
(516) 581-6601
Customers' Favorites
Custom Ice Cream Cone My Kid’S Creation
Creat-Your-Own Pepermint Patty & Cherry
Monster Squad with Reese's Pieces
Mrs Voorhees Apple Pie
Cinnamon Toast Crunch
Captain Spaulding
Wednesday Addams
Green Apple Pie
Create Your Own
Trick or Treat
Menu
Photos
+7 photos
+6 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
This place is absolutely amazing! The decor and atmosphere has me speechless when I opened the door. This was our first visit and I can’t complain one bit. The lady that greeted my daughter and I was so helpful and explained everything to perfection. Hocus pocus cups were perfectly crafted and tasted even better. I have read some of the negative reviews on here and I think they are all bogus and they are from people that don’t appreciate something different. Go give this place...
Cute little horror themed ice cream shop. You create your own concoctions starting with a choc or vanilla soft serve base. Choose mix in or toppings and they make it for you. They also have plenty of seasonally themed combinations to try out. The ice cream itself tasted just fine, not overly great and not bad also. I have attached an image of the main menu, atmosphere, and an ice cream example. We drove past it at first because the place has no large exterior sign just the name...
You May Also Like
Tatsumaki Ramen & Lounge - 1300 12th Ave SE STE 230
![]()
Sushi, Sushi Bar, Ramen, Vegan, Vegetarian
Taco Bell - 1201 E Lindsey St
![]()
Fast Food, Mexican
The atmosphere inside is super fun, a continuous homage to a ton of classic horror franchises. Those unfamiliar with such might find it a tad creepy, but for me this was just good, solid fun.
The horror-themed ice cream recipes are right on the money, with a number of the names being really fun homages to the franchises themselves. They even...