Coney Island

Name: Coney Island
Address: 428 W Main St, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma, 73102, US
Telephone: (405) 239-8568
Price range: $
Rating: 3.9

$ • Hot Dogs, American

Hours:
428 W Main St, Oklahoma City
(405) 239-8568

About Coney Island

Coney Island is a downtown OKC restaurant known for its reasonably priced, straightforward cheese dogs. The single waitress provides great service, handling multiple orders with a diner waitress personality. The restaurant has an old country atmosphere where customers walk up to place orders before taking their food to the table. While some may find it a bit unclean, others appreciate its vibe and consider it a hidden treasure for a cheap meal. Notably, the red hot dogs are similar to those served at JW Grill in Chickasha, accompanied by a slaw. The food is simple but great for lovers of a great dog, and the place also offers a bowl of chili, with or without cheese, diced onions, and chips. The establishment uses local supplier Schwab’s for brick chili and all meat wieners, and the chili served is homemade Greek-style, offering a slightly different but very delicious flavor. The buns are fresh and soft, and the hot dogs are loaded with meaty chili and shredded cheddar, served piping hot and full of flavor. It is a place for hot dogs, chili, frito chili pies, and Greek spaghetti with chili. The decor is modest but tolerable, and the atmosphere has that old-school charm with worn booths and football schedules on the walls. The place is cash only and has fast service, great prices, and an unforgettable local experience. Customers often praise its unique charm, atmosphere, and the best chili in the state, making it a memorable stop for those seeking comfort food with personality.