Mary Eddy's Dining Room

server was bottom rung - barely got water, and not the bottled water we asked for, failed to put in our appetizer order with barely an apology. Food was okay - not great. Hoped for a very nice meal and experience, but it turned out to be run of the mill.

Excellent food, excellent service, and the best tiramisu I've ever had!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Food and service are always wonderful- any time I have friends visit OKC we make Mary Eddys part of the itinerary!

Everything we had here was AMAZING!! Beautiful atmosphere and an amazing waitress named River who took great care of us! Definitely recommend!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The food was probably my favorite thing, it was absolutely divine! My friend and I said mmmm after every bite😂. The waitress, Melissa, gave us enough time to look at the menu and had the perfect balance between checking in on us and letting us have our conversation. The dessert was great - Tiramisu parfait😍. It was my first time there and I will definitely return soon☺️

Such a beautiful date night spot! The fettuccine was delicious. Would definitely come back for dinner or a night cap at the bar.

My wife and I went to Mary Eddy’s for a local date night, and we absolutely loved it. The restaurant has such an intimate, cozy atmosphere with a great vibe — perfect for a night out. The ambiance and service were spot-on, and the food was excellent from start to finish. Definitely one of the better date night spots in OKC. We’ll be back for sure!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I only had dessert and cocktails at the bar but all was phenomenal! Wine was fab, and so was my dirty martini. Service was top notch!

Mary Eddys was amazing!! My husband and I went for our anniversary dinner and it was perfect. The food was so so good, the noodles were cooked so well they felt like they were melting in my mouth, the alfredo sauce didn't taste like every other alfredo, the chicken we added to it wasn't over crispy or dry. The rigatoni was overall a 10/10, the sauce wasn't too overwhelming, the meat tasted amazing, again the noodles were spectacular. The atmosphere was amazing, the whole building is super beautiful as well as the interior designing. My table was so cute, the desert was amazing, we were a little biased to be drinking espresso and having ice cream at 7pm, I am so glad we picked that desert. It was amazing.

Our server Katren was so very attentive without being intrusive. The food and drinks were excellent. The music was quite loud but Katren asked the manager, and he lowered the volume to a pleasant conversation level. Shout out to Natalie. We also had brunch the next morning and our server Bri was amazing. Have good advice on food choices. Appreciate Sooner, the manager too.

Mary Eddy's has become our go-to for Italian food. My Blush Negroni was so delicious as was the Caesar salad and the rigatoni. My husband had the lasagna (his usual order) and he said it was one of the best he has had. We finished with the carrot cake ice cream sandwich. Our server was excellent and the atmosphere was perfect.

Service was excellent and food was amazing. Everything from beginning to end was fantastic.

We didn't get anything to eat, we sat at the bar for some drinks. The service was great drinks were great.

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Emily the bartender was fabulous, from the bar to our seating, food and drink, the entire experience was tier 1.

The service was amazing! The dishes are unique and delicious! We visited for Sunday brunch. The blue berry pancakes were the biggest hit!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5