17 Best Italian Restaurants near Sand Springs

“A slice of magic in the Tulsa region. Best tiramisu, banana foster, pasta dishes.
Michael Lowry is such a great ancillary with his music that perfectly fits the mood, and creates a fine dining experience.

What's especially cool is how the young staff are trying to excel in different dishes and end up with like, the best tiramisu I've ever had, or the best banana foster, etc etc.
Truly a satisfying dining experience.“

“Delicious and generous portions of food! I love their Salmon Piccata and bread dipped in their olive oil. Yum!“

“Mazzio's gets four stars cuz they have a salad bar buffet that I really enjoy I think the pizzas are just okay I don't like that they don't put much sauce on them and the sauce they do put don't have much flavor and that's a major key for me when it comes to pizza. The staff is nice enough it's okay and the atmosphere is just like a pizza place nothing special“

“Ok so out of all the simple Simons from hominy, mannford, tank n tummy, this one in sand springs or Prattville is the best hands down absolutely the best. Will definitely be going back again. Is a carry out simple Simons no dining in... But best one around.“

“I don't know who was crafting the pizzas the night of Aug 14th, 2025, but they need to be recognized for their outstanding service and care for the food they've prepared. I worked a very long and hard day and my wife had a ordered Mazzio's before I got home without telling me and when I opened the pizza box it was like I was witnessing a glimpse of heaven. The pepperoni pizza was made so well I don't think I've ever seen a better pie. The slices were all perfect and the pepperonis were laid so perfect and portioned just right, made quickly yet efficiently. Upon that first bite you could tell the cheese and sauce was precisely and skillfully placed as well. The thin crust perfectly baked to a delicious crispy crunch on the edges with Zero air bubbles making it look so beautiful. Truly an outstanding masterpiece and such a treat to enjoy. I don't usually write reviews like this, but I couldn't just let this pass without mentioning. Excellent job pizza guy or girl. Thank you so much for making my night that much better. 🍕😎“

“Wonderful meal yesterday at Prossimo Ristorante. The food was fabulous. (Fresh ingredients make such a difference.) Our waiter Allen was knowledgeable, personable, and attentive. Great experience!!“

“The pollo and gorgonzola alfredo was delicious. The alfredo was rich and creamy with a hint of gorgonzola but not overpowering. I was afraid it was going to be like eating a chunk of gorgonzola but it wasn't at all. We started with the complementary bruschetta pieces which had so much delicious garlic on the bread it was like a piece of heaven. The tomatoes were nicely seasoned with balsamic vinegar but it was just enough to give a great flavor. Crab cakes were meaty, flaky, and tender. They were also a hearty size so next time I may have to partake of them as the entree.“

“We hosted our corporate holiday event at IlSeme. Everything went as expected and beyond. The food options were so fresh, flavorful and different; everyone loved it! The staff was attentive and very helpful. 100% recommend.“

“Great food, great service. Definitely will return.“

“Hands down, the best pizza I’ve ever had. Is it worth driving 1–3 hours? Yes. Yes it is. I’d drive through a thunderstorm, uphill, both ways. The pizza? Out. Of. This. World. Like, “did NASA make this?” good. The vibe? Immaculate. And there’s a playground out back so the kids can burn off their sugar high while you contemplate how something so cheesy could make you cry. You think I’m joking, but if you wanna witness a grown man weep with joy over a slice—this is the place. Welcome to your new pizza standard. Everything else is just bread with an identity crisis.“

“Always well staffed, clean/good looking restaurant,,excellent service and great food!“

“Had lunch today, first time in their new location. Very very nice. The house salad could have been a meal in itself but we also had a pasta dish. Still great food and excellent service.“

“The food was amazing, relaxing atmosphere, and great service too. I highly recommend this restaurant.“

“We came for the first time tonight The food was great The service was fantastic!!!!!!! Our waitress made my whole night!“

“Good pizza and clean. Went on a Saturday for lunch. Tables were wiped down and the salad bar had been cleaned recently. Got an order of cheese dippers and a medium pizza to share. Chicken bacon Alfredo pizza was good, but we forgot to get onions on it, so they gave us some from the salad bar. Would go again! They do have a buffet on weekdays for lunch and have added a Saturday night buffet as well if interested.“

“We recently visited our local Simple Simon’s Pizza and were blown away by the improvements since Chad, the new manager, took over. The restaurant has always had delicious pizza and a cozy atmosphere, but now everything runs even more smoothly!

Chad goes above and beyond to make sure every customer feels welcome. He’s friendly, attentive, and really cares about making the experience great. The team seems happier too—everyone was super helpful and quick to check in on us. The pizza was hot and fresh, and the toppings were piled high, just the way we like it!

If you haven’t been by in a while, you’re definitely missing out. The place feels more vibrant and welcoming than ever, and it’s clear that Chad’s leadership is making a big difference. Keep up the awesome work! Will be coming back!“