37 Best Italian Restaurants in Tulsa

“Wonderful meal yesterday at Prossimo Ristorante. The food was fabulous. (Fresh ingredients make such a difference.) Our waiter Allen was knowledgeable, personable, and attentive. Great experience!!“

“Outstanding wine dinner last night! 4 course meal with wine pairing was a delightful event. Great food, great wine, fantastic atmosphere, and wonderful staff. Highly recommend! We will be there for the February one! ❤️“

“We had a party of five and everything we ordered was amazing! They were very accommodating to my food allergy and our waitress did an awesome job!“

“We hosted our corporate holiday event at IlSeme. Everything went as expected and beyond. The food options were so fresh, flavorful and different; everyone loved it! The staff was attentive and very helpful. 100% recommend.“

“Visiting Tulsa from out of town; my group wanted pasta and saw Gambill’s had great reviews. We loved everything we ordered from the ricotta balls, to the pasta dishes, to the tiramisu! We will definitely return when we are in Tulsa again!!“

“We dined at Ti Amo after a few years away and I have to say it was the best meal I’ve had at a restaurant in a long long time! I had the rib eye and it was cooked perfectly, the mashed were awesome and green beans had the best flavor I have ever tasted. Of course the service was on point and the ambiance is warm, comfortable and classy! Mehdi and his team do an awesome job - we highly recommend Ti Amo for your next night out!!!“

“Always well staffed, clean/good looking restaurant,,excellent service and great food!“

“kayla is the best! so attentive friendly and fast. i never had to ask for a refill even on my soup and salad. she was very kind in helping me pick out what i could and couldn’t eat on my vegan diet. if you’re ever dining in, ask for kayla!! she goes above and beyond, so helpful considerate and courteous. she made my experience the best. thank you kayla :)“

“Pizza was delicious. Peach Italian ice with some vanilla honey on top is crazy good and their Oreo is out of this world 😭 they let me customize my Shirley temple float to cherry pineapple Italian ice and it was sooo refreshing ! The root beer float was so creamy it was almost like a milkshake def worth a try !“

“The pollo and gorgonzola alfredo was delicious. The alfredo was rich and creamy with a hint of gorgonzola but not overpowering. I was afraid it was going to be like eating a chunk of gorgonzola but it wasn't at all. We started with the complementary bruschetta pieces which had so much delicious garlic on the bread it was like a piece of heaven. The tomatoes were nicely seasoned with balsamic vinegar but it was just enough to give a great flavor. Crab cakes were meaty, flaky, and tender. They were also a hearty size so next time I may have to partake of them as the entree.“

“Just had to mention the manager of this Olive Garden, Marvin. He was exceptional and was completely involved with the serving, cleaning, and seemed to keep a positive moral even when super busy. Always had a smile. Love to see managers involved instead of barking orders.“

“Good food at a decent price.“

“We came for the first time tonight The food was great The service was fantastic!!!!!!! Our waitress made my whole night!“

“My husband’s and I’s favorite late night restaurant for years now.“

“Hands down, the best pizza I’ve ever had. Is it worth driving 1–3 hours? Yes. Yes it is. I’d drive through a thunderstorm, uphill, both ways. The pizza? Out. Of. This. World. Like, “did NASA make this?” good. The vibe? Immaculate. And there’s a playground out back so the kids can burn off their sugar high while you contemplate how something so cheesy could make you cry. You think I’m joking, but if you wanna witness a grown man weep with joy over a slice—this is the place. Welcome to your new pizza standard. Everything else is just bread with an identity crisis.“

“The service is impeccable and the food is delicious!!“

“The food is amazing the salad is to die for❤❤❤“

“For the most part hideaway is a good place to eat. But my visit last night was no so good. We set down ordered our drinks and appetizers. My wife had to remind our waiter to bring me my beer. He then took our pizza order. Our appetizers arrived warm not hot like they had been setting on the counter too long. We eat them and just thought they are a little busy, no harm. 20 min later our pizza was brought out. The crust was warm and the toppings were cold. We told our waiter and he went and got the manager who said do you want to box it up and take it home and warm it up? I told him no and he came back I will give it to you for free. I again said no I will pay for my beer, wife’s drink and raviolis. The manager would hardly make eye contact with my with and I and when he laid the bill on the table he said sorry as he walked off. The waiter wasn’t much better instead of playing games with the table behind us he should have been keeping a eye on our orders. I will continue to eat at hideaways just not the one on S. Memorial.“

“The food was amazing, relaxing atmosphere, and great service too. I highly recommend this restaurant.“

“Tasty and well worth what we spent and had a very good time together no long wait and a very kind well mannered gentleman for our waiter. Everything was great we will be back no doubt -delicious!“

“Had lunch today, first time in their new location. Very very nice. The house salad could have been a meal in itself but we also had a pasta dish. Still great food and excellent service.“

“I had a small order of cheese dippers with pepperoni and 10 boneless buffalo wings. i started out with the cheese sticks, and after I finished them, I was still hungry so I bought a 5 piece order of boneless wings with the mild buffalo sauce. The wings were so good that I had to have another order. I jokingly asked the guy who took my order if the sauce had any crack in it, who I made him laugh. This location has a nice cozy vibe, and is quite pleasant.“

“We recently visited our local Simple Simon’s Pizza and were blown away by the improvements since Chad, the new manager, took over. The restaurant has always had delicious pizza and a cozy atmosphere, but now everything runs even more smoothly!

Chad goes above and beyond to make sure every customer feels welcome. He’s friendly, attentive, and really cares about making the experience great. The team seems happier too—everyone was super helpful and quick to check in on us. The pizza was hot and fresh, and the toppings were piled high, just the way we like it!

If you haven’t been by in a while, you’re definitely missing out. The place feels more vibrant and welcoming than ever, and it’s clear that Chad’s leadership is making a big difference. Keep up the awesome work! Will be coming back!“

“This is the best Mazzios I have found. They are consistently on point. The pizzas are always hot and have the right amount of sauce on them. The staff is very friendly and goes out of their way to take care of their customers. We live in Jenks, and drive across the river to go to this specific Mazzios.“

“I've been getting pizza here for the last three years. The last two times(last night and last week) I've gotten a cheese pizza and y'all keep burning my pizza and putting the sauce closer to the crust than in the middle so pls put the laddle in the center of the pie whenever you sauce the dough then spread it out to the edges, super easy! I used to work at Andolinis, I promise it's easier than it looks. 😉 Just don't burn people's cheese pizza, even IF it's only a cheese, it's literally my favorite pizza ever. I still ate it and enjoyed it, just less burnt and more sauce in the middle. Thanks, darlings! 💜❤️💜❤️💜❤️💜❤️💜❤️“

“The guy working the window is always slammed, this location stays busy & I visit it regularly as it is across from my work, he always has a smile on his face and goes above and beyond to make sure we’re not inconvenienced by a wait, he deserves a raise for sure.“

“Mazzio's has gone downhill over the past few years, to the point where we decided not to go anymore. However, we visited The Farm location today. Mazzios is in the middle of revamping each of their restaurants. They are currently whipping this location into shape and doing a great job of it! Our experience was fantastic, and we will be back. So happy the old Mazzios seems to be making a comeback!“

“Mazzios is one of my favorite pizza joints.
Nice selection of foods like salads or subs+fries and of course Pizza, is a semi Pricey place but it's nice. Normally do pickups here and staff are quick and friendly. Parking varies depending on day/time but normally a spot or two is open

When you arrive early there's a bench you can rest on and wait which is very nice, however being a light dude the bench slowly bends into place and honestly is seen better days and Is ready to be replaced. Plus side, outlet is right behind it and pretty useful while you wait for your order and can charge your device or such.
.
Inside is very nice and cozy with a nice smell of pizza, subs, fries etc.“

“Order 30 minutes in advance for pick up. Arrive at the location and they tell me it will 8+ minutes before my order is ready. This has happened to me several times at this location and I eat here at least once a week. Very disappointing when one is on his lunch hour and has to wait half that time to get their meal.“

“We were very happy with everything! Atmosphere, our waiter was great ! our food was fabulous and prices were great !! We will definitely visit again !!“

“My pizza was good. No complaints. I ordered on 04/22/26 order #29. Driver and cooks did a great job. My question is what happened to the original crust? Its not the same as I remember, but it was still good. I had a 9 year hiatus in military and didn't order for a couple of years. The original mazzios crust was different.“

“Mazzios delivers not only a great buffet at a fair price, but the positive attitudes of the employees makes this location a pleasant experience. From being greeted the second you walk through the front door to the ease of ordering, plus the overall taste of the buffet items will make you want to come back time and again. The variety of pizza and a fully stocked salad bar are all you need to enjoy for your dining experience. 😊 Laura and her team dish out whatever pizza your craving per request. Comfortable n a relaxing atmosphere will have you coming back. There is wheelchair access n bathroom accessibility for disabled patrons. Thank you Mazzios! 👍“

“The food was amazing the manager waited on us and let me tell you he made the experience for us celebrating our anniversary here was everything we would have hoped for our waiter recommended so many phenomenal dishes for us to try hands down must try and we will be back“

“This is my favorite mazzios hands down. Everyone is so nice and sweet. My food is always fresh and hot. This mazzios can get my business everytime

Vegetarian options: They have a veggie pizza

Dietary restrictions: They have diabetic options which is so great cause my husband deals with it. Alot of times he has no clue wat to eat but he does with mazzios on 39th n garnet

Parking: Great parking and even drive thru

Kid-friendliness: Very kid friendly.“

“THIS PARTICULAR MAZZIOS OFF EDISON AND GILCREASE IN NORTH TULSA IS THE ABSOLUTE BEST MAZZIOS IN OKLAHOMA, I STARTED GOING THIS EARLY SUMMER IN JUNE 2023, WHICH AFTER THE FIRST PIZZA MYSELF & MY BOYFRIEND HAVE BEEN HOOKED EVER SINCE, THE STAFF HAS ALWAYS BEEN FRIENDLY, AND A WELCOMING ATMOSPHERE WHICH THERE EMPLOYEES ACTUALLY SMILE AND IF THEY AREN'T SMILING THERE STILL SHOWING CUSTOMERS THERE FRIENDLY SIDE, OH AND THEY ACTUALLY WORK AS A TEAM AND ACTUALLY LIKE TO BE AT WORK, AND THE PIZZA ITSELF HAS BEEN FRESH AND THE BEST MAZZIOS I'VE EATEN OUT OF EVERYONE OF THEM WHICH WE'VE EATEN AT I BELIEVE ALL OF THEM, WE LIVE IN SAND SPRINGS OUT BY COYOTE TRAIL, YET WE DRIVE TO PICKUP AT MAZZIOS OFF OF EDISON IF WE CAN'T GET A DELIVERY SERVICE TO DELIVER TO US BUT WE 95% OF THE TIME USE PICKUP, I JUST WANTED TO POST THIS BECAUSE OUT OF ALL THE LAZINESS,HATE, PEOPLE HAVING NO MANNERS OR NO FAITH IN HUMANITY NOW DAYS,ITS REFRESHING TO SEE A SMALL BUSINESS HAVE IT RIGHT FOR ONCE AND ITS BEEN MULTIPLE TIMES WE'VE EATEN HERE IN PAST 9 MONTHS SO ITS BEEN 100% EACH TIME.“

“Delicious and chill environment“