Cutest little place!!! Got the crime brûlée gelato and am blown away! Very fast and good service!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gelato
Mason Newark
Neat little Gelato spot in downtown Stillwater.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Gelato
Katie Cobbs
I've been here three times and honestly the flavors that the owner comes up with absolutely blows my mind every time I go in. The layout is very cute as is the theme they have. Can't recommend this place enough!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
IM Burgin
Too many flavors to choose from to get just one. So narrowed it down to three choices, actually I think we'll a a bigger cup next time to get more its so good. You know that sound when you scrape the bottom of the cup to get ever drop when somethings really good...need I say more
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Katelyn Young
Truly a hidden gem. If you are a coffee snob like me, they have the best coffee roast I’ve ever had! We bought a package of roasted coffee beans and use it in our espresso maker at home.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Barbara Price
They have the best gelato! I can’t praise them enough. I go there every time I pass through Stillwater.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gelato, Double Chocolate and Creme Brulee
Brittany Thompson
Always the best gelato we’ve ever enjoyed! We happened to be in Stillwater for Thanksgiving time and enjoyed tasting the seasonal flavors. They’re apple pie and earl grey flavors were incredible???. Not only that, we experienced THE BEST customer service! The very kind server and I were chatting, and she accidentally dished a different flavor than I requested. She felt badly, but I insisted it was perfectly fine and enjoyed what she gave me. As my party and I were walking out the door, she approached one of my friends and gave them a cup of the flavor I had originally requested?. How’s that for excellent customer service?! Love Blue Spruce, and we’ll be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gelato, Affagato
Emily Keenan
They don’t carry affogato anymore but the coffee gelato is a close second! We love going later at night and watching downtown through the big floor-to-ceiling windows or taking our gelato to-go and enjoying it on the bench outside. Our fave dessert spot in Stillwater!
Ryan McKenzie
This place is a-friggin-mazing! Beautiful decor. Awesome staff. They let me borrow a piece of tape. The Gelato is on point. Sweet lightbulbs. You gotta try this place.
Bettina Hudson
Very friendly service and wonderful Gelato along with sherbet for lactose intolerant etc .....My favorite is the rasberry sherbert
Best gelato in town.Love their vanilla, cookie butter, almond, dark chocolate, and coffee gelatos
Rebekah King
Service and coconut gelato was fabulous! ?
Amy Suchodolski
Delicious gelato and sorbeto! Key Lime Pie is a must!
Valerie Raney
Introduced my son to Gelato two weeks ago. Blue Spruce is now on our must stop shop list. We go everytime we are in Stillwater. My son loves the strawberry gelato, the lemon is very clean and refreshing, stole some of my husband's no bake cookie flavor today ..OMG! If you like no bake cookies, the no bake cookie gelato is amazing!!! Highly recommend. Staff is super nice and the shop is always clean.
Daniel
To the ownership,3rd time is not a charm!Last evening I brought family, that was in from out of town, to your little shop. …Always wanting to share the “best of Stillwater”!I, we, waited patiently in line, starting outside the open garage door at the side walk, I bragging on and explaining what your Avalanche was.By the time we got up to the counter to make those orders of, what would of been, “5” Avalanche’s, (which I know to be your most expensive offering) and a few cups of gelatos,basically was ask to step aside and allow the line behind us to go ahead with their orders. I assume I would of stood there waiting all evening, because as the line started to shorten people would then trickle in and lengthen the line again. Some of my party did go ahead and changed what they actually were wanting, to satisfy your “single” employee for the evening! All the while, those sitting there in our group, empty handed, we’re there to experience an Avalanche!Finally after some length of time, the line died down, my party finished with their gelato’s, others of us still empty handed. Now it could of been my choice to go up to the counter and order one to go, which we did not. I would of thought the girl behind the counter might “get our attention” and ask if she could help us now… no it was more important for her to text or call someone staying in the back room until we left.All that to say, first of all, I blame you the owner for not staffing your place of business with a second person, especially on a Friday evening. You should make a BIG side note on the menu board that Avalanches are “ONLY AVAILABLE WHEN THERE IS NO LINE!”This is the forth time, in many, to come into your establishment asking specifically for an Avalanche, that there have been service issues.One time I believe we were lied to, saying there was no more coffee in which to make an Avalanche, I find that very hard to believe, you are a coffee establishment, with beans even on the shelf for sell!No problem, we left and came back another evening so our friends could experience what we have enjoyed many times in the past. When we did return, we were treated in discuss, by the employees actions the entire time the Avalanches were being made. We had just ask her to do an overwhelming task! On one another occasion, not long after that, we came in with some family that traveled through. That same employee treated us the same way, in discuss, for ordering Avalanches.Most of the time you have long lines, so as a single customer, this entire explanation to my experience may mean nothing to you.Blue Spruce is no longer on my list of highlights in Stillwater to experience. Being employed at OSU, you have lost my business, and the many colleagues, family, friends, that I would of treated at your establishment.Your business model and employees are in need of some serious improvement!
Cutest little place!!! Got the crime brûlée gelato and am blown away! Very fast and good service!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gelato
Neat little Gelato spot in downtown Stillwater.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Gelato
I've been here three times and honestly the flavors that the owner comes up with absolutely blows my mind every time I go in. The layout is very cute as is the theme they have. Can't recommend this place enough!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Too many flavors to choose from to get just one. So narrowed it down to three choices, actually I think we'll a a bigger cup next time to get more its so good. You know that sound when you scrape the bottom of the cup to get ever drop when somethings really good...need I say more
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Truly a hidden gem. If you are a coffee snob like me, they have the best coffee roast I’ve ever had! We bought a package of roasted coffee beans and use it in our espresso maker at home.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
They have the best gelato! I can’t praise them enough. I go there every time I pass through Stillwater.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gelato, Double Chocolate and Creme Brulee
Always the best gelato we’ve ever enjoyed! We happened to be in Stillwater for Thanksgiving time and enjoyed tasting the seasonal flavors. They’re apple pie and earl grey flavors were incredible???. Not only that, we experienced THE BEST customer service! The very kind server and I were chatting, and she accidentally dished a different flavor than I requested. She felt badly, but I insisted it was perfectly fine and enjoyed what she gave me. As my party and I were walking out the door, she approached one of my friends and gave them a cup of the flavor I had originally requested?. How’s that for excellent customer service?! Love Blue Spruce, and we’ll be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gelato, Affagato
They don’t carry affogato anymore but the coffee gelato is a close second! We love going later at night and watching downtown through the big floor-to-ceiling windows or taking our gelato to-go and enjoying it on the bench outside. Our fave dessert spot in Stillwater!
This place is a-friggin-mazing! Beautiful decor. Awesome staff. They let me borrow a piece of tape. The Gelato is on point. Sweet lightbulbs. You gotta try this place.
Very friendly service and wonderful Gelato along with sherbet for lactose intolerant etc .....My favorite is the rasberry sherbert
Restaurantji Recommends
Best gelato in town.Love their vanilla, cookie butter, almond, dark chocolate, and coffee gelatos
Service and coconut gelato was fabulous! ?
Delicious gelato and sorbeto! Key Lime Pie is a must!
Introduced my son to Gelato two weeks ago. Blue Spruce is now on our must stop shop list. We go everytime we are in Stillwater. My son loves the strawberry gelato, the lemon is very clean and refreshing, stole some of my husband's no bake cookie flavor today ..OMG! If you like no bake cookies, the no bake cookie gelato is amazing!!! Highly recommend. Staff is super nice and the shop is always clean.
To the ownership,3rd time is not a charm!Last evening I brought family, that was in from out of town, to your little shop. …Always wanting to share the “best of Stillwater”!I, we, waited patiently in line, starting outside the open garage door at the side walk, I bragging on and explaining what your Avalanche was.By the time we got up to the counter to make those orders of, what would of been, “5” Avalanche’s, (which I know to be your most expensive offering) and a few cups of gelatos,basically was ask to step aside and allow the line behind us to go ahead with their orders. I assume I would of stood there waiting all evening, because as the line started to shorten people would then trickle in and lengthen the line again. Some of my party did go ahead and changed what they actually were wanting, to satisfy your “single” employee for the evening! All the while, those sitting there in our group, empty handed, we’re there to experience an Avalanche!Finally after some length of time, the line died down, my party finished with their gelato’s, others of us still empty handed. Now it could of been my choice to go up to the counter and order one to go, which we did not. I would of thought the girl behind the counter might “get our attention” and ask if she could help us now… no it was more important for her to text or call someone staying in the back room until we left.All that to say, first of all, I blame you the owner for not staffing your place of business with a second person, especially on a Friday evening. You should make a BIG side note on the menu board that Avalanches are “ONLY AVAILABLE WHEN THERE IS NO LINE!”This is the forth time, in many, to come into your establishment asking specifically for an Avalanche, that there have been service issues.One time I believe we were lied to, saying there was no more coffee in which to make an Avalanche, I find that very hard to believe, you are a coffee establishment, with beans even on the shelf for sell!No problem, we left and came back another evening so our friends could experience what we have enjoyed many times in the past. When we did return, we were treated in discuss, by the employees actions the entire time the Avalanches were being made. We had just ask her to do an overwhelming task! On one another occasion, not long after that, we came in with some family that traveled through. That same employee treated us the same way, in discuss, for ordering Avalanches.Most of the time you have long lines, so as a single customer, this entire explanation to my experience may mean nothing to you.Blue Spruce is no longer on my list of highlights in Stillwater to experience. Being employed at OSU, you have lost my business, and the many colleagues, family, friends, that I would of treated at your establishment.Your business model and employees are in need of some serious improvement!