By far BEST pizza I would venture out and say in “Oklahoma” we’ve tried them all !! We are big time pizza heads and thankfully we finally found a pizza spot for when we’re home! Thank you Cindy’s pizza for exceptional pizza!!
Carolyn Coleman
We were in town for The Midsouth and felt so taken care of by Cindy and her crew- they were responsive and accommodating. The pizza was delicious and we will definitely be back next year.
Logan VonBokel
Cindy’s is a gem of a pizza joint. Couldn’t have asked for better service and food. DEFINITELY will order again.
tig sun
Best pizza in oklahoma, the first time i went in to order a pizza, my card would not work so Cindy kindly gave me a free one. I later payed her back. However I will only ever buy pizza from cindys now. Support local businesses.
Vincent Price
We ordered a pizza last night and they hooked us up!!! Prob the best pizza in Stillwater! We will be back!!
Alberto Sanchez
Best pizza ever. Wish they still had a there store closer to me but always love getting pizza here when coming to Stillwater
Andrew Roberts
Well the pie did not disappoint and the service (delivery) on a football night was fast!!! Thanx Cindy for a delicious pizza. ?
Food: 4
Service: 5
Mary Hogan
The best food and the nicest people! We went on a busy day and the customer service was still amazing. They were out of something we ordered so they gave us double of the substitute of our choice! The best people and service.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael Madsen
Top notch everything. Ordered a pizza w/pepperoni, sausage, and mushroom, very delicious and I didn’t feel bad after eating it like the other pizza places. Also got some cheesecake ???. Don’t get pizza from anywhere else in town, definitely come here. Best to order in advance because everything is hand made and cooked to order, all ingredients are proprietary and you can taste it. Will return!
Kid-friendliness: Dining area outside and cool vibe.
Wheelchair accessibility: Has a big ramp.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheesecake with Apple, Pepperoni Pizza
Kristina -
As a native NYer and former Chicagoan, I’m a pizza snob. My family is dairy-free and we’ve had to go to OKC or Tulsa for dairy-free pizza (or make it myself) until now! We kindly asked Cindy to carry vegan cheese and she agreed to give it a try. Her crust and sauce are absolutely incredible and we are very impressed. The cheese is Violife vegan mozzarella; it melts and stretches, and the taste is spot on. We are so happy to finally have a local option, and it’s amazing! ??
Update: the vegan cheese is no longer offered. ☹️ Luckily there’s another option in Stillwater now, but we wish it was an option at Cindy’s!
First time ordering. Was delivered by a very kind man with a smile on his face. Pizza, garlic knots, and cheesecake were all incredible. Strongly recommend.
This is always the best pizza in town! Friendly staff, quality ingredients, and consistently perfect every time. Blows Hideaway out of the water, this place is a hidden gem.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Build Your Own Pizza
Greg G
While staying at the Hampton Inn from Illinois on family matters, mistakenly tried ordering the 10" Garlic Bread appetizer as an entree in a larger size, then cancelled and ordered a 14" Veggie Pizza. I commented on the Lady's New England accent and she on mine from Midwest Illinois, both a long way from home. We were pleasantly surprised when Cindy's delivered the Veggie Pizza and included the Garlic Bread appetizer as complimentary! They were both great and we'll enjoy Garlic Bread appetizer all the way back to Illinois! Thank you Cindy for the New Hampshire Oklahoma Hospitality!
Wonderbod
Tucked away in a residential neighborhood on the south side, Cindy's has quietly put itself in the top tier of pizza places in a college town with a bunch of them. I'm shocked there are no Tripadvisor reviews, because every year they finish second to Hideaway in the pizza category when the paper does its annual best-of competition. When you share a town with Hideaway, second in that category is like winning it all. So, about Cindy's ... it is not a sit-down kind of place. They ship a ton of pizzas out the door, but it is entirely carry-out, delivery or wholesale to Homeland. Yes, you will see Cindy's pizzas in a cooler right inside Homeland's entrance. Their selection is not as broad as some other pizzerias, but it allows for something for everyone. You will want to be aware they do not open until 4:00 p.m., so don't count on them for lunch. Then finally, to the pies. The main point. Given that they do not offer a lot of the specialty pizzas Hideaway has, it might be best to compare them to Pizza West or Pizza Hut. A competent product at a competitive price. As it should be, since their facility is, well, humble. A trailer house, basically, that oddly faces away from the street. But don't be put off by the building. Remember, you won't be eating there. The pizza is as enticing as the trailer house is the opposite. If you do not opt for delivery you will be wowed by how hands-on the operations really is. You are getting artisan pizza right here in little old Stillwater.
By far BEST pizza I would venture out and say in “Oklahoma” we’ve tried them all !! We are big time pizza heads and thankfully we finally found a pizza spot for when we’re home! Thank you Cindy’s pizza for exceptional pizza!!
We were in town for The Midsouth and felt so taken care of by Cindy and her crew- they were responsive and accommodating. The pizza was delicious and we will definitely be back next year.
Cindy’s is a gem of a pizza joint. Couldn’t have asked for better service and food. DEFINITELY will order again.
Best pizza in oklahoma, the first time i went in to order a pizza, my card would not work so Cindy kindly gave me a free one. I later payed her back. However I will only ever buy pizza from cindys now. Support local businesses.
We ordered a pizza last night and they hooked us up!!! Prob the best pizza in Stillwater! We will be back!!
Best pizza ever. Wish they still had a there store closer to me but always love getting pizza here when coming to Stillwater
Well the pie did not disappoint and the service (delivery) on a football night was fast!!! Thanx Cindy for a delicious pizza. ?
Food: 4
Service: 5
The best food and the nicest people! We went on a busy day and the customer service was still amazing. They were out of something we ordered so they gave us double of the substitute of our choice! The best people and service.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Top notch everything. Ordered a pizza w/pepperoni, sausage, and mushroom, very delicious and I didn’t feel bad after eating it like the other pizza places. Also got some cheesecake ???. Don’t get pizza from anywhere else in town, definitely come here. Best to order in advance because everything is hand made and cooked to order, all ingredients are proprietary and you can taste it. Will return!
Kid-friendliness: Dining area outside and cool vibe.
Wheelchair accessibility: Has a big ramp.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheesecake with Apple, Pepperoni Pizza
As a native NYer and former Chicagoan, I’m a pizza snob. My family is dairy-free and we’ve had to go to OKC or Tulsa for dairy-free pizza (or make it myself) until now! We kindly asked Cindy to carry vegan cheese and she agreed to give it a try. Her crust and sauce are absolutely incredible and we are very impressed. The cheese is Violife vegan mozzarella; it melts and stretches, and the taste is spot on. We are so happy to finally have a local option, and it’s amazing! ??
Update: the vegan cheese is no longer offered. ☹️ Luckily there’s another option in Stillwater now, but we wish it was an option at Cindy’s!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
First time ordering. Was delivered by a very kind man with a smile on his face. Pizza, garlic knots, and cheesecake were all incredible. Strongly recommend.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Garlic Bread, Cheesecake
Pizza is fantastic and I order every chance I get
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheesecake with Apple
This is always the best pizza in town! Friendly staff, quality ingredients, and consistently perfect every time. Blows Hideaway out of the water, this place is a hidden gem.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Build Your Own Pizza
While staying at the Hampton Inn from Illinois on family matters, mistakenly tried ordering the 10" Garlic Bread appetizer as an entree in a larger size, then cancelled and ordered a 14" Veggie Pizza. I commented on the Lady's New England accent and she on mine from Midwest Illinois, both a long way from home. We were pleasantly surprised when Cindy's delivered the Veggie Pizza and included the Garlic Bread appetizer as complimentary! They were both great and we'll enjoy Garlic Bread appetizer all the way back to Illinois! Thank you Cindy for the New Hampshire Oklahoma Hospitality!
Tucked away in a residential neighborhood on the south side, Cindy's has quietly put itself in the top tier of pizza places in a college town with a bunch of them. I'm shocked there are no Tripadvisor reviews, because every year they finish second to Hideaway in the pizza category when the paper does its annual best-of competition. When you share a town with Hideaway, second in that category is like winning it all. So, about Cindy's ... it is not a sit-down kind of place. They ship a ton of pizzas out the door, but it is entirely carry-out, delivery or wholesale to Homeland. Yes, you will see Cindy's pizzas in a cooler right inside Homeland's entrance. Their selection is not as broad as some other pizzerias, but it allows for something for everyone. You will want to be aware they do not open until 4:00 p.m., so don't count on them for lunch. Then finally, to the pies. The main point. Given that they do not offer a lot of the specialty pizzas Hideaway has, it might be best to compare them to Pizza West or Pizza Hut. A competent product at a competitive price. As it should be, since their facility is, well, humble. A trailer house, basically, that oddly faces away from the street. But don't be put off by the building. Remember, you won't be eating there. The pizza is as enticing as the trailer house is the opposite. If you do not opt for delivery you will be wowed by how hands-on the operations really is. You are getting artisan pizza right here in little old Stillwater.
Loading...