8 Best Mexican Restaurants in Stillwater

Take a look at our favorite Stillwater Mexican restaurants.

PIBIL GRILL Meal Delivery • $
Eastend of HWY express Inn. Next to the swimming pool, 2313 W 6th Ave, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Burrito Bowl Mango Chicken & Green Enchilada Bowl
Diablo Quesadillas Quesabirria
Don Pibil Grilled Steak Tacos
Queso and Steak Tips
Combo Street Tacos
Chicken Bowl Beef
Parrillada Mixta
Plant Based Meat
Shredded Chicken
Grilled Chicken

“oooommmmggg the best burrito I've ever had in my life got full and still couldn't stop eating it definitely highly recommend“

4.8 Superb102 Reviews
Cafe Mona Mexican • $
211 N Perkins Rd ste 30, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Enchiladas Verdes Platter
Monas Breakfast Skillet
Chicken Chimichanga
Cheese Enchiladas
Street Corn Nachos
Breakfast Burrito
Chicken Enchiladas
Huevos Rancheros
Sizzling Fajitas
Arroz Y Frijoles

“I just visited Cafe Mona, located at 211 N Perkins Rd, Ste. 30, Stillwater, Oklahoma. It is the former location of Boba Fusion and is newly remodeled. I have wanted to check it out for some time because of the great reviews! I like the previous decor, but the new look has new possibilities! The new look is brightly lighted, with tables spaced appropriately. The waitress was new but was able to answer all my questions. We started with a Mango Mimosa! The Mimosa was not weak, but not super strong either; however, they only started serving alcohol yesterday. The Chips and Salsa were good, but the salsa portions could be larger. The tortilla chips are homemade and flour-based. Very good! Everything else was portioned great for me! The second drink I ordered was a Senorita Margarita with one extra shot; it was perfect! The quality of a margarita can make or break you! Regarding my palate, I think the best-frozen margarita in town is Mariachi Grill. However, it is important to note Cafe Mona is still waiting on their machine to make frozen margaritas, so we will have to wait to check them out! My meal was better than expected. I had the Alex Comal. Alex Comal is a house chili pineapple marinated in an Al pastor pork skillet, topped with white Queso, and served with cilantro lime white rice, black beans, and tortillas. It was served sizzling hot, and not only did not disappoint but exceeded my expectations. I cannot believe the restaurant was not full. I also tried a side of Plantains while I was there, and they were excellent! The service was excellent, and the waitstaff was friendly and had just the right amount of interaction. Students, this would be a great place to do a fundraiser for your organizations! There is Plenty of space, and I believe it is locally owned! Many places will allow you to have an event night to raise money. A good approach is to invite people to your fundraiser and ask the business to donate a percentage of those pretax sales back to you, usually 8-10 percent. It is worth asking. That is my two cents, and I will definitely return to check out the frozen margarita!“

4.4 Superb108 Reviews
Tacos Los Primos Mexican • $
2000 N Boomer Rd, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Al Pastor Taco Rice and Beans
Street Tacos De Carne Asada
Chips Salsa and Queso
Strawberry Mango
Cheese and Salsa
Guacamole Salad
Fajitas Double
Chile Colorado
Marinated Pork
5 Taco Salad

“this is my favorite place to eat tacos always a great staff always a great time!!“

4.5 Superb56 Reviews
Chico's Mexican Grill and Cantina Mexican • $
611 N Perkins Rd, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Chimichanga Lunch Chimichanga
Carna Asada and Beef Fajitas
Ground Beef Quesadilla
Enchiladas Supremas
Fajita Quesadilla
Colorado Burrito
Ice Ice Cold Beer
Chico’S Special
Chips and Salsa
Homemade Salsa

“Definitely the best Mexican restaurant in Stillwater. Definitely try anything with pineapple…you won’t be disappointed. Their fajitas are large enough to feed two people.“

4.1 Good120 Reviews
Saul's Grill Mexican • $
211 N Perkins Rd #27, Stillwater

“Best Burger in town!!! We had the grilled jalapeño and onion cheese burger!! Sooo Good!!! Can’t wait to try the Ribeye! Very nice people too!“

4.3 Superb18 Reviews
Fuzzy's Taco Shop Tex-Mex • $
305 S Washington St, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Shredded Chicken Burrito Bowl
Fajita Beef Burrito Bowl
Our Famous Chips & Queso
Shredded Chicken Nachos
Fajita Chicken Nachos
Breakfast Taco Plate
California Heat Taco
Kid's Cheese Nachos
Fajita Chicken Taco
Fajita Beef Plate

“The open area is great for sitting out in the sun and sunbathing if you can't speak Mexico then it's okay they will always have somebody toss the English out and about
The goods great and the drinks are even better

Vegetarian options: Mexican food does not taste good in the winter time but that just in my mind

Parking: Yeah all of still water has bad parking in my mind

Kid-friendliness: I'm telling you it's kind friendly

Wheelchair accessibility: It's not the best handicap parking but it is still do-able just got to go over a lot of bumps for them people“

4.5 Superb80 Reviews
El Tapatio Authentic Mexican Restaurant Mexican • $
825 S Perkins Rd, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Little Enchilada Rice & Beans
Molcahete Beans and Rice
Taco and Chile Relleno
Quesadilla and Flauta
Whole Tilapia Dorada
Chicken Fajitas
White Queso Dip
Chips and Salsa
Mixed Fajitas
Chimichanga

“Had lunch with grandkids here. They got exactly what they wanted and ate it all. Parents and grandparents food was delicious. They have a huge patio with fountain during the summer. My 2 year old grandson and I had a good walk after eating on sidewalk next to building to release some energy (for him)!!“

3.8 Good74 Reviews
La Carreta Mexican Bar and Grill Mexican • $
1919 N Perkins Rd, Stillwater

Customers` Favorites

Chimichanga
Tortillas

“We had dinner there tonight, and it was delicious. They have great homemade flour tortillas. Their chips and salsa are good. We also loved their cheese dip. We had the chicken fajita nachos and the Tahlequah Enchiladas, and both dishes were exceptional. The booths are comfortable, and the service was good. We will be back for sure.“

3.8 Good38 Reviews

You May Also Like