Andolini's Pizzeria Cherry Street

We tried this place based on local recommendation about our half marathon. It wasn’t busy yet we had to wait 20m for a table after waiting to be greeted. Jason the server was friendly but forgetful. Got the drink order wrong, forgot straws, forgot refills. We were so hungry and cold after running. After waiting 45 minutes play for a pizza he says he forgot our order and can we tell him again what we wanted. He said it was only him and one other firm. Waited 30 more min for two pizzas. No apology just that he wasn’t used to working that area, no discount. Asked for a manager said there wasn’t one. Got the bill wrong not once but twice, had to wait again. Maybe it was an off day, but we were expecting an awesome place, atmosphere, service and food.

Had it delivered to our downtown motel and the pizza was OUTSTANDING. Wife said best margherita pizza she ever had and that was hard to argue against.

Pizza was delicious! We ordered two and had them in minutes. Our drinks were subpar. I recommend tap and bottled drinks only! Two of our drinks tasted nothing like they were supposed to.

Amazing pizza!! Best I have eaten west of the Mississippi. Service was outstanding. Selections were incredible. Wish I lived closer.

Used my coupon for garlic knots & they were way overcooked & I was very disappointed, I did just trash them & waste of my time because I do not live close & had better things to do take care

The waiter was ok but the pizza puts people to sleep! All jokes aside, they put something in their pizzas to make people unusually tired! Not sure if it's loads of sugar in their sauce or if it something else, but for sure , Andolinis pizza will make you tired and unproductive after eating one slice! Don't eat here unless you got nothing else to do that day.

We had such a great time next door last night at Prossimo that we had to try out this place! The wife and I split the 14 in Demarco of Brooklyn and had two pieces left! Super tasty and high quality! And the homemade ranch sealed the deal!

Deliciously made pizzas and more. All ingredients made in-house. Have a beer or two while u wait on your pizza, and it only adds to the deliciousness of these pizzas. Also, FYI, some places call pizzas pie.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Bruschetta, Italian Sausage

Good pizza, parking available, ice cream shop across the street is very good.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Hands down, the best pizza I’ve ever had. Is it worth driving 1–3 hours? Yes. Yes it is. I’d drive through a thunderstorm, uphill, both ways. The pizza? Out. Of. This. World. Like, “did NASA make this?” good. The vibe? Immaculate. And there’s a playground out back so the kids can burn off their sugar high while you contemplate how something so cheesy could make you cry. You think I’m joking, but if you wanna witness a grown man weep with joy over a slice—this is the place. Welcome to your new pizza standard. Everything else is just bread with an identity crisis.

Absolutely everything was great except our server ignored my boyfriend when he spoke to her and then suddenly we had a new server after we reacted confused and shocked. Not sure what that was about. It certainly made us feel terribly unwelcome. Our new server was really nice, though. He gave us great suggestions that we tried, and he said he was Italian so of course it was delicious. This was my first time coming here so hopefully the next time is better. I have autism so experiences like that are super grating and uncomfortable.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 1

Great pizza with fresh mozzarella, basil and tomato sauce! Lunch specials are delicious and affordable. Wood fired oven makes a perfect crust.

Very unprofessional, booked a group here, someone told me the district manager would call me, I answered some many spam calls in a week waiting, walked in and somebody said 'we dropped the ball' sorry we can't accommodate you. If you have a group, go to Elgin park pizza.

Service: 1

Mediocre at best;my husband and I were visiting from Edmond over the weekend and decided to stop by for lunch. It cost $80 for two people - two drinks, an appetizer, and two entrees. Ridiculously overpriced for bland food. Could have easily gone to Olive Garden or Texas Roadhouse for half the cost and better quality food + complimentary dishes. We will not be returning and I do not recommend.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

This is Clemenzo. We liked it.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 3