The Original Coney Island

$ • American, Hot Dogs

Hours:
11332 E 21st St B, Tulsa
(918) 438-3089

About The Original Coney Island

The Original Coney Island has been a favorite spot for generations, serving up the best Coneys in town with a touch of nostalgia. Customers appreciate the long-standing tradition and the friendly service that has been consistent over the years. This excellent establishment is the exactly what you want, with original Coney, relish dogs, kraut dogs, Frito chili pie, and 3-way chili. The owner is awesome and really likeable, often talking with guests. The coneys are great, and the three way chilli is so far the best. Whether you've been a regular for decades or just discovered this gem, the soft and delicious food will keep you coming back. With a small town charm that has stood the test of time, this is the go-to place for a classic Coney experience.

Customers' Favorites

The Original Coney Island Reviews

4.7
130 ratings
Restaurantji Rating
5
89%
4
3%
2
3%
1
5%
Food
4.9
Atmosphere
4.8
Service
5.0

Share your opinion about The Original Coney Island

Restaurantji Rating

I've been eating here since 1976 - My favorite coneys in the world.

The best coneys and 3-way in Tulsa. My husband and I eat there frequently. The food, portions, and price are the best you'll find in the area. Highly recommend.

I ordered 8 8 coney's to go after tasting the Coney sauce and yes I asked to taste the sauce before ordering.well my wife who is picky got the Frito chili pie.and decided to order a large and small chili to go.well today my wife asked where did all the chili go and I had to tell her I ate all of it last night.so if you go and you should order Xtra to go.my first time there but won't be my last.uses real onions real cheese and you wouldn't believe the amount of fixing on the coney.i...read full review

Read All Reviews(130)

Ratings

Photos

Add a Photo
The Original Coney Island
The Original Coney Island
View All Photos

Hours

Monday 10:30AM - 5PM
Tuesday 10:30AM - 5PM
Wednesday 10:30AM - 5PM
Thursday 10:30AM - 5PM
Friday 10:30AM - 5PM
Saturday 10:30AM - 2PM
Sunday Closed
Updated on: